In one critical chiral RNS string sector, light-cone gauge in string theory leaves eight transverse directions. The Neveu–Schwarz sector massless states give eight spacetime bosonic polarizations. The Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra gives sixteen ground-state polarizations, split into two eight-dimensional spinor chiralities. The supersymmetric GSO projection keeps one chirality, giving eight spacetime fermionic polarizations. Without that projection the massless counts do not agree. Counting a chiral sector is distinct from tensoring left and right sectors into closed-string states.
Oscillator vacuum Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-11-05
An oscillator vacuum is annihilated by all positive-frequency oscillator annihilation operators. For a Ramond sector string this leaves a degenerate space on which the fermionic zero modes act through the Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra. Vacuum annihilation therefore does not select a unique spinor state.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2001 iii Paper 64 5 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Introduce anticommuting matter fields as worldsheet Majorana fermions, transforming as target-spacetime vectors and two-dimensional spinors. The RNS string pairs them with through worldsheet supersymmetry. In flat superconformal gauge the matter action is, up to the conventional fermion normalization,and the field equations split into left- and right-moving components. The supersymmetry constraints include both the stress tensor and the supercurrent, so unphysical polarizations are removed rather than interpreting every fermionic worldsheet component as a physical particle.
The possible spin structures produce two sectors. On the closed chiral circle, or the doubled open string, the Neveu–Schwarz sector has and half-integer modes . The Ramond sector has periodic and integer modes , including . Canonical quantization replaces the classical Grassmann variables by operators satisfyingIn particular obeys . This is the Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra in covariant form. Its ground-state space must carry a representation of the Clifford algebra of the target metric, and hence transforms as a spinor, not a scalar vacuum. Indeed the zero-mode Lorentz generators proportional to act on it as the spin representation. This is the essential mechanism converting anticommuting worldsheet matter into spacetime spinorial states.
The zero-mode supercurrent constraint on a Ramond ground state is proportional to . It becomesthe momentum-space Dirac equation. The Ramond level operator has zero intercept, so the ground state is massless. Exciting bosonic or nonzero fermionic oscillators gives tensor-spinor excitations; the Clifford ground-state factor is retained. In the Neveu–Schwarz sector there is no fermionic zero-mode degeneracy. Its ground state is a scalar and its excited states carry integer-spin tensor representations, despite the anticommuting oscillator construction. Thus worldsheet fermionic oscillators do not by themselves make every target-space state a fermion.
Consistent projection also matters. The GSO projection removes the NS tachyon and selects a definite Ramond chirality in the standard supersymmetric spectrum. At the critical dimension ten, the projected massless NS vector has eight transverse polarizations, while the projected Ramond ground state has eight physical spinor polarizations after the massless Dirac constraint and the Majorana-Weyl spinor conditions. The projection permits their organization into spacetime supersymmetry multiplets. The assignment of spacetime fermionic statistics is compatible with spinorial transformation, vertex-operator locality and the Spin-statistics theorem; it is not just a relabeling of the Grassmann variables in the classical action.
For a closed string the left and right sectors can be chosen independently subject to level matching and the consistent spin-structure sum. The NS-NS sector and Ramond–Ramond sector have bosonic spacetime representations; a pair of Ramond spinors produces integer-spin fields. The mixed NS-R sector and R-NS sector instead carry one spinor factor and yield spacetime fermions, including gravitino and dilatino states. Opposite versus equal chiralities of the two Ramond sectors distinguish the type IIA superstring theory and type IIB superstring theory choices.
Quantum consistency of this RNS matter-plus-gauge system requires : its matter central charge is , the reparameterization ghosts contribute and the commuting superconformal ghosts contribute , so the total is . Spacetime fermions arise through Ramond matter zero modes, their Clifford/spinor representations and the physical-state/projection conditions. The anticommuting gauge-fixing ghosts already present in the bosonic path integral are not such matter fields and do not create physical spacetime fermions.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 67 5 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
The RNS string adds worldsheet Majorana fermions to the coordinate fields . The new fields are spinors on the worldsheet but vectors under the target Lorentz group; this distinction matters when interpreting their oscillator states. In a flat target, a convenient Lorentzian convention for the free gauge-fixed action iswhere are two-dimensional gamma matrices. The bosonic and fermionic kinetic terms are related by worldsheet supersymmetry. Before fixing local worldsheet supersymmetry, one introduces a worldsheet gravitino along with the worldsheet metric. After superconformal gauge fixing, the residual matter constraints are the Virasoro constraints and the constraints generated by the superconformal current .
Each real worldsheet Majorana fermion contributes to the chiral central charge, while each coordinate contributes one. The reparameterization bc system contributes , and fixing local worldsheet supersymmetry also produces commuting superconformal ghosts of weights , with central charge . ThusIn light-cone gauge in string theory there are eight physical transverse coordinate fields and eight transverse worldsheet Majorana fermions.
On the doubled spatial interval of an open string, the two allowed fermionic periodicities areThey arise from the relative signs of the left-right fermion gluing conditions at the two ends. Thus the Ramond sector has integer-mode oscillators , including , and the Neveu–Schwarz sector has half-integer oscillators , , without zero modes. In either sector,A closed string has independent left- and right-moving periodicities, giving four sector choices rather than two.
The Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra isHence its ground states carry a Spinor representation of the Lorentz group. The zero-mode supercurrent constraint reduces on a ground state to the Dirac equation . In the Neveu–Schwarz sector the oscillator vacuum instead carries a scalar representation. Consequently the open string NS sector describes spacetime bosons, while the R sector describes spacetime fermions. Exciting a target-vector oscillator does not change this statistics assignment.
The string intercepts follow from the transverse zero-point energy. Per boson the integer-mode contribution is . Per fermion it is the negative of the corresponding half-sum. Since , the eight transverse pairs giveThus , , and the open string mass formula is . This distinguishes the lowest states explicitly:
- In the NS sector, the level-zero scalar is a tachyon with . At level , is a massless vector. The supercurrent and Virasoro constraints give and the equivalence . There are eight physical vector polarizations.
- In the R sector, the level-zero states are massless spacetime spinors satisfying the Dirac equation. Before the GSO projection, the two chiralities together give 16 on-shell polarizations; they split into the two eight-dimensional transverse spinor representations.
The supersymmetric GSO projection keeps odd oscillator fermion number in the NS sector. Defining so that the NS vacuum has , its projector isIt removes the scalar tachyon and keeps the massless vector. In the R sector, fermion parity contains the zero-mode chirality operator, so one may writeHere counts nonzero-mode fermionic excitations. On the ground states, this keeps one Majorana-Weyl spinor chirality: 16 real covariant components, or eight on-shell polarizations after the Dirac equation. The projected massless open-string states are an eight-polarization gauge vector and an eight-polarization gaugino. The compatible projected tower exhibits spacetime supersymmetry; unprojected worldsheet supersymmetry by itself did not eliminate the tachyon or equalize these massless counts.
For a closed string, both chiral zero-mode constraints must hold:This shifted closed-string level matching is particularly important in the mixed sectors. The lowest states and their spacetime nature are as follows.
- The NS-NS sector is bosonic. Before projection, is a scalar tachyon with . The GSO projection on each side removes it. The surviving lowest level is , with transverse states . Decomposing their tensor product into symmetric traceless, antisymmetric and trace parts gives the graviton, Kalb–Ramond field and dilaton, with physical polarizations.
- The RR sector is bosonic, since it combines two spacetime spinors. Its lowest states have and are massless. The two Dirac equations on the bispinor polarizations identify them with on-shell differential-form field strengths. After projection they supply 64 bosonic polarizations. The actual form degrees depend on the two chosen Ramond sector chiralities.
- The NS-R sector and R-NS sector are fermionic. Their respective lowest level-matched pairs are and , not two oscillator vacua. A vector tensored with a chiral spinor decomposes into its gamma-traceless vector-spinor and gamma trace. These give a massless gravitino and dilatino, with polarizations in each mixed sector. The vacuum pair would fail the shifted closed-string level matching, so it cannot be counted as a mixed-sector tachyon.
For type IIA superstring theory, the two R sector ground-state chiralities are opposite. The Ramond–Ramond potentials can be represented by , with transverse counts . The two mixed-sector gravitinos have opposite chiralities, and the ten-dimensional theory is nonchiral. For type IIB superstring theory, the two R sector chiralities agree; the Ramond–Ramond potentials are , with self-dual five-form field strength, giving . Its two gravitinos have the same chirality. Thus both projected type II theories have 128 massless bosonic and 128 massless fermionic polarizations and no tachyon, while their chiralities and form spectra differ.
If unoriented open strings are included in the complete theory, the supersymmetric example is type I string theory. Worldsheet orientation reversal projects the closed type IIB superstring theory spectrum and identifies the two mixed sectors; the surviving closed fields include the graviton, dilaton, a Ramond–Ramond potential , and one gravitino and dilatino. The open states form vector and gaugino multiplets with Chan-Paton factors; tadpole and anomaly cancellation select . This is an additional orientation projection, not part of the GSO projection itself. The heterotic string instead pairs one supersymmetric chiral side with a bosonic chiral side carrying an internal gauge sector; it does not have a Ramond choice on both sides.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2003 iii Paper 50 4 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Write the integrand, without its common overall factor, as . Keep each constant Grassmann variable on the left. For the first supersymmetry component, varying the bosonic term givesVarying its fermion term gives . The plus sign in the second term comes from moving the odd parameter past . The middle terms cancel and the rest form . The second supersymmetry component similarly gives . Hence, off shell,This proves the local total-derivative identity for rigid worldsheet supersymmetry; the action is invariant when the corresponding boundary flux vanishes and the transformation preserves the allowed fields. A constant parameter preserves a periodic boson and a periodic fermion. In a Neveu–Schwarz sector, however, is antiperiodic for constant and does not preserve the periodic boson. Thus the bulk identity does not supply a global constant supercharge in every spin sector. This is the spin-structure obstruction to constant worldsheet supersymmetry; the local superconformal formulation handles the different sectors consistently.
For independent field variations, integration by parts gives bulk termsThe equations of motion are thereforeFor variations vanishing at the temporal ends, the spatial seam term is proportional to the difference between its values at and ofThe bosonic part cancels for closed string periodicity, also in a fixed winding sector. For a real fermion impose and the same relation on its variation. Seam cancellation requires , so the two untwisted possibilities are periodic, (Ramond sector), or antiperiodic, (Neveu–Schwarz sector). The two chiralities of a closed string can choose these signs independently, giving R–R, NS–NS, R–NS and NS–R sectors. This discussion assumes the ordinary Lorentz-invariant untwisted boundary conditions of the flat theory.
The chiral equations and boundary signs give the following Fourier serieswhere in R and in NS. Thus integer or half-integer modes follow directly from the Fourier series monodromy. With the conventional string oscillator normalization their anticommutation relations and reality conditions areFor an open string the endpoint gluing identifies the two sets of coefficients, leaving one R or NS tower.
In ten-dimensional light-cone gauge in string theory, the eight transverse bosonic modes have positive integer level and each NS fermionic creator has a positive half-integer level. For the unprojected low levels of the open RNS string, all states through in the NS sector areThe antisymmetric index restrictions are consequences of fermionic anticommutation; the boson–fermion pair has all 64 choices. The displayed partitions exhaust levels at most . Here the NS normal-ordering constant of a string is .
In the R sector , and the zero modes satisfy . Thus generate the Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra. The unprojected ground states span a sixteen-dimensional transverse spinor space, . All states in the requested range areThere is no intervening half-level, since all nonzero R modes have integer level. Acting with the zero modes only moves within the ground spinor space and does not generate further independent copies.
The GSO projection keeps odd NS fermion-excitation parity, removing the tachyonic vacuum and the entire NS level. In R it keeps one eigenvalue of total fermion parity, whose zero-mode part is spinor chirality. It leaves eight massless spinor states. At R level one, the retained families are and , of opposite ground chirality, so there are states. The retained NS states are spacetime bosons and the R states spacetime fermions. Consequently the retained levels have at mass zero and at , with no tachyon.
Equality at every higher mass level follows from the standard Jacobi abstruse identity, or equivalently the equality of the transverse generating functionsThe left side counts the projected NS bosons, the right side the projected R fermions. Their common coefficients start . This consistent truncation yields spacetime supersymmetry; the bulk worldsheet symmetry alone would not remove the tachyon or impose the projection.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2005 iii Paper 54 4 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Use the critical ten-dimensional RNS string and light-cone gauge in string theory, leaving eight transverse bosons and eight transverse fermions. The bosonic oscillators have integer . In the Neveu–Schwarz sector the fermionic oscillators have positive half-integer , while in the Ramond sector the fermionic oscillators have integer , including zero modes. Their anticommutators are and . The level and mass formulas areBefore projection the NS ground state is a tachyon of mass squared . Its oscillator tower describes spacetime bosons. The Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra makes the Ramond vacuum a 16-dimensional spinor of , split into the two chiral eight-dimensional spinors. The Ramond tower describes spacetime fermions; there is no Ramond tachyon.
Choose the supersymmetric GSO projection. In the NS sector it keeps states with an odd number of fermionic creation operators, eliminating the zero-oscillator tachyon. In the Ramond sector it fixes the combined parity of the zero-mode chirality and the nonzero-mode fermion number. Thus the Ramond vacuum retains one chirality; adding an odd number of nonzero-mode fermions requires the opposite zero-mode chirality. The projected towers both have . Here the counts refer to oscillator polarizations for a single endpoint multiplicity; any common Chan-Paton multiplicity multiplies both counts.
At the first retained mass level, , the NS states are for , furnishing the eight polarizations of the ten-dimensional gauge vector. The Ramond ground state is one chiral spinor with eight physical polarizations. HenceThese form the massless supersymmetric vector multiplet.
At the next mass level, , the NS level is . The odd-fermion condition leaves exactlyTheir counts are , and . Anticommutation requires distinct indices in the third family. There are no other partitions of with odd fermion number, so these are all 128 bosons. They assemble into the massive little-group representations of dimensions 44 and 84: a traceless symmetric two-tensor and a three-form.
At Ramond level one, the only possibilities are and . The spinors and each have eight components and have opposite zero-mode chirality because the fermionic oscillator reverses the GSO parity. Consequently there are fermions. They form a gamma-traceless vector-spinor of the massive little group: a vector-spinor has components and its gamma trace removes 16. Therefore the first massive level of the open RNS string hasThis is the open-string mass normalization; the same chiral oscillator count used in a closed string would correspond to .
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 51 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
A Majorana spinor equals its transform under charge conjugation, so its spinor components are not independent of their conjugates. In a real two-dimensional gamma matrix representation it can be taken real, with anticommuting Grassmann variables as components. Each target index labels a separate worldsheet Majorana fermion; it is not itself a target-space spinor.
Use worldsheet signature and the real gamma matricesTake with . Define the chirality matrix with the chosen worldsheet orientation byIt squares to one and anticommutes with each gamma matrix. Chirality is its eigenvalue, selected by the chiral projectors. Its overall sign is conventional.
Writing , the fermion equation of motion becomesHenceThe first profile travels toward increasing , and the second toward decreasing . Thus the choice of chirality orientation realizes the requested worldsheet chirality and propagation direction correspondence; reversing the orientation interchanges the labels.
For the rigid worldsheet supersymmetry variation, let be a constant Grassmann-odd Majorana spinor. With the displayed conventions,The minus sign follows from . A second identity from the Majorana Grassmann bilinear interchange is . Keeping these Grassmann signs is essential.
The bosonic kinetic variation is . The two fermionic kinetic variations, using the two identities above, give the full resultFor the second equality use and symmetry of the second embedding derivative. No field equation has been used. Thus the variation is an off-shell total derivative:This is the rigid worldsheet supersymmetry boundary term. It vanishes when the boundary flux vanishes, for example on a closed worldsheet with compatible fields and variations. On a spatial circle, a constant supersymmetry parameter must also respect the chosen spin structure. Periodic fermions allow this rigid transformation; antiperiodic fermions and a constant parameter would give an antiperiodic and fail to preserve a periodic bosonic embedding. The local action identity remains valid, but global symmetry requires compatible boundary data. This is the spin-structure obstruction to constant worldsheet supersymmetry.
For the spectrum, assume the usual critical RNS string, physical-state constraints, a nonzero null target momentum, and the supersymmetric GSO projection. Analyze just one chiral sector. Its matter central charge is ; the bc system and superconformal ghosts contribute . Therefore gives the critical dimension of the RNS superstring . Light-cone gauge in string theory leaves eight transverse bosonic and eight transverse fermionic string oscillator directions.
In the Neveu–Schwarz sector, the normal-ordering intercept is . The massless level is and has statesThe GSO projection retains these eight transverse vector polarizations while removing the tachyonic ground state. They are spacetime bosons, although the creating string oscillator is a worldsheet fermion. In covariant language transversality and the longitudinal null-state quotient leave polarizations.
In the Ramond sector, bosonic and fermionic zero-point energies cancel, so and the ground states are massless. The eight transverse fermion zero modes obeyThis Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra acts on a sixteen-dimensional ground-state space. Its two chirality subspaces each have dimension eight. The GSO projection keeps one, an or spinor of , the rotation subgroup of the massless little group. These are spacetime fermions. Equivalently a ten-dimensional Majorana-Weyl spinor has sixteen real components before the massless Dirac equation reduces the physical polarization count to eight.
Consequently the massless chiral RNS spectrum after GSO projection satisfiesThe GSO projection is essential: without it, the transverse Ramond sector would retain both eight-dimensional spinor chiralities. These are counts for one chiral sector, not the tensor-product counts of the full closed-string spectrum.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 48 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The fields constitute an RNS string coupled to two-dimensional worldsheet supersymmetry. The zweibein and worldsheet gravitino impose constraints; they do not supply extra propagating string polarizations. Worldsheet diffeomorphisms, local frame rotations and Weyl transformations put the metric locally in conformal gauge, . Local supersymmetry together with super-Weyl symmetry removes the worldsheet gravitino, giving superconformal gauge . On a general closed worldsheet, moduli and spin structures remain and must still be summed or integrated over; gauge fixing is not a declaration that every surface is globally a flat cylinder.
Variation with respect to the metric and worldsheet gravitino before gauge fixing gives the stress-tensor and supercurrent constraints and . The remaining matter consists of free and their worldsheet fermions. In covariant quantization, these become the N=1 super-Virasoro algebra physical-state conditions: positive Virasoro and supercurrent modes annihilate a physical state, , and the R sector also has the zero-mode condition . Null gauge states are quotiented out. Equivalently, physical states are BRST cohomology classes, so BRST-exact operators do not represent additional physical states.
The diffeomorphism ghosts have central charge , while the bosonic superconformal ghosts have charge . Matter contributes . Therefore quantum gauge consistency requiresThis is the critical dimension of the RNS superstring. In light-cone gauge in string theory, choose nonzero , make linear in worldsheet time and set . The stress-tensor and supercurrent constraints solve for the longitudinal and oscillators. Only eight transverse bosons and eight transverse fermions remain, with positive norm. This explicitly eliminates the time-like and longitudinal unphysical states.
In a chiral sector the fermions have half-integral modes in the NS sector and integral modes in the R sector. The normal-ordering constant of a string is and . The GSO projection retains odd fermion-excitation parity in the NS sector, removing its tachyonic vacuum. In the R sector it keeps one chirality of the zero-mode spinor, with oscillator parity included in the projection. The Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra then leaves eight ground-state polarizations in light-cone gauge in string theory.
Worldsheet supersymmetry alone does not imply spacetime supersymmetry. The GSO projection makes the spinorial worldsheet currents mutually local with the retained vertex operators and pairs their NS and R states. More explicitly, let be an RNS spin field and the bosonized superghost scalar. The spacetime supercharges are generated byand similarly in the other chiral sector. The spin field has conformal weight , and its superghost factor has weight , so the current has weight one. Its operator products generate the spacetime translation operator; schematically . This is the spacetime supercharge from an RNS spin field. For type IIA superstring theory, the left and right Ramond projections select opposite ten-dimensional Majorana-Weyl chiralities, giving 32 real supercharges and a nonchiral spacetime theory.
The massless physical states are best counted with the transverse little group . Choose the left Ramond ground representation and the right one . ThenThe NS-NS sector supplies the graviton, Kalb–Ramond field and dilaton, with , and polarizations. The RR sector supplies a one-form potential and a three-form potential, with and polarizations. The mixed sectors supply two gravitinos of opposite chirality, each with polarizations, and two dilatinos, each with . Covariantly the dilatino has chirality opposite to its corresponding supersymmetry parameter; the two chirality sets are both present. Thus the massless type IIA spectrum hasThese fields form the massless type IIA supergravity multiplet.
For the first massive level of a chiral RNS sector, restore throughThe first positive value is one. The NS states therefore have level . A complete transverse basis after GSO projection isAll contain odd fermion-excitation parity. Their respective dimensions are , and , so the NS count is . These are the first massive GSO-projected Neveu–Schwarz states. The middle family decomposes into . Together the families assemble into the massive representations : a symmetric traceless rank-two tensor and a three-form, since and .
In the R sector, the first massive level is . If the retained right-moving ground spinor is , its two families areThe Ramond spinors have opposite zero-mode chiralities in these two families: inserting one fermionic oscillator reverses the oscillator contribution to the GSO condition, so the second family must use the opposite zero-mode chirality. Each family has states. HenceThese first massive GSO-projected Ramond states form the gamma-traceless vector-spinor representation of , of dimension . Its transverse branching is . The right-moving sector therefore contains bosons and fermions, a massive chiral superstring supersymmetry multiplet.
For the closed string, closed-string level matching requires the left and right shifted levels to agree. Both chiral sectors at this first massive mass have NS states and R states. The bosons lie in the NS-NS sector and RR sector, while the mixed sectors are fermionic. ConsequentlyTheir total is . A massive ten-dimensional state with 32 real supercharges and no central charges has sixteen fermionic creation operators in its rest-frame supersymmetry algebra, giving a long multiplet of this size. Thus the chiral equality, the four closed sectors and level matching are consistent with the first massive type IIA long supermultiplet, rather than merely matching an isolated number of right-moving states.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 iii Paper 306 4 ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The PDF's displayed zero-mode term has no derivative. Read literally, vanishes for classical Grassmann variables and supplies no zero-mode symplectic structure. The subsequent canonical-algebra requests therefore require the standard kinetic term . We use that intended correction explicitly; the rest of the displayed action fixes the nonzero-mode normalization.
The Ramond level operator, with vacuum-annihilating normal ordering, isThe canonical oscillator relations, for transverse indices , areThe hermiticity convention is and . The commuting bosonic zero mode is supplied by the center-of-mass momentum. For , define and . Their bosonic occupation numbers are and their fermionic occupation numbers are . Therefore, on the Fock space generated from an oscillator vacuum,Equivalently, creation operators raise the level by , since and . The zero modes commute with and do not change the level. The multiplier imposesso the states are massless. In the Ramond sector the bosonic and fermionic oscillator zero-point contributions cancel, consistently with the stated zero intercept. The massless ground states are spacetime spinors, as the Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra now shows.
Normalize . ThenLet . Each positive-frequency bosonic annihilator commutes with , while each fermionic annihilator anticommutes with it. Applying either annihilator to therefore gives zero. Thus all eight are oscillator vacua. For real , the hermitian operator satisfies , soThis proves the real independence of Clifford-generated vectors, and hence their linear independence over .
The same argument applies to the nonzero vacuum , because . It gives eight real-linearly independent oscillator vacua . They include itself, at . Products of two zero modes preserve vacuum annihilation just as products of one do.
For the chirality matrix , reversing eight anticommuting factors introduces . HenceMoving any through the other seven factors also gives . If , thenThe first collection has negative chirality; the second has positive chirality. If and have these respective chiralities, hermiticity gives , so they are orthogonal. Combining the two real-independent collections therefore gives at least sixteen real-linearly independent oscillator vacua, eight in each chirality.
The real qualification in the question matters: the particular eight vectors generated from an arbitrary complex need not be independent over . Nevertheless the dimension bound from paired Clifford involutions also follows from the full Clifford algebra. Define four commuting hermitian involutions , . Their joint spectral projections preserve the vacuum space, so it contains a nonzero common eigenvector . Multiplication by flips the eigenvalue of and leaves the other three eigenvalues unchanged. The sixteen products obtained by independently choosing whether to apply these four odd-indexed Gamma matrices to consequently have distinct joint eigenvalue quadruples. They are nonzero, mutually orthogonal oscillator vacua. Thus the unprojected vacuum space also has complex dimension at least sixteen, with eight states of each chirality in the minimal representation. A further chiral projection is an additional physical restriction, not part of the oscillator-vacuum conditions here.
Before the GSO projection, the Neveu–Schwarz sector has string oscillator levels , with physical multiplicities in ten-dimensional light-cone gauge in string theory. The eight transverse worldsheet Majorana fermions supply eight single states. Level one has eight states and pairs of distinct modes. Level has single modes, mixed boson–fermion modes and triples. Their squared masses are respectively . In the Ramond sector, the Ramond zero-mode Clifford algebra gives a sixteen-dimensional ground space. At level one, and each provide states, hence multiplicities at squared masses . No half-integer Ramond levels occur. The GSO projection keeps odd NS fermion number and one total Ramond chirality, giving bosons and fermions at zero mass, then of each at the first massive level.