Hessian criterion for a flex Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-10-25
For a plane curve defined by a homogeneous polynomial of degree , assume the field characteristic is different from two and is nonzero in the field. A smooth point of a variety is a flex exactly when the determinant of the homogeneous Hessian matrix vanishes there, provided its tangent line is not a component. Put the point at with tangent and . The homogeneous identities give and , so the determinant is . In the completed local ring, write the curve as a formal power series . Its linear coefficient is zero and its quadratic coefficient is . Vanishing of that coefficient is exactly intersection multiplicity at least three with the tangent, proving the criterion in these positive characteristics as well as in characteristic zero.
Translate the point to the origin of an affine chart and expand a local defining polynomial as . Its lowest nonzero total degree is the multiplicity. A smooth point of a variety has multiplicity one; a double point has multiplicity two. On a point blowup of a smooth algebraic surface, the total transform is the strict transform of an algebraic subvariety plus this multiplicity times the algebraic exceptional divisor.
Work on affine open subsets. Their coordinate rings are Noetherian rings and integrally closed domains. At a prime ideal of height of a prime ideal one, the local ring is a one-dimensional Noetherian local ring which is an integrally closed domain, hence a discrete valuation ring and therefore a regular local ring. At the generic point the local ring is a field, hence a regular local ring. For a brief justification of the one-dimensional local ring fact, take in a one-dimensional Noetherian local ring which is an integrally closed domain. Some ; choose the least such , and choose . Then , but . If , the determinant trick applied to the finitely generated faithful module would make integral over , a contradiction. Hence the ideal contains a unit and equals . Thus is principal. A one-dimensional Noetherian local ring with principal maximal ideal is a discrete valuation ring. Therefore a normal variety is regular in codimension one.
The ground field is an algebraically closed field, hence a perfect field, so having a regular local ring is equivalent to being a smooth point of a variety here. Moreover, the smooth locus of a variety is open, making the singular locus closed. If an irreducible component of the singular locus had algebraic codimension zero or one, its generic point would have a regular local ring by the preceding argument, a contradiction. Consequently every such component has algebraic codimension at least two.
One can read the numerical bound directly from chains of prime ideals, without identifying algebraic dimension with transcendence degree. For a prime ideal of height of a prime ideal at least two in an affine chart, append a chain below any chain in the quotient by . Its length increases by two. Thus . Since a nonempty affine open subset of the irreducible variety has algebraic dimension ,
For or , this means the singular locus is empty; take .
On an affine chart , the module of Kähler differentials is generated by symbols subject to -linearity and . It represents -derivations. These modules commute with localization, so their associated quasi-coherent sheaves glue to the Kähler differential sheaf . It is coherent: if and , then it has the finite presentation of a module
For a closed point , put with maximal ideal and residue field . The Zariski tangent space is , equivalently . A derivation kills constants and , so it factors through ; conversely every linear functional on defines such a derivation by the product rule. The universal property of Kähler differentials therefore identifies this space with
In particular, , the algebraic cotangent space.
A point is a smooth point of a variety when its local ring is a regular local ring; over this algebraically closed field this says . Tensor the finite presentation of a module above with . The tangent space is the kernel of the Jacobian matrix , hence has dimension . This proves the Jacobian criterion
For a smooth irreducible variety , choose at each point an invertible -minor and shrink the affine chart so that it remains invertible. Its relations eliminate of the generators of , yielding a surjection . At the generic point, its target has dimension : over a perfect ground field, a separating transcendence basis of the function field has differentials forming a basis. Equivalently this follows from the assumed density of the smooth locus. The kernel therefore becomes zero over the fraction field of the integral domain . As a submodule of , it is a torsion-free module, so it is already zero. Thus these maps give local isomorphisms with , proving local freeness of differentials on a smooth variety with rank .
For an affine chart , write and . The restriction of a module sheaf to a closed subvariety is . The Conormal exact sequence for Kähler differentials is
It follows from the generators and relations: passing to imposes precisely the additional relations for . The first map is well defined because lies in . Glue these exact module sequences, using exactness of localization, to obtain
In the final assertion, interpret locally principal subvariety as a proper local hypersurface. Its ideal on each chart is with . Since is an irreducible variety and reduced, is a non-zero-divisor, and , , is an isomorphism. These local rank-one descriptions make the conormal sheaf invertible.
Because is not contained in the singular locus of , there is a dense open subset of where both and are smooth varieties. At a closed point there, by the Krull principal ideal theorem. The tangent description then forces . Hence the conormal map is injective at the generic point of . Its kernel is a subsheaf of a line bundle on the integral variety , so it is a torsion-free sheaf; a torsion-free sheaf with zero generic fibre is zero. This proves conormal injectivity for a generically smooth Cartier divisor. If zero equations were allowed in the phrase locally principal, would be a counterexample to invertibility; the proper-hypersurface convention is essential.