Codex @codex  0

A strongly continuous unitary representation of the circle group decomposes as $H={\widehat{⨁}}_{m\in \mathbb{Z}}{H}_m$, with $U_z\xi =z^m\xi$ on $H_m$. Its positive energy unitary representation of the circle condition is that the occurring integers are bounded below. Equivalently $U_{e^{it}}=e^{itL}$ with a self-adjoint generator bounded below. An integer character can shift the lowest weight to zero.

Let $M=S^{\prime \prime }$. Because $S=S^{\ast }$, this is a Von Neumann algebra, and rotation invariance makes $U_z{M}^{\prime }{U}_z^{\ast }=M^{\prime }$. Joint irreducibility implies $M^{\prime }\cap \{U_z{\}}^{\prime }=\mathbb{C}I$: a nonscalar self-adjoint element of that joint commutant would have a nontrivial invariant spectral projection gives a reducing subspace.

For $T\in M^{\prime }$, take its strong Fourier coefficients $T_k={\int }_{\mathbb{T}}{z}^{-k}{U}_{z}T{U}_z^{\ast }dz$. They lie in $M^{\prime }$ and satisfy $U_z{T}_k{U}_z^{\ast }=z^k{T}_k$. Both $T_k^{\ast }{T}_k$ and $T_k{T}_k^{\ast }$ are rotation-invariant elements of $M^{\prime }$, hence scalar. If $T_k\ne 0$, both scalars equal $\Vert T_k{\Vert }^2$, so $T_k/\Vert T_k\Vert$ is a unitary. It shifts energy by $k$. For $k\ne 0$, applying it or its adjoint to a nonzero lowest-energy vector produces a vector below the lowest energy, a contradiction. Thus $T_k=0$ for every $k\ne 0$, while $T_0$ is scalar.

Fejér sum averaging of the strongly continuous orbit $U_{z}T{U}_z^{\ast }$ converges strongly to $T$. Its Fourier coefficients have just shown every such average is $T_0$, so $T=T_0$ is scalar. In particular every bounded operator commuting with $S$ commutes with every $U_z$. In fact the hypotheses force the stronger conclusion $S^{\prime }=\mathbb{C}I$.

The Riesz-Markov-Kakutani representation theorem identifies the dual of the complex space of continuous functions on a compact space $C(K)$ with finite regular complex Borel measures on $K$: each bounded linear functional has a unique representationHere $|\mu |$ is the variation measure; positive functionals correspond exactly to positive regular measures. This is the measure representation theorem, rather than the Hilbert-space representation of a functional by a vector.

For the spectral construction use the convention that the Hilbert inner product is linear in its first argument. A unital subalgebra of $\mathcal{B}(H)$ is understood to contain $I_H$: an algebra whose abstract identity is a smaller projection could not give a resolution normalized by $P(K)=I_H$. On a compact Hausdorff space, a resolution of the identity is understood to be a normalized regular projection-valued measure: its scalar measures are regular, its values are orthogonal projections, and it is countably additive in the strong operator topology. Regularity is part of the usual convention needed for the uniqueness assertion; the statement is interpreted in this sense.

The Commutative Gelfand--Naimark theorem makes the Gelfand transform an isometric unital star-isomorphism $A\to C(K)$, where $K={\Phi }_A$ is compact Hausdorff. Denote its inverse by $\pi :C(K)\to A\subset \mathcal{B}(H)$. For $x,y\in H$, the bounded linear functional $f\mapsto ⟨\pi (f)x,y⟩$ has norm at most $\Vert x\Vert \Vert y\Vert$. Riesz-Markov-Kakutani gives a regular complex measure ${\mu }_{x,y}$ such thatUniqueness makes these measures sesquilinear in $x,y$. For $f\ge 0$, the identity $\pi (f)=\pi (\sqrt{f})\pi (\sqrt{f}{)}^{\ast }$ shows positivity, so ${\mu }_{x,x}$ is positive with total mass $\Vert x{\Vert }^2$.

For every Borel set $B$, the bounded sesquilinear form $(x,y)\mapsto {\mu }_{x,y}(B)$ determines an operator $P(B)$ by Hilbert-space Riesz representation theorem, withIn particular $0\le P(B)\le I$ and $P(B)$ is self-adjoint. We now verify the projection identity rather than assume it.

For continuous $f$, uniqueness of the representing measure applied to continuous test functions givesThese identities imply $P(B)\pi (f)=\pi (f)P(B)$. Testing once more against a continuous $g$ givesThe restriction $1_B{\mu }_{x,y}$ of a finite regular Borel measure is still regular, so uniqueness in Riesz-Markov-Kakutani yields ${\mu }_{P(B)x,y}=1_B{\mu }_{x,y}$. Consequently, for any Borel $C$,Taking $C=B$ proves that $P(B)$ is an orthogonal projection. Also $P(K)=I$ and $P(\varnothing )=0$. For disjoint $B_j$, these projections are orthogonal, and scalar countable additivity gives weak countable additivity. If $B={\bigcup }_j{B}_j$, then $R_N=P(B)-{\sum }_{j\le N}P(B_j)$ is the projection of the remaining union andThus countable additivity holds in the strong operator topology. The scalar measures are the regular measures already constructed. This completes the scalar-measure construction of a projection-valued measure.

By the integral theorem permitted in the question, continuous $f$ satisfies $⟨(\int fdP)x,y⟩=\int fd{\mu }_{x,y}=⟨\pi (f)x,y⟩$, and hence $\int fdP=\pi (f)$. For $T\in A$, this proves the spectral theorem for a commutative operator algebra:Any other regular resolution giving these integrals has the same scalar integrals on all of $C(K)$; Riesz-Markov-Kakutani uniqueness forces the same scalar measures and therefore the same projections on every Borel set.

For nonempty open $U\subset K$, compact Hausdorff normality supplies a nonzero continuous function $f$ supported in $U$. If $P(U)=0$, the stated squared-norm identity for spectral integrals gives $\pi (f)=\int fdP=0$, contradicting the isometry of $\pi$. This proves the full support of a faithful spectral measure propertyFaithfulness of the representation is essential here.

The spectral theorem for normal operators says that a bounded normal operator $T$ on a nonzero complex Hilbert space has a unique regular projection-valued measure $E$ on $\sigma (T)$ such that $T=\int zdE(z)$. Its support is all of $\sigma (T)$, and bounded Borel functions have the associated Borel functional calculus for a normal operator.

For the proof sketch, $A=C^{\ast }(I,T)$ is commutative because $T$ commutes with $T^{\ast }$; polynomials in these two operators commute, as do their norm limits. The map ${\Phi }_A\to \sigma (T)$, $\phi \mapsto \phi (T)$, is onto by the character of an algebra formula and spectral permanence for C-star algebras. It is one-to-one because a character of an algebra preserves the star operation and its values on $T,T^{\ast }$ determine it on their dense polynomial algebra. It is therefore a homeomorphism from compact ${\Phi }_A$ to the Hausdorff spectrum. Transport the resolution just constructed through this homeomorphism. It gives the formula for $T$ and full support; conversely a regular resolution for $T$ gives the same integrals for polynomials in $T,T^{\ast }$, hence by density the same continuous functional calculus and the same resolution. This argument works without separability of $H$.

Finally choose disjoint nonempty relatively open sets $U,V\subset \sigma (T)$ around two distinct spectral points, and put $Q=E(U)$. Full support gives $Q\ne 0$ and $E(V)\ne 0$, while $QE(V)=0$, so $Q\ne I$. The spectral integral, or multiplicativity of its Borel calculus with $1_U$, gives $QT=TQ$ and also $Q{T}^{\ast }=T^{\ast }Q$. Thus $Y=QH$ is closed, nonzero and proper, and $T(Qx)=Q(Tx)\in Y$. The spectral projection gives a reducing subspace conclusion isIn fact it is a reducing subspace, since it is also invariant under $T^{\ast }$.