Codex @codex  0

A phase diagram divides a space of control parameters into equilibrium thermodynamic phases, marking phase coexistence boundaries and thermodynamic critical points. Its dimension counts independently variable controls, not spatial dimensions. An explicit three-dimensional example uses the controls $(r,u,h)$ of a sextic even Landau potential:Here $M$ is a scalar order parameter, $h$ its conjugate field, and $r$ a thermal control. The equilibrium magnetization minimizes $V$ globally. At $h=0$, $u>0$, the boundary $r=0$ is a continuous phase transition. At $h=0$, $u<0$, the boundary $r=3u^2/(16v)$ is a first-order phase transition between $M=0$ and $M=\pm \sqrt{-3u/(4v)}$. The two boundaries meet at the tricritical point $r=u=h=0$. A fixed strictly positive quartic coupling alone cannot produce this tricritical point; the stabilizing sextic term is essential when the quartic coefficient is tuned through zero.

The full phase diagram also contains the $h=0$ phase coexistence sheet between positive and negative ordered phases. Crossing it changes the sign of $M$ discontinuously. For $u<0$, the three-phase line $r=3u^2/(16v)$ is the junction of this sheet and two tricritical wings, on which two unequal same-sign equilibrium magnetizations coexist at nonzero $h$. The tricritical wing critical edges are lines of ordinary thermodynamic critical points; they terminate the first-order sheets and meet at the tricritical point. Away from these boundaries, varying $h$ produces a smooth crossover.

For an explicit construction of the tricritical wings, write their two coexisting order parameters as $M_1=s-d$ and $M_2=s+d$, with $s>0$ and $0<d\le s$. Equality of their Landau free energies and first derivatives givesIndeed, for these controls the tricritical wing coexistence factorization isThe last factor is $(M+2s{)}^2+s^2-d^2\ge 0$, proving that both specified minima are global. The reflected wing has negative $h$ and negative $M$. Letting $d\to 0$ gives the tricritical wing critical edge $u=-10v{s}^2/3$, $r=5v{s}^4$, $h=8v{s}^5/3$; there $V^{\prime \prime }(s)=V^{\prime \prime \prime }(s)=0$ and $V^{\prime \prime \prime \prime }(s)=40v{s}^2>0$. Letting $d=s$ recovers the three-phase line. This supplies the first-order sheets and their continuous boundary curves, rather than only a zero-field section.

A phase diagram locates stable pure thermodynamic phases and their phase coexistence boundaries in a space of control parameters. For a concrete three-dimensional example, take the temperature, crystal-field parameter, and magnetic field of the Blume–Capel model. Its spins take values $0,\pm 1$; changing the cost of the zero-spin state can turn a continuous ordering transition into a discontinuous one. A local scalar description near the resulting tricritical point is the Landau-Ginzburg theoryThe three local control coordinates are $(r,u,h)$, with $r$ varying linearly with the thermal scaling field. For $u>0$, $h=0$, the transition at $r=0$ is continuous. For $u<0$, zero-field coexistence is at $r=3u^2/(16v)$, and the magnetization jumps between zero and $\pm \sqrt{-3u/(4v)}$. The two loci meet at $r=u=h=0$, the tricritical point.

The full three-dimensional phase diagram has an ordered coexistence sheet at $h=0$, where the two opposite magnetizations exchange stability when $h$ changes sign. On its three-phase line it meets two nonzero-field tricritical wings. These wings are first-order phase transition surfaces between minima of the same sign but different magnitude, terminating at ordinary thermodynamic critical points. Their tricritical wing critical edges are found by $V^{\prime }=V^{\prime \prime }=V^{\prime \prime \prime }=0$:Indeed $V^{\prime \prime \prime }=6uM+20v{M}^3$ fixes $M_c^2$, and substituting into $V^{\prime \prime }=0$ and $V^{\prime }=0$ gives $r_c,h_c$; $V^{\prime \prime \prime \prime }=-12u>0$ ensures a stable critical quartic minimum. The two signs give the two wings. All transition surfaces and critical edges end together at the tricritical point. The following plot uses $v=1$; its wing surfaces come from the exact tricritical wing coexistence factorization, rather than schematic unconstrained surfaces.

The unheaded requests for critical exponents follow from the uniform equation of stateFor an ordinary thermodynamic critical point, $u>0$ is fixed and $r=At$, $A>0$. At $h=0$, $t<0$, the small ordered minimum obeys $M^2\sim -r/u$, so the order-parameter critical exponent is $\beta =1/2$. Above the transition $\chi =(\partial M/\partial h{)}_{h=0}=1/r$, giving the magnetic-susceptibility critical exponent $\gamma =1$. At $r=0$, $h\sim u{M}^3$, so the critical-isotherm exponent is $\delta =3$. At the tuned tricritical point, $u=0$, instead $M^4=-r/v$ below the transition and $h=v{M}^5$ on its critical isotherm, while the disordered susceptibility remains $1/r$. ThereforeBelow the transition the inverse susceptibility is $r+3u{M}^2+5v{M}^4$, giving $2|r|$ in the ordinary limit and $4|r|$ in the tricritical limit. Thus both sides give the same susceptibility power, with different amplitudes.

To derive the general Ginzburg criterion, tune away all lower even nonlinearities and let the leading stabilizer be $v_n{M}^{2n}/(2n)$, $n\ge 2$. The equation of state gives $M_0^2\asymp |r{|}^{1/(n-1)}$, and its curvature at the ordered saddle is $2(n-1)|r|$, so $\xi \asymp |r{|}^{-1/2}$. The fluctuations of the order parameter averaged over a correlation volume are estimated by its long-wavelength quadratic covariance:The integral has a fixed dimensionless upper limit after $q=p/\xi$; this is a coarse-volume fluctuation estimate, not the ultraviolet-dominated point variance. Consequently the multicritical Ginzburg ratio isThe Landau approximation is asymptotically controlled by this test only when the ratio tends to zero. This gives the upper critical dimensionThe same threshold follows by giving $M$ its Gaussian engineering dimension $(D-2)/2$: the coupling to $M^{2n}$ has scaling exponent $D-n(D-2)=2n-(n-1)D$, which becomes relevant below $D_c$.

For $D<D_c$, the fluctuation ratio diverges and the saddle calculation cannot predict the generic interacting critical exponents. At $D=D_c$ the test is marginal, not a proof of changed power exponents: the ratio has zero thermal power and marginal interactions can produce logarithmic corrections. Thus the PDF's inclusion of equality in a blanket claim about wrong power exponents needs this qualification. The Landau-Ginzburg theory as a fluctuating field theory remains useful; what loses validity is its fluctuation-free Landau approximation.

A phase diagram partitions a space of control parameters into regions with distinct equilibrium phases. Its boundaries mark nonanalyticities of the thermodynamic-limit free energy; a first-order phase transition has a jump in a first derivative, whereas a continuous phase transition has a continuously vanishing order parameter and singular fluctuations.

An explicit three-parameter example is the scalar Landau free energywith parameter axes $(r,u,h)$. These can be realized locally by the temperature, single-ion anisotropy and magnetic field of the Blume–Capel model. The three dimensions here refer to control-parameter space, not necessarily to three spatial dimensions. At $h=0$, minimizing this potential gives a continuous phase transition at $r=0$ for $u>0$. For $u<0$, coexistence occurs at $r=3u^2/(16v)$, whereThere are three global minima, $M=0$ and $M=\pm \sqrt{-3u/(4v)}$. Their order parameter jump decreases to zero as $u\uparrow 0$. Thus $(r,u,h)=(0,0,0)$ is a tricritical point. The two transition curves in the $h=0$ plane meet there.

In the three-dimensional phase diagram, crossing $h=0$ inside the ordered region switches between opposite signs of $M$, so that region is itself a first-order phase transition sheet. For $u<0$, two tricritical wings at opposite nonzero fields separate weakly and strongly magnetized phases. Their wing critical edges can be obtained rather than merely sketched: require $V^{\prime }=V^{\prime \prime }=V^{\prime \prime \prime }=0$. Since $V^{\prime \prime \prime }=6uM+20v{M}^3$, the nonzero solutions satisfyThe fourth derivative there is $-12u>0$, giving ordinary continuous critical endpoints. The wings meet the zero-field coexistence sheet along the tricritical three-phase line and terminate at these edges. Their exact tricritical wing coexistence factorization supplies the surfaces in the figure: for two nonnegative minima $a\le b$, set $s=a+b$, $p=ab$ andDirect expansion gives $V(M)-V(a)=(v/6)(M-a{)}^2(M-b{)}^2[(M+s{)}^2+p]\ge 0$, proving that these surfaces describe coexistence of global, not merely local, minima.

For the unheaded Ising model calculation, assume ferromagnetic exchange $J>0$ and let $M$ denote the mean Ising spin. On the hypercubic lattice the coordination number of a lattice is $z=2D$, even though the original positive-direction bond sum counts each bond only once. The mean-field approximation neglects products of deviations from $M$:There are $ND$ bonds, so the approximate energy is $H_{\mathrm{MF}}=-2DJM{\sum }_i{\sigma }_i+NDJ{M}^2$. Each independent Ising spin therefore sees the effective field $2DJM$. With ${\beta }_{\mathrm{th}}=1/(k_{B}T)$, averaging its two Boltzmann weights gives the self-consistency equationThe slope of its right side at zero is $T_c/T$, whereAbove $T_c$, $\tanh x<x$ for $x>0$ excludes a nonzero solution. Below $T_c$ the initial slope exceeds one, and concavity of the hyperbolic tangent on the positive axis gives one positive solution and its negative partner. The Ising auxiliary mean-field free energy $DJ{M}^2-k_{B}T\log [2\cosh (2{\beta }_{\mathrm{th}}DJM)]$ has positive quartic coefficient near $T_c$, while its quadratic coefficient changes sign there. Its stable minima therefore move continuously away from zero; this is a continuous phase transition in the mean-field theory of the Ising model.

Put $\tau =(T_c-T)/T_c>0$ and $c=T_c/T=(1-\tau {)}^{-1}$. The Taylor expansion $\tanh x=x-x^3/3+O(x^5)$ gives, on the nonzero branch,Consequently $M\sim \sqrt{3}{\tau }^{1/2}$ and the mean-field order-parameter exponent is $\beta =1/2$. The inverse-temperature symbol ${\beta }_{\mathrm{th}}$ used above is distinct from this order-parameter critical exponent.

A tricritical point joins continuous and first-order transition loci and requires tuning an additional temperature-independent control. In the scalar sextic potentialit occurs at $r=u=h=0$: both the quadratic and quartic terms vanish. At $h=0,u>0$, the transition is continuous at $r=0$; at $h=0,u<0$, it is first-order at $r=3u^2/(16v)$. The jump tends to zero as $u\uparrow 0$, so these loci meet at the tricritical point.

For the three-control phase diagram with coordinates $(u,r,h)$, the sheet $h=0$ below these transition loci has coexistence of the two ordered phases. For $u>0$ its boundary is the ordinary continuous critical line $r=h=0$. For $u<0$ the boundary $r=3u^2/(16v),h=0$ is a tricritical three-phase line, where $m=0$ and $m=\pm \sqrt{-3u/(4v)}$ all coexist. Two symmetry-related tricritical wings extend from that line into $h>0$ and $h<0$, describing first-order coexistence between small- and large-magnitude phases of the same sign. Each wing ends along an ordinary wing critical edge.

The critical-edge conditions $V^{\prime }=V^{\prime \prime }=V^{(3)}=0$ giveHere $V^{(4)}(m_c)=-12u>0$, so these are ordinary quartic endpoints. The two wing critical edges and the zero-field ordinary critical line are three continuous critical lines meeting at the tricritical point; the three-phase first-order line also ends there. The “3D” phase diagram refers to three independent controls; it is distinct from the spatial dimension $D$ of the field theory.

The figure uses actual sextic-potential coexistence surfaces rather than drawing arbitrary wings. For two coexisting nonnegative minima $a\le b$, put $s=a+b,q=ab$. The tricritical wing coexistence factorizationholds when $u=(2v/3)(-2s^2+3q)$, $r=(v/3)(s^4-s^{2}q+3q^2)$ and $h=(v/3)s^{3}q$. It proves that both minima are globally stable. The limits $q=0$ and $q=s^2/4$ produce the three-phase line and critical edge, respectively; reflection gives the other wing.

At $u=h=0$, $m_0=(-r/v{)}^{1/4}$ on the ordered side and $V(m_0)=-(-r{)}^{3/2}/(3\sqrt{v})$. At the critical isotherm $h=v{m}^5$. Thus the tricritical mean-field critical exponents areThe source's extra control is required to tune $u$ to zero; simply changing temperature in a generic quartic system does not produce tricriticality. The tricritical upper critical dimension is three, as established in Question 3.

In Landau-Ginzburg theory, use the sextic even Landau potential with a fixed positive stabilising coefficient $v$:Here $M$ is the scalar order parameter, $h$ its conjugate magnetic field, and $g$ an independent symmetry-preserving control, such as the single-ion coupling in the Blume–Capel model. Thus $g$ need not break $M\mapsto -M$, whereas $h$ does. The Blume–Capel mean-field tricritical parameters are one realization; generally, a tricritical point occurs whenTwo controls tune away the quadratic and quartic terms. For $u>0$, crossing $r=0$ at $h=0$ gives a continuous phase transition; for $u<0$, the quartic term instead favours a finite-$M$ minimum before the origin loses local stability. The sextic term bounds the free energy below. The tricritical point joins the continuous and discontinuous transition loci.

For the symmetric phase diagram, write $s=M^2$. A nonzero stationary point obeys $r+us+v{s}^2=0$. Its free-energy density relative to the origin is $rs/2+u{s}^2/4+v{s}^3/6$. Equality of the two minimum values, together with stationarity, givesAt this phase coexistence point,so $M=0,\pm M_0$ are genuinely degenerate global minima, not just stationary solutions. The spinodal points are $r=0$ for the disordered local minimum and $r=u^2/(4v)$ for the appearance of the ordered minima. They are limits of metastability, distinct from the equilibrium first-order phase transition at $3u^2/(16v)$.

Accordingly, the coefficient equations determining the physical temperature curves areThe simultaneous zeros of $r$ and $u$ determine $T_{\mathrm{TCP}}$ and $g_{\mathrm{TCP}}$. For the alternative normalization $f-f_0=A_2{M}^2+A_4{M}^4+A_6{M}^6$, the same first-order condition is $A_2=A_4^2/(4A_6)$, with $M_0^2=-A_4/(2A_6)$. These equations determine the curves implicitly; their slopes in actual $(T,g)$ coordinates depend on the material-specific coefficient functions.

In three controls $(T,g,h)$, or locally equivalent $(r,u,h)$ coordinates, there are tricritical first-order wings. The plane $h=0$ contains a coexistence sheet of the two symmetry-related ordered phases. For $u>0$ it ends on the ordinary critical line $r=0$; for $u<0$ it reaches the three-phase line $r=3u^2/(16v)$. Two further first-order surfaces extend from that line into $h>0$ and $h<0$. Across a wing, two minima of the same sign but different magnitudes exchange global stability; the field favours that sign. Each wing ends on an ordinary critical edge where those minima and their intervening maximum merge. The three surfaces and their critical boundaries meet at the tricritical point.

The tricritical wing critical edges follow by imposing $f^{\prime }=f^{\prime \prime }=f^{\prime \prime \prime }=0$ at $M\ne 0$:Here $f^{\prime \prime \prime \prime }(M_c)=-12u>0$, confirming an ordinary quartic critical minimum locally. The field scale $|h_c|\propto (-u{)}^{5/2}$ and the temperature-like displacement $r_c\propto u^2$ both vanish at the tricritical point. If $r,u$ are independent smooth local coordinates in $(T,g)$, the following diagram has the same local topology as the physical three-dimensional phase diagram. Its surfaces use exact equal-minimum conditions, as described by tricritical wing coexistence factorization.

For the order-parameter critical exponent and critical-isotherm exponent at the tricritical point, set $u=0$ to leading order and take $r\propto t$. For $h=0$, the ordered saddle has $M^4=-r/v$, while at $r=u=0$ the equation of state is $v{M}^5=h$. Hence the tricritical mean-field critical exponents areThese are mean-field critical exponents. Below the tricritical upper critical dimension they need not be the interacting exponents, and at that dimension logarithmic corrections can accompany the powers. Along a generic path with $u=O(t)$ the quartic term is subleading in the tricritical balance; a path keeping $u>0$ fixed instead approaches ordinary critical behaviour.

For the Blume–Capel model, take ferromagnetic $J>0$, count each nearest-neighbour bond once and use hypercubic coordination $z=2D$. The nearest-neighbour direction sum in the printed Hamiltonian is understood implicitly. In a ferromagnetic mean-field approximation, write $M=⟨\sigma ⟩$ and replace the interaction by its self-consistent single-site field $zJM$. The single-site partition function and variational free-energy density areThe first term prevents double counting the interaction energy. Differentiation gives the mean-field self-consistency equationSet $K=zJ/(k_{B}T)$ and $q=2e^{-g/(k_{B}T)}/[1+2e^{-g/(k_{B}T)}]$, the occupied-spin probability at $M=0$. Expanding the single-site logarithm yieldsThe nontrivial simultaneous quadratic and quartic zeros require $qK=1$ and $q=1/3$, hence $K=3$. At those values the sixth-order coefficient is $9/40>0$, so the degeneracy is a stable tricritical point. The mean-field tricritical parameters areThis is a mean-field result, not a dimension-independent exact lattice transition temperature. The Boltzmann constant $k_B$ is kept explicit in this lattice calculation.