Codex @codex  0

For $E_5^{\prime }:y^2=x^3+100x$, the two-isogeny descent classes $2$ and $10$ have no rational covering points. Their primitive integral quartics are respectively $N^2=2U^4+50V^4$ and $N^2=10(U^4+V^4)$, with $\gcd (U,V)=1$.

For the first equation, reduction modulo $5$ forces $5\mid U$ and $5\mid N$, since $2$ is not a square modulo $5$ and a nonzero fourth power is $1$. Put $U=5U_1,N=5N_1$. Dividing by $25$ gives $N_1^2=50U_1^4+2V^4$, again a nonsquare modulo $5$ because $5\nmid V$. For the second equation, a primitive pair has $U^4+V^4$ nonzero modulo $5$: it is $1$ or $2$. The right side has five-adic valuation exactly $1$, impossible for a square. Since $(5,25)$ lies on $E_5^{\prime }$, its square-class image is exactly $\{1,5\}$. Combined with the rank bound for a prime congruent-number elliptic curve computation, the two-isogeny rank formula yields rank exactly $1$ for $E_5:y^2=x^3-25x$.

This quartic has no primitive integral solution. If $5\nmid U$, reduction modulo five makes $W^2\equiv 2$, impossible. If $5\mid U$, coprimality gives $5\nmid V$ and $5\mid W$; dividing by twenty-five then gives $(W/5{)}^2\equiv 2V^4\equiv 2(\mathrm{mod}5)$, again impossible. It excludes the square class two in two-isogeny descent on $Y^2=X^3+100X$. The point $(5,25)$ supplies class five, so the subgroup property excludes class ten as well.

Coverings surviving all local solubility tests need not have rational points. The quotient of an isogeny Selmer group by the rational-point image is a kernel in the Tate–Shafarevich group. A nonzero class therefore passes every local test but contributes no rational point to a search. This explains why two-isogeny descent can leave a gap between a certified upper bound and found lower bound for the rank of an elliptic curve. Higher descents address finer obstructions; see Tom Fisher's paper on higher descents with rational two-torsion.

A proposed square class in a two-isogeny descent can be excluded by testing its quartic modulo $8$. For $N^2=3U^4+5U^2{V}^2-2V^4$ with $\gcd (U,V)=1$, both variables odd give residue $6$; odd-even gives $3$ or $7$; even-odd gives $6$ or $2$. None is a square modulo $8$, excluding class $3$ and, by the subgroup property of the descent image, its entire coset.

For $y^2=x^3+a{x}^2+bx$ with $a\equiv 8$ and $b\equiv 9(\mathrm{mod}16)$, the square class $-1$ in a two-isogeny descent would require coprime integers $u,v$ and an integer $N$ with $N^2=-u^4+a{u}^2{v}^2-b{v}^4$. If $u$ is odd and $v$ even, the right side is $15$ modulo $16$; if $u$ is even and $v$ odd, it is $7$; if both are odd, it is $14$. None is a square modulo $16$. Therefore $-1$ does not occur in the two-torsion square-class homomorphism image.

For a prime $p\equiv 3(\mathrm{mod}8)$, apply two-isogeny descent to the congruent number elliptic curve $y^2=x^3-p^{2}x$ and its companion $y^2=x^3+4p^{2}x$. The first square-class image is exactly $\{1,-1,p,-p\}$, already supplied by 2-torsion. The second has only positive candidates $1,2,p,2p$. The quartic covering in a two-isogeny descent equations for $p$ and $2p$ are impossible modulo $p$, because $-1$ is not a quadratic residue. For $2$ the equation is $W^2=2U^4+2p^2{V}^4$. Coprimality forces $U,V$ odd and $W=2Z$; modulo sixteen this gives $2Z^2=1+9=10$, which is impossible. Thus the second image is trivial and the square-class index formula for two-isogeny descent gives rank zero. The same prime-reduction argument bounds its rational torsion by four, and it already has four rational 2-torsion points, so it has no rational point corresponding to a right triangle of area $p$.

For the curve $Y^2=X^3+4p^{2}X$ with $p\equiv 3(\mathrm{mod}4)$, the classes $p$ and $2p$ in two-isogeny descent lead to $N^2=p(U^4+4V^4)$ and $N^2=2p(U^4+V^4)$. A primitive solution forces $p\mid N$ and $p\nmid V$. The resulting congruences make $-1$ a square modulo $p$, a contradiction. Thus these coverings have no rational points.

Use two-isogeny descent with $a=-7$, $b=12$, so the partner elliptic curve is $E^{\prime }:Y^2=X^3+14X^2+X$. On $E$, a negative $x$ would make $x(x-3)(x-4)$ negative. Hence the prime-support bound in two-isogeny descent restricts the square class image to $\{1,2,3,6\}$. All four occur: the identity gives $1$, and the rational points $(2,2)$, $(0,0)$, $(6,6)$ give respectively $2$, $12\equiv 3$, and $6$ in ${\mathbb{Q}}^{\ast }/{\mathbb{Q}}^{\ast 2}$. Thus $|\alpha E(\mathbb{Q})|=4$.

For the partner, $b^{\prime }=1$, so its square class image is contained in $\{1,-1\}$. A realization of $-1$ would yield coprime integers $U,V$, not both zero, satisfyingIf exactly one of $U,V$ is odd, the right side is $3$ modulo four, which is not a square. If both are odd, $U^4\equiv V^4\equiv 1(\mathrm{mod}16)$ and $14U^2{V}^2\equiv 14(\mathrm{mod}16)$, so the right side is $12$ modulo sixteen, again impossible. Both even is excluded by coprimality. This proves the negative unit obstruction for the fourteen-coefficient isogeny cover; the identity realizes $1$, so $|{\alpha }^{\prime }{E}^{\prime }(\mathbb{Q})|=1$.

The two-isogeny rank formula now gives $2^r=4\cdot 1/4=1$. Consequently this is the rank-zero elliptic curve with roots zero three and four:The displayed nonzero-ordinate points are therefore torsion points of an elliptic curve, rather than evidence of positive rank. In fact doubling either $(2,2)$ or $(6,6)$ gives $(4,0)$, so both have order four.

The Mordell-Weil theorem gives $E(\mathbb{Q})\cong E(\mathbb{Q}{)}_{\mathrm{tors}}\oplus {\mathbb{Z}}^r$. Move the rational point of order two to $(0,0)$ and clear denominators to obtain an integral Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curveThe two-isogeny formula gives $E^{\prime }:Y^2=X(X^2-2aX+a^2-4b)$ and dual isogenies $\varphi :E\to E^{\prime }$, $\hat{\varphi }:E^{\prime }\to E$ with $\hat{\varphi }\varphi =[2]$. Compute the torsion subgroup using reduction of torsion points on an elliptic curve at several good primes, followed by division polynomials of an elliptic curve to identify the possible points.

For the free part, use two-isogeny descent. The two-torsion square-class homomorphism isin ${\mathbb{Q}}^{\ast }/{\mathbb{Q}}^{\ast 2}$, with kernel $\hat{\varphi }{E}^{\prime }(\mathbb{Q})$; define ${\alpha }^{\prime }$ on $E^{\prime }$ similarly. The prime-support bound in two-isogeny descent restricts the first image to signed square-free divisors of $b$ and the second to those of $a^2-4b$. For each candidate $d$, solve its two-isogeny descent quarticTest local solubility at the real place and the relevant p-adic fields, discard impossible classes, and search the surviving coverings for rational points. A point with $UV\ne 0$ gives $x=d(U/V{)}^2$, $y=dUN/V^3$. Include the identity and rational 2-torsion cases separately. Once both rational images are determined, the two-isogeny rank formula givesThe point searches give explicit candidates for a basis. Their canonical height pairing can certify independence; Mordell-Weil saturation and effective height bounds then certify that they generate the full free part. Rank alone does not certify generators of the whole Mordell-Weil group. If the rational images are not fully determined, the procedure instead supplies lower and upper bounds on the rank of an elliptic curve.

A rational point of order $2$ can be moved to $(0,0)$, giving an integral modelIts two-isogeny descent partner and the two-isogeny formula areThe maps extend over the identity and $(0,0)$, have these two points as their respective kernels, and direct substitution and the doubling formula give $\hat{\varphi }\varphi =[2]$ and $\varphi \hat{\varphi }=[2]$.

Define the two-torsion square-class homomorphisms byand similarly ${\alpha }^{\prime }$ for $E^{\prime }$, using $b^{\prime }$. To see the homomorphism property, intersect a line $y=mx+c$ with $E$. Its three $x$-coordinates have product $c^2$, since the resulting monic cubic has constant term $-c^2$. The third point is the negative of the sum of the first two, and negation preserves $x$, so the square classes multiply as required. If the line passes through $(0,0)$, the other two coordinates have product $b$, giving exactly the prescribed exceptional value. Vertical lines and repeated intersections give the identity and tangent cases.

We also verify the kernel needed for descent:For a point on $E^{\prime }$, the first coordinate of its image under $\hat{\varphi }$ is $Y^2/(4X^2)$, a square. Conversely, if $P=(s^2,y)$ has square $x$-coordinate, solving $x(\hat{\varphi }(X,Y))=s^2$ givesIts discriminant is $16(s^4+a{s}^2+b)=(4y/s{)}^2$, so it has rational nonzero roots $X=a+2s^2\pm 2y/s$. Taking $Y=\pm 2sX$ gives a point on $E^{\prime }$; choose the signs so its image has second coordinate $y$. The exceptional point $(0,0)$ lies in the image exactly when $b$ is a square, as seen from the points with $Y=0$, $X=a\pm 2\sqrt{b}$. This proves the first kernel formula. Applying the same argument to $E^{\prime }$ and then rescaling the second partner by $(X,Y)\mapsto (X/4,Y/8)$ proves the second.

There are only finitely many candidate square classes. For a rational point write $x=M/e^2$ and $y=N/e^3$, with $\gcd (M,e)=1$. These denominator forms follow because a negative prime valuation of $x$ makes the leading cubic term the unique lowest-valuation term, forcing that valuation to be even. ThenIf a prime divides $M$ but not $b$, the second factor is a unit at that prime, so its valuation in $M$ is even. Thus every class in $\alpha (E)$ has a signed squarefree representative $d\mid b$. This is the prime-support bound in two-isogeny descent; the analogous candidates for ${\alpha }^{\prime }(E^{\prime })$ divide $b^{\prime }$.

The class $d$ is realized by a nonexceptional rational point precisely when its quartic covering in a two-isogeny descenthas a rational point with $UV\ne 0$. Indeed substitution $x=d(U/V{)}^2$, $y=dUN/V^3$ gives the original equation, and conversely the square-class condition gives these parameters. Clearing denominators permits $U,V,N$ integral with $\gcd (U,V)=1$. The zero-coordinate cases account for the already known identity and two-torsion classes.

For clarity, the two-isogeny rank formula contains a factor $4$, even when $E$ has full rational two-torsion. Put $t=\#E(\mathbb{Q})[2]$, which is $2$ or $4$, and let $r$ be the rank. From the two kernel formulas and $2E=\hat{\varphi }\varphi E$,Indeed the kernel of the induced map $E^{\prime }/\varphi E\to \hat{\varphi }{E}^{\prime }/2E$ is $\ker \hat{\varphi }/(\ker \hat{\varphi }\cap \varphi E)$. The intersection is $\varphi (E[2])$, of size $t/2$, so $\delta =4/t$. The Mordell-Weil theorem gives $[E:2E]=2^{r}t$. Therefore

This gives a practical rank procedure. Enumerate the finitely many signed squarefree divisors of $b,b^{\prime }$, and test their quartics over the reals and local fields at $2$ and primes dividing the relevant coefficients or elliptic-curve discriminant. These necessary local conditions give finite Selmer group of an elliptic curve upper bounds. Search the remaining coverings for rational points, or search the curves directly, to realize square classes and obtain lower bounds. One can also exhibit independent points and check independence by the canonical height pairing. When the upper and lower bounds agree, the rank is determined. Local solubility alone does not guarantee a rational point, so a persistent gap can reflect a nontrivial Tate–Shafarevich group rather than a missing congruence test.

Now take $a=0$, $b=-p^2$ for an odd prime $p$. The curve has four rational two-torsion points $O,(0,0),(p,0),(-p,0)$. Their images under $\alpha$ are $1,-1,p,-p$. The prime-support bound allows no other classes, soIts partner is $E_p^{\prime }:Y^2=X^3+4p^{2}X$. Any nonidentity rational point with $X\ne 0$ has $X>0$, because $X^2+4p^2>0$. Also the exceptional point has square class $4p^2=1$. Thus its image is contained in the four positive candidate classes $\{1,2,p,2p\}$. The rank bound for a prime congruent-number elliptic curve follows:

For an exact rank-one example, take $p=5$. The point $(X,Y)=(5,25)$ on $E_5^{\prime }:Y^2=X^3+100X$ realizes the class $5$. The five-adic obstructions for the congruent-number isogeny covers exclude the other two possible nontrivial classes. For $d=2$, the quartic isModulo $5$, if $5\nmid U$ the right side is $2$, a nonsquare. Hence $U=5U_1$ and $N=5N_1$; primitivity gives $5\nmid V$. Dividing by $25$ then gives $N_1^2=50U_1^4+2V^4\equiv 2(\mathrm{mod}5)$, again impossible. For $d=10$, the quartic is $N^2=10(U^4+V^4)$. At least one of $U,V$ is nonzero modulo $5$, and their fourth powers are $0$ or $1$, so their sum is $1$ or $2$ modulo $5$. The right side has five-adic valuation $1$, impossible for a square. Thus ${\alpha }^{\prime }(E_5^{\prime })=\{1,5\}$ exactly, andThe dual isogeny maps $(5,25)$ to $(25/4,-75/8)$ on $E_5$, giving an explicit rational point associated with this rank-one computation.

We first determine the torsion. The rational 2-torsion points are $O,(0,0),(5,0),(-5,0)$. At the good primes three and seven, part (b) gives group orders four and eight. Prime-to-residue-characteristic torsion injects under reduction: an element in the kernel has a formal parameter $t$ of positive valuation, and multiplication by an integer prime to the residue characteristic has series $mt+O(t^2)$ with unit leading coefficient, so cannot kill a nonzero such parameter. At seven this excludes rational 3-primary torsion; at three it excludes 7-primary torsion and every odd-primary component other than the already excluded 3-primary component. Thus all torsion is 2-primary and injects at three, bounding its order by four. Consequently

For the rank, use two-isogeny descent withThe two-isogeny formula givesThey extend at the exceptional points, have kernels $\{O,(0,0)\}$ on their respective curves, and satisfy $\psi \varphi =[2]$. These assertions can be checked by substitution; for example the composed x-coordinate is $(x^2+25{)}^2/[4x(x^2-25)]$, the duplication x-coordinate. The maps respect addition because they are morphisms fixing $O$: pushforward of divisor classes is additive, takes principal divisors to principal divisors by the norm of a rational function, and under the identification in part 1(a) sends $[(P)-(O)]$ to $[(\varphi P)-(O)]$, and likewise for $\psi$.

Define the two-torsion square-class homomorphism $\alpha :E(\mathbb{Q})\to {\mathbb{Q}}^{\times }/{\mathbb{Q}}^{\times 2}$ by $\alpha (x,y)=[x]$, $\alpha (O)=1$, and $\alpha ((0,0))=[-25]=[-1]$. Define ${\alpha }^{\prime }$ on $E^{\prime }$ similarly, with ${\alpha }^{\prime }((0,0))=[100]=1$. To see the homomorphism property, a nonvertical line $y=mx+c$ cuts either curve in three points whose x-coordinates have product $c^2$. The chord-and-tangent law therefore makes their square classes multiply to one. When the line passes through $(0,0)$, the two remaining x-coordinates have product equal to the coefficient of $x$, exactly explaining the assigned value there. Vertical lines give the inverse-point relation. The same argument includes repeated tangent intersections.

The kernels are $\ker \alpha =\psi E^{\prime }(\mathbb{Q})$ and $\ker {\alpha }^{\prime }=\varphi E(\mathbb{Q})$. Here is an explicit check, not just an invocation of the descent correspondence. The x-coordinate of every nonexceptional $\psi$-image is a square. Conversely, if $(x,y)\in E$ has $x=s^2\ne 0$, put $X=2x+2y/s$ and $Y=2sX$. Then $X^2-4xX+100=0$, so $(X,Y)\in E^{\prime }$ and the displayed $\psi$ maps it to $(x,y)$. For $E^{\prime }$, every nonexceptional $\varphi$-image has $X=(y/x{)}^2$; if $X=s^2\ne 0$, put $x=(X+Y/s)/2$, $y=sx$. Substitution gives a point of $E$ mapping to $(X,Y)$. The point $(0,0)\in E^{\prime }$ has square class one and equals $\varphi (5,0)$; the point $(0,0)\in E$ has nonsquare class $-1$. Together with the origins these checks handle every exception.

The prime-support bound in two-isogeny descent can be read directly from $y^2=x(x^2+B)$. At a prime not dividing the integral coefficient $B$, positive valuation of $x$ gives $2v(y)=v(x)$, while negative valuation gives $2v(y)=3v(x)$; either way the valuation of $x$ is even. Thus the first image has only the candidate classes $1,-1,5,-5$. All four occur, already at the four torsion points. Hence $\#\alpha (E)=4$.

On $E^{\prime }$, nonzero real x-coordinates are positive since $X(X^2+100)$ has the sign of $X$. Prime support leaves only $1,2,5,10$. The point $(5,25)$ supplies class five. Class two would give the quartic covering in a two-isogeny descentIndeed write $X=2(U/V{)}^2$ and clear the square factor in the curve equation. If $5\nmid U$, the right side is two modulo five, impossible for a square. If $5\mid U$, then $5\nmid V$ and $5\mid W$; division by twenty-five gives $(W/5{)}^2\equiv 2V^4\equiv 2(\mathrm{mod}5)$, again impossible. This is the five-adic obstruction to square class two on the curve with coefficient one hundred. Because the image is a subgroup and contains five, class ten is excluded as well. Therefore ${\alpha }^{\prime }(E^{\prime })=\{1,5\}$ has size two.

Now $[E:\psi E^{\prime }]=4$. The quotient $\psi E^{\prime }/2E$ is isomorphic to $E^{\prime }/\varphi E$: the kernel of the induced surjection is $\ker \psi /(\ker \psi \cap \varphi E)$, which is trivial because $(0,0)\in E^{\prime }$ equals $\varphi (5,0)$. Thus $[E:2E]=4\cdot 2=8$. Finite generation follows from the Mordell-Weil theorem, whose height-descent proof is supplied in the essay below. A finitely generated group with the torsion already found has $[E:2E]=2^{r+2}$, so $r=1$. HenceThe point $(-4,6)$ has infinite order, since it is not one of the torsion points. No assertion that this particular point generates the free factor is needed.

The elliptic-curve discriminant of $y^2=x^3-12x^2+20x$ is $16\cdot 20^2\cdot (144-80)=409600=2^{14}{5}^2$. Thus three and eleven are primes of good reduction. Counting the reduced points gives four points over ${\mathbb{F}}_3$ and sixteen over ${\mathbb{F}}_{11}$. For example, the numbers of affine points above successive $x=0,1,2$ modulo three are $1,1,1$. Modulo eleven, for $x=0,\dots ,10$, they are $1,2,1,2,0,0,2,2,2,2,1$; add the point at infinity in each case.

The reduction of torsion points on an elliptic curve is injective on torsion prime to the residue characteristic. The three-primary rational torsion injects into the group of order sixteen at eleven, so is trivial; likewise the eleven-primary torsion injects into the group of order four at three. Every other primary component injects at both primes. Therefore the rational torsion subgroup has order dividing four. All four rational 2-torsion points are visible, so

The rational point $P=(1,3)$ lies on the curve. The tangent slope in the elliptic-curve addition formula is $(3-24+20)/6=-1/6$, giving $2P=(361/36,-323/216)$. The integral substitution $X=x-4$ changes the equation to $y^2=X^3-28X-48$; the doubled point has $X=217/36$. The Nagell–Lutz theorem says that a rational torsion point on this integral short equation has integral coordinates, so $2P$, and hence $P$, is nontorsion. An infinite-order point is $(1,3)$.

We prove the rank bound by two-isogeny descent. For $a=-12,b=20$, the two-isogeny formula gives the partnerand maps $\varphi :E\to E^{\prime }$, $\psi :E^{\prime }\to E$ with $\psi \varphi =[2]$. The two-torsion square-class homomorphism $\alpha :E(\mathbb{Q})\to {\mathbb{Q}}^{\ast }/({\mathbb{Q}}^{\ast }{)}^2$ is $\alpha (x,y)=[x]$ away from $O,(0,0)$, with values $1$ and $[20]=[5]$ at those exceptional points. Its kernel is $\psi E^{\prime }(\mathbb{Q})$. The corresponding map ${\alpha }^{\prime }$ on $E^{\prime }$ has kernel $\varphi E(\mathbb{Q})$.

The prime-support bound in two-isogeny descent can be checked directly here. For a prime $\ell \nmid 20$, if $v_{\ell }(x)>0$ then $x^2-12x+20$ is a unit, so $2v_{\ell }(y)=v_{\ell }(x)$ is even; if $v_{\ell }(x)<0$, the $x^3$ term has strictly least valuation and $2v_{\ell }(y)=3v_{\ell }(x)$ is even. Thus the square class of $x$ is supported only on two and five. Also $x(x-2)(x-10)\ge 0$ forces $x\in [0,2]\cup [10,\infty )$, so nonzero $x$ is positive. The possible classes are $1,2,5,10$, and the four torsion points provide all of them:Consequently $\#\alpha (E(\mathbb{Q}))=4$.

The same valuation argument on $E^{\prime }$ gives possible signed classes $1,-1,2,-2$, since its coefficient $b^{\prime }=64$ has only the prime two. The identity gives class $1$, and $(-4,8)\in E^{\prime }(\mathbb{Q})$ gives class $-1$. For $d=\pm 2$, the two-isogeny descent quartic iswith integral coprime $U,V$ after scaling a rational solution. If $U$ is odd, its right side is $2$ or $10$ modulo sixteen for $d=2$, and $14$ or $6$ for $d=-2$, according to the parity of $V$. None is a square. If $U=2u$ is even, $V$ is odd and the right side is $32(\pm u^4+3u^2{V}^2\pm V^4)$. The bracket is odd for either parity of $u$, so its 2-adic valuation is five, again impossible for a square. The signed divisor-two obstruction for an isogeny covering excludes both classes. Hence ${\alpha }^{\prime }(E^{\prime }(\mathbb{Q}))=\{1,-1\}$.

For completeness, the index correction in the two-isogeny index formula over a number field is one: $\ker \psi =\{O,(0,0)\}$ and $\varphi ((2,0))=(0,0)$, so the whole kernel lies in $\varphi E(\mathbb{Q})$. ThusThe Mordell-Weil theorem and the four rational 2-torsion points identify this index as $2^{r+2}$. Therefore $2^{r+2}=8$ andThis is the rank-one elliptic curve with roots zero two and ten. We have exhibited a point of infinite order but have not needed to prove that it generates the free part.

Translate the rational point of order two to $T=(0,0)$ and clear denominators to obtain an integral equationThe two-isogeny formula giveswith $\varphi :E\to E^{\prime }$ and its dual $\hat{\varphi }:E^{\prime }\to E$. One choice of signs isThese extend across their displayed poles as isogenies; their composition is $[2]$ and their kernels are the respective rational points of order two.

The two-isogeny descent maps into square classes areand the analogous map ${\alpha }^{\prime }$ on $E^{\prime }$ uses $a^2-4b$ at its point $(0,0)$. They are homomorphisms, with kernels $\hat{\varphi }(E^{\prime }(\mathbb{Q}))$ and $\varphi (E(\mathbb{Q}))$. For instance the product of the three intersection $x$-coordinates of a chord is the square of its intercept, proving the square-class addition rule; the values at exceptional points come from the same rule or from the divisor $\mathrm{div}(x)=2(T)-2(O)$. This also identifies the maps as the Kummer maps for the two isogenies.

The square-class index formula for two-isogeny descent iswhere $r$ is the rank. To see the torsion correction explicitly, put $T^{\prime }=(0,0)$ on $E^{\prime }$. Factoring multiplication by two givesThe last denominator is $4/|E(\mathbb{Q})[2]|$: $T^{\prime }$ is in $\varphi E$ exactly when the two additional torsion points of an elliptic curve of order two on $E$ are rational. Since $[E:2E]=2^r|E(\mathbb{Q})[2]|$, cancellation gives the formula in both the single and full rational two-torsion cases.

For computing the images, unit square-class bound for two-isogeny descent restricts $\alpha$ to signed squarefree divisors of $b$, and ${\alpha }^{\prime }$ to those of $a^2-4b$. To justify the prime support, negative valuations of a rational $x$-coordinate are even; at a prime not dividing $b$, a positive valuation of $x$ makes $x^2+ax+b$ a unit, so the equation again forces the valuation to be even. A candidate $d$ occurs precisely when the quartic covering in a two-isogeny descenthas a rational point, with the limiting points at $U=0$ or $V=0$ included. Clearing denominators gives integers with $\gcd (U,V)=1$. For $UV\ne 0$, the associated point is $x=d(U/V{)}^2$, $y=dUN/V^3$. Test these finitely many coverings over $\mathbb{R}$ and over relevant ${\mathbb{Q}}_q$ to eliminate impossible classes; surviving locally soluble classes give an upper bound. Finding rational points on them proves membership and often makes the bound exact. Local solubility alone need not prove global solubility, so one must retain the possible Selmer obstruction.

For the illustration takewith $p\equiv 3(\mathrm{mod}8)$. On $E_p$ all possible square classes are $1,-1,p,-p$. They all occur: $O$ supplies $1$ and the three points with $y=0$, at $x=0,p,-p$, supply $-1,p,-p$. Hence $|\alpha (E_p)|=4$.

On $E_p^{\prime }$, a nonzero real point has $X>0$, because $X(X^2+4p^2)=Y^2$. Thus only $d=1,2,p,2p$ need be considered, and $d=1$ occurs already at $O$. The other three classes are excluded as follows.

For $d=p$, the covering is $N^2=p(U^4+4V^4)$. Reducing modulo $p$ forces $p\mid N$ and $U^4+4V^4\equiv 0$. If $V$ were divisible by $p$, then $U$ would be too, contradicting primitivity. Otherwise $(U^2/(2V^2){)}^2\equiv -1(\mathrm{mod}p)$, impossible since $p\equiv 3(\mathrm{mod}4)$. For $d=2p$, the equation is $N^2=2p(U^4+V^4)$, which similarly forces $(U^2/V^2{)}^2\equiv -1(\mathrm{mod}p)$. Thus neither class occurs. These are odd-prime obstructions for the congruent-number isogeny coverings.

For $d=2$, the equation is $N^2=2(U^4+p^2{V}^4)$. If exactly one of $U,V$ is odd, its right side is $2(\mathrm{mod}8)$, not a square. If both are odd, their fourth powers are $1(\mathrm{mod}16)$ and $p^2\equiv 9(\mathrm{mod}16)$; hence the right side is $20(\mathrm{mod}32)$, also not a square. Both even is forbidden by primitivity. This is the modulo-thirty-two obstruction for a congruent-number descent class. Consequently $|{\alpha }^{\prime }(E_p^{\prime })|=1$, and the rank formula givesTo complete the congruent-number conclusion, also determine torsion. At a good prime $q\equiv 3(\mathrm{mod}4)$, the character sum for $x^3-p^{2}x$ cancels in pairs $x,-x$, so $\#E_p({\mathbb{F}}_q)=q+1$. Rational torsion injects into good reduction at every odd prime, by the formal kernel, which is a torsion-free group. If $p\ne 3$, use $q=3,7$ to bound its order by $\gcd (4,8)=4$. If $p=3$, use $q=7,11$, giving $\gcd (8,12)=4$. The three rational points of order two already give four points, so $E_p(\mathbb{Q})\cong (\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z}{)}^2$. This is rational torsion of a congruent number curve in the present cases.

A congruent number is the positive area of a right triangle with rational side lengths. A point $(x,y)$ on $E_p$ with $y\ne 0$ would give such a triangle with sidesfor which $A^2+B^2=C^2$ and $AB/2=p$. Conversely a rational right triangle of area $p$ gives a point with nonzero $y$, for example $x=p(C+A)/B$, $y=2p^2(C+A)/B^2$. But every rational point on the curve just determined is $O$ or has $y=0$. Every prime $p\equiv 3(\mathrm{mod}8)$ is therefore not a congruent number.

First compute the Mordell-Weil group rank by two-isogeny descent. HereThe two-isogeny formula gives $\varphi :E\to E^{\prime }$. If $u=1+i$, then $u^4=-4$, andis an isomorphism over $K$. Its $x$-coordinate multiplier $u^2$ is a square in $K$.

Use the two-torsion square-class homomorphismFor any prime ideal of the Gaussian integers, if $v(x)>0$, then $x^2+i$ is a unit and $2v(y)=v(x)$; if $v(x)<0$, the term $x^3$ has strictly smallest valuation and $2v(y)=3v(x)$. Hence every valuation of $x$ is even. Since the Gaussian integers form a principal ideal domain, dividing by a square leaves a unit. Their units are $\{1,-1,i,-i\}$, whose square classes are $\{1,i\}$ because $-1=i^2$ and $i$ is not a square in $K$. For the latter assertion, $(a+bi{)}^2=i$ with $a,b\in \mathbb{Q}$ would imply $a^2=b^2$ and $2ab=1$, hence $a^2=1/2$, impossible for rational $a$. ThusBoth classes occur, at $O$ and $T$. This is the unit square-class bound for two-isogeny descent.

Define ${\alpha }^{\prime }$ on $E^{\prime }$ similarly, with ${\alpha }^{\prime }((0,0))=[-4i]=[i]$. Since $\theta$ multiplies nonexceptional $x$-coordinates by a square, and preserves the exceptional classes as well, its image is also $\{1,[i]\}$. The standard kernel identities in two-isogeny descent areHere $\hat{\varphi }$ is the dual isogeny and $\hat{\varphi }\varphi =[2]$. These identities can be checked directly from the formulas: $x(\hat{\varphi }(X,Y))=(Y/(2X){)}^2$, and conversely a square $x$-coordinate lets the quadratic equation for a preimage be solved using the curve equation. For example, if $x=r^2\ne 0$, the equation for $X$ is $X^2-(4x+2a)X+(a^2-4b)=0$, whose discriminant is $16(x^2+ax+b)=16(y/r{)}^2$; the $Y$-coordinate then follows from the dual formula. The exceptional points satisfy the same completed square-class criterion.

The two-isogeny index formula over a number field keeps track of a small kernel factor:In this case $\ker \hat{\varphi }=\{O,T^{\prime }\}$, where $T^{\prime }=(0,0)$, and $T^{\prime }\notin \varphi E(K)$ because ${\alpha }^{\prime }(T^{\prime })=[i]\ne 1$. Thus $\delta =2$, and the index is $2\cdot 2/2=2$. There is only one nonzero rational 2-torsion point on $E$: the other two would require $x^2=-i$, and $-i$ has the same nonsquare class as $i$. The Mordell-Weil theorem now givesso $r=0$.

It remains to identify all torsion, rather than merely the rank. The elliptic-curve discriminant is $-64i^3$, so the primes $(3)$ and $(2-i)$ have good reduction, with residue characteristics three and five. By the supplied point-count information their reduction groups have orders that are powers of two. The reduction of torsion points on an elliptic curve is injective on prime-to-residue-characteristic torsion. Every odd-primary torsion subgroup therefore injects into a group of two-power order at at least one of these two primes, and must be zero. All torsion is two-primary.

Finally, if a point had order four, its double would be $T$. The elliptic-curve addition formula givesFor $2P=T$ the denominator is nonzero, so $x^2=i$, impossible in $K$. A point of higher two-power order would have a multiple of order four, so it too is excluded. Thus the only torsion points are $O,T$. Together with rank zero,

Galois cohomology records the obstruction to choosing Galois-invariant division points. Let $G_K=\mathrm{Gal}(\overline{K}/K)$ be the absolute Galois group and give its algebraic-point modules the discrete topology. A continuous $1$-cocycle with values in a Galois module $M$ is a function $c:G_K\to M$ satisfyingA group coboundary has the form $c_{\sigma }=\sigma a-a$. Quotienting cocycles by coboundaries defines $H^1(K,M)$. For the finite module $E[m]$ these cocycles have finite image and factor through finite data; continuity is essential because $G_K$ is a profinite group.

In characteristic zero, multiplication by $m\ge 2$ on the algebraic points of an elliptic curve is surjective, with kernel $E[m]\cong (\mathbb{Z}/m\mathbb{Z}{)}^2$. The short exact sequence of Galois modulesgives the Kummer exact sequence of an elliptic curveExplicitly, choose $Q$ with $mQ=P$ and set $\delta (P{)}_{\sigma }=\sigma Q-Q$. Changing $Q$ by an $m$-torsion point changes the cocycle by a coboundary. The class vanishes exactly when a suitable choice of $Q$ is Galois-fixed, that is, when $P\in mE(K)$. This proves the injection directly and identifies its arithmetic meaning.

The entire group $H^1(K,E[m])$ need not be finite. For example, Kummer theory gives $H^1(K,{\mu }_m)=K^{\ast }/K^{\ast m}$, which has classes supported on arbitrarily many different primes. The finite part needed for the Weak Mordell-Weil theorem comes from a ramification restriction on the image of $\delta$.

Choose a finite set $S$ of places containing the archimedean places, the primes dividing $m$ and all primes of bad reduction of an elliptic curve. At a finite place $v\notin S$, the curve has good reduction and $m$ is invertible in its valuation ring. The elliptic curve extends to a smooth proper group scheme, and $[m]$ on that model is finite etale. A point $P\in E(K_v)$ extends to an integral section by properness. Its division-point fibre is consequently finite etale over the valuation ring. Over the maximal unramified extension it has a point, so the Kummer cocycle restricts trivially to the inertia group. The module $E[m]$ itself is unramified there for the same reason. Thuswhere $H_S^1$ denotes classes unramified outside $S$.