 Extensive quantity

Two related properties of an extensive quantity must be distinguished. Additivity says that a quantity $X$ for independent subsystems A and B obeysThe subsystems may be in different states. Extensivity expressed through a homogeneous function says that the equilibrium fundamental relation obeyswith composition held fixed. This is degree-one homogeneity along a replication ray; it does not say that internal energy is a linear function of arbitrary independent changes of entropy, volume and amount of substance.

Additivity gives integer replication by repeated addition. Subdividing a uniform bulk sample into $b$ equivalent parts gives rational scaling $a/b$; continuity then extends it to positive real factors. This argument requires negligible boundary contributions and a consistently prepared state. Conversely, a degree-one homogeneous function need not be additive between different rays: $f(x,y)=\sqrt{x^2+y^2}$ has $f(\lambda x,\lambda y)=\lambda f(x,y)$, but $f(1,0)+f(0,1)=2\ne \sqrt{2}=f(1,1)$. Thus a scaling identity alone cannot justify summing arbitrary states.

For finite samples, the surface correction to thermodynamic free energy can matter. Under geometric enlargement with volume multiplied by $\lambda$, surface area grows as ${\lambda }^{2/3}$, so a surface energy term is not a bulk extensive quantity. Replicating separated droplets retains every original surface, whereas merging them changes the total surface area. Likewise, appreciable mutual gravitational potential energy makes interacting subsystems fail the independent-copy premise. The thermodynamic limit explains when bulk scaling becomes accurate; it does not remove these qualifications for every small or strongly interacting system.