Large ND describes weakly coupled collective screening; a single electron does not dominate its screening cloud. For a small uniform electrondisplacement ξ relative to fixed ions, the restoring field gives meξ¨=−nee2ξ/ε0, hence
For the stipulated carbon plasma and B≃10, setting the gradient equal to 1011Km−1 gives a critical fluxfraction of order Acrit≃0.05. Fourier transport is invalid according to this test when A<Acrit; a still larger actual gradient raises the critical value. Thus the source's request for a minimumA has the inequality reversed: the calculation gives an upper threshold, not a positive minimum. An arbitrarily smaller positive A makes the criterion easier to satisfy. The exact numerical threshold is evaluated in the independent check.