Atomic and molecular cooling thresholds for galaxy formation Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-11-05
Primordial atomic line cooling becomes effective near the temperature where electronic excitations are accessible, of order ten thousand kelvin. Molecular hydrogen has lower-energy transitions and can cool colder gas if it forms and survives. The corresponding virial temperature thresholds translate into epoch-dependent halo mass thresholds. Radiation, molecular chemistry, metal-line cooling and gas density qualify a single universal minimum galaxy mass.
Atomic line cooling Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-11-05
Atomic line cooling removes gas kinetic energy by collisional excitation followed by photon escape. It is strongest where atoms or ions have bound electrons and thermally accessible transitions. If photons are trapped, or if the relevant atoms are fully ionized, the simple optically thin line-cooling rate no longer gives the same loss.
Collisional excitation Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-20
A collision can transfer kinetic energy to an atom or ion and excite a bound electron. Subsequent radiative de-excitation removes that energy from an optically thin gas. The thermal excitation rate is strongly reduced when the transition energy exceeds , giving the threshold behavior of atomic line cooling.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 60 3 i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For an optically thin low-density gas in collisional ionization equilibrium, the astrophysical cooling function collects losses per pair of hydrogen nuclei into . Its units are ; the time unit is missing from the printed guide to the vertical-axis labels. For the primordial atomic cooling curve, only hydrogen and helium provide bound-state coolants.
Schematic primordial cooling function with hydrogen and helium features, metal enrichment and photoionization effects
. Details. Near , collisional excitation of hydrogen becomes effective and subsequent photon emission removes thermal energy. The excitation rate is exponentially suppressed below the atomic energy threshold. Atomic line cooling and collisional ionization generate a strong hydrogen feature around a few ; helium excitation and ionization produce further structure around . Radiative recombination also contributes. Once the gas is highly ionized, these bound-state losses weaken. At –, thermal bremsstrahlung dominates, with approximately apart from slowly varying factors. The figure is an original qualitative sketch anchored to the two supplied values, not an atomic-rate calculation.
Increasing galactic metallicity adds many ionic transitions, producing metal-line cooling and substantially enhancing cooling, particularly in the – range. Metals also provide low-energy fine-structure transitions below . The change is not a uniform vertical shift: the positions and strengths of features depend on the elemental abundances and ionization state.
Photoionization removes bound electrons even where collisions alone would leave atoms neutral, often suppressing the hydrogen and helium line peaks and changing the metal-ion population. It also adds photoionization heating. The net thermal loss is then , with possible heating-cooling equilibrium near . A single density-independent no longer describes every irradiated cloud: the answer also depends on radiation intensity, spectrum, shielding and density. The illustrative photoionized curve denotes altered cooling alone, not the net loss including heating.
Below , primordial gas can use molecular line cooling, especially rotational and vibrational transitions of molecular hydrogen and, in suitable chemical conditions, hydrogen deuteride. Molecule formation and protection against photodissociation are essential. Enriched gas can additionally use metal-line cooling, other molecular species and dust thermal emission, with gas-dust energy exchange important at high density. At high cosmological redshift, residual free electrons can transfer energy to the cosmic microwave background through Compton cooling by the cosmic microwave background if the gas is hotter than the radiation. Expansion can also cool gas adiabatically, but neither that process nor Compton cooling by the cosmic microwave background is an atomic loss law. The atomic threshold is a cooling-channel limitation, not a universal minimum gas temperature.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 55 1 ii ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
In the intermediate-temperature interval, atomic line cooling is generally efficient. Collisional excitation of hydrogen and helium followed by photon emission removes thermal energy; collisional ionization and subsequent recombination also contribute. As the gas becomes more ionized, different transitions enter and leave the cooling budget.
For enriched gas, metal-line cooling is often dominant over substantial parts of this interval, because heavy ions provide many ultraviolet and optical transitions. The cooling curve consequently has pronounced peaks rather than one smooth universal power law. Hydrogen/helium atomic processes and metal lines provide the main cooling channels here. Their relative strengths depend on metallicity, ionization state, density and the incident radiation field; these temperature bands describe typical gas, not composition-independent boundaries.
Recombination cooling of ionized hydrogen Created 2026-10-20 Updated 2026-11-05
In an optically thin plasma, radiative recombination removes the kinetic energy of captured electrons. A radiative recombination photon can also carry the binding energy released when a free electron becomes bound; that part is stored ionization energy, rather than newly removed thermal energy. The kinetic contribution per event is the recombination-weighted electron energy, which need not be .
Equality with mean photoelectron heating requires two balances. If photoionization is the only ionization and heating process, and radiative recombination the only recombination and cooling process, photoionization equilibrium equates their event rates. Separately imposing thermal equilibrium then equates the mean heating energy per ionization to the mean kinetic cooling energy per recombination. Photoionization equilibrium alone does not do this: at the same balanced event rate, unequal energies can still heat or cool the gas. Additional atomic line cooling, collisional ionization or trapping of emitted photons changes the energy accounting.
