Boson-fermion degeneracy in a supermultiplet

Every positive-energy supermultiplet contains equally many bosonic and fermionic states. A supertrace of a positive supercharge anticommutator proves the equality, provided supersymmetry is exact and the representation is finite-dimensional at fixed momentum.

For a finite physical supermultiplet at fixed positive energy, fermion parity anticommutes with each odd supercharge. Trace cyclicity makes $\mathrm{Tr}[(-1{)}^F\{Q,Q^{†}\}]=0$. Summing the Super-Poincaré algebra diagonal entries replaces the anticommutator by $4E$, giving equal bosonic and fermionic state counts. A zero-energy vacuum is an exception to the division by $E$, so it need not have a partner. The argument requires an invariant fixed-momentum representation, which is the step lost under explicit supersymmetry breaking.

An odd involution $A$ reverses fermion parity and is its own inverse, so it identifies the bosonic and fermionic subspaces. They have equal dimension in a finite-dimensional representation. For a supercharge $q$ with $q^2=0$ and $\{q,q^{†}\}=cI$, $c>0$, use $A=(q+q^{†})/\sqrt{c}$. This gives a direct proof of boson-fermion degeneracy in a supermultiplet at positive energy. A zero-energy supersymmetric vacuum need not have an accompanying fermionic vacuum.

In an unbroken supersymmetric vacuum, physical boson and fermion partners have equal masses because supercharges commute with four-momentum. For one canonical chiral superfield, fluctuations about $W^{\prime }(v)=0$ have mass $|W^{\prime \prime }(v)|$ for both the complex scalar field and Weyl spinor.

For one canonical chiral field at $W^{\prime }(v)=0$, the quadratic scalar potential is $|W^{\prime \prime }(v){|}^2|\delta \phi {|}^2$. Writing $\delta \phi =(a+ib)/\sqrt{2}$ gives two canonically normalized real scalars with squared mass $|W^{\prime \prime }(v){|}^2$. The chiral-superfield fermion mass matrix has the same physical mass. A complex bilinear coefficient or its algebraic square is not itself a signed physical squared mass.