By the spectral theorem, the nonscalar unitary V has orthonormal eigenvectors with distinct eigenvalues . Choose . Then is not proportional to .
On the product input , the controlled unitary gate produces
Its two conditional target vectors are linearly independent, so the conditional-vector product-state criterion proves that the output is entangled. Equivalently, in the control computational basis and target eigenbasis its coefficient matrix is , whose determinant is . Thus U is an entangling gate. The excluded scalar case would only apply a phase gate to the control and could not entangle the factors; this is the controlled-unitary entangling criterion.
For and , the third equation gives . Combining it with gives and , after which the second equation gives . Hence
The coefficient matrix has determinant , proving uniqueness. Direct substitution gives the required right-hand sides , and .
Gaussian elimination of the first two equations gives and . The third then reduces to . Hence
In the infinite family , and , for . This makes the distinction between an inconsistent linear system and a free parameter explicit; its coefficient matrix has determinant .
Let and take the reduced positive operator . Choose orthonormal eigenvectors for its positive eigenvalues . Define
The defining identity of the partial trace gives , so the are orthonormal. Expansion in a full eigenbasis of yields ; zero-eigenvalue terms have zero squared norm and contribute nothing. Thus
The zero vector has the empty decomposition. Unit normalization would give , but no normalization is needed for the theorem itself.
For the given vector, the coefficient matrix is . Its second reduced operator is , whose eigenvalues are and eigenvectors , . The corresponding normalized first-factor vectors are
Their norms are one and their inner product is zero. Hence
Expanding the two terms returns the original three contributions. The vector has squared norm ; if a normalized state is wanted, divide by two and the Schmidt coefficients become and .
Row reduction, or the cofactor formula for a matrix inverse, gives
Multiplying by the right-hand-side column gives, at ,
For general , the coefficient matrix has determinant . Thus other parameter values give a unique solution. If , subtracting the first equation from the second gives , while subtracting it from the third gives , a contradiction. If , subtraction gives and , again inconsistent. Hence
Collecting the coefficients gives the coefficient matrix
A square homogeneous linear system has a nonzero solution precisely when its matrix is a singular matrix. Expanding the determinant down the first column,
Hence the necessary and sufficient condition is or or . A zero determinant gives a nontrivial kernel of a linear map; otherwise multiplication by the matrix inverse would force the zero solution.
The square roots simplify to the absolute values and . Put . A nontrivial solution of the homogeneous linear system exists exactly when its coefficient matrix is singular:
The second factor vanishes precisely when , or , giving both coordinate axes. The first factor vanishes when is a nonnegative integer. Hence the complete locus is
These are the two axes together with concentric circles of positive integer radii. The zero-radius case is the origin, already included on the axes; at that point both equations vanish and any nonzero pair works.
Figure 1.
The parameter locus consists of both axes and circles with integer radii
. Details.
Let and take the reduced positive operator . Choose orthonormal eigenvectors for its positive eigenvalues . Define
The defining identity of the partial trace gives , so the are orthonormal. Expansion in a full eigenbasis of yields ; zero-eigenvalue terms have zero squared norm and contribute nothing. Thus
The zero vector has the empty decomposition. Unit normalization would give , but no normalization is needed for the theorem itself.
For the given vector, the coefficient matrix is . Its second reduced operator is , whose eigenvalues are and eigenvectors , . The corresponding normalized first-factor vectors are
Their norms are one and their inner product is zero. Hence
Expanding the two terms returns the original three contributions. The vector has squared norm ; if a normalized state is wanted, divide by two and the Schmidt coefficients become and .