Two finite Galois extensions of the rational number field with coprime field discriminants have trivial intersection. Any ramified prime in the intersection would ramify in both fields. The intersection is therefore everywhere unramified at finite primes and has field discriminant of absolute value one. The Minkowski lower bound for a number-field discriminant excludes this in degree greater than one. The Galois correspondence then gives the product degree for their compositum. The normality hypothesis is used in this last intersection-to-degree argument.
For number fields, a prime ideal divides the different ideal exactly when it is ramified. More precisely, the local different exponent and tame ramification relation is , with equality for tame ramification; if , the finite residue extension is separable and the exponent is zero. One can see the ramification criterion directly from the trace pairing modulo the base prime: when its quotient ring has a nonzero nilpotent ideal, whose elements pair to zero since multiplication by a nilpotent has trace zero. When the quotient is a product of finite separable fields and its trace pairing is nondegenerate. Its determinant is a unit exactly in the second case.
Let . Any rational prime ramifying in must ramify in each , because ramification indices multiply in a tower. It would then divide both field discriminants, contrary to their coprimality. Thus is unramified at every finite prime, so . The Minkowski lower bound for a number-field discriminant excludes this for a field of degree :
The last inequality follows already for the weakest signature bound : the expression starts above one at and increases with . Consequently .
For completeness, normality converts this intersection statement into the desired degree statement. Put . Restriction injects into . The fixed field of its image in is exactly , because is Galois. The Galois correspondence therefore gives . This proves coprime discriminants imply linear disjointness:
Begin with two points at distance one. A ruler draws the line through two known points; a compass draws a circle with a known centre and a constructible radius. New points are intersections of such lines and circles. A real number is constructible when it occurs as a coordinate of a point obtained by finitely many such operations; a complex point is constructible when both coordinates are.
If current coordinates lie in a field , a line-line intersection solves linear equations over , while line-circle or circle-circle intersections reduce to a quadratic equation over . Thus each step requires at most adjoining a square root. Consequently every constructible number lies in a tower
Conversely field sums and differences are obtained by laying off segments, products and quotients by similar triangles, and a positive square root by the geometric-mean construction in a semicircle. Hence every real number in such a tower is constructible. This proves the quadratic-tower criterion, not merely its necessity.
In particular a constructible algebraic number has degree a power of two. Degree alone is not sufficient in general; the exact criterion is containment in a quadratic tower. Equivalently the Galois group of its normal closure is a finite two-group: a tower's normal closure remains a two-extension, and a two-group admits a chain of subgroups with successive index two, yielding the converse by Galois correspondence.
The standard impossibility results follow. Doubling a unit-volume cube requires , whose polynomial is irreducible by Eisenstein and has degree three. Trisecting an arbitrary angle would in particular trisect degrees, requiring , a root of . This cubic has no rational root and is irreducible, so this construction is impossible, although some particular angles can be trisected. Squaring the unit circle requires side length , impossible because is transcendental whereas constructible numbers are algebraic.
For a regular -gon, constructibility is equivalent to that of . The cyclotomic extension is Galois of degree , so it is constructible exactly when this degree is a power of two. Writing the prime factorization of shows the equivalent condition
Indeed odd prime exponents must be one, and each must be a power of two. If is prime, must itself be a power of two by factoring when has an odd divisor. Conversely this factorization makes the cyclotomic Galois group a two-group and provides a quadratic tower. This gives both positive constructions, such as the regular seventeen-gon, and obstructions, such as the regular seven-gon.
For odd prime , every subgroup is one of , , a reflection subgroup for , or . Indeed, a subgroup containing a nonidentity rotation contains all rotations; with any reflection it is then . A subgroup with no nonidentity rotation contains at most one reflection, since the product of distinct reflections is a nonidentity rotation.
The Galois correspondence gives the following fixed fields. The trivial subgroup corresponds to , the rotation subgroup to , and to the base . Since composition of the stated automorphisms gives , the reflection subgroup corresponds to
This rational invariant has degree two, hence generates the fixed field of its order-two subgroup, by the same degree argument as part (i). These fields have degrees respectively over .
An intermediate field is Galois over the base exactly when its corresponding subgroup is normal in . The trivial subgroup, the rotations and are normal; no reflection subgroup is normal because is odd and greater than two. Hence the Galois intermediate extensions and groups are
The reflection fixed fields are not Galois over the base.
For the first field, set . Its field extension degree is four, since is real and adjoining doubles its degree. The polynomial is irreducible over : a reducible cubic would have a root in , but every root has degree three over by Eisenstein criterion, impossible by the tower law because . Thus
For the second field, put . The splitting field is and has degree eight, since is Eisenstein and is real. Define automorphisms and . They satisfy and , and give eight distinct automorphisms. Hence .
The Galois correspondence gives all the subfields in the following table. The middle column records generators, not merely their degrees.
Each displayed generator is fixed by the indicated subgroup. The two last quartic generators have fourth power , so their degree is four by Eisenstein criterion; the other quartic degrees are immediate. These are all the subgroups of and hence all the subextensions.
Put , where is the group of th roots of unity. The compatible Galois groups of the cyclotomic fields give
For odd , the Teichmüller character gives
The p-adic logarithm identifies with , which is topologically isomorphic to . More explicitly, is an isomorphism from the additive p-adic integers onto : the logarithm of has valuation one and generates . Take the fixed field of in .
For , use instead
The p-adic logarithm identifies the second factor with , and identifies it with . The fixed field of in is the union of the maximal real subfields of the cyclotomic fields of -power conductor. Thus in both cases the cyclotomic Zp-extension exists:
where for odd and .
The closed subgroup is the unique subgroup of index , so the Galois correspondence supplies the unique degree- field . In the odd case it is the -fixed field in ; in the even case it is the real subfield of . These finite layers are all totally real number fields.
Now set , , and let be the ordinary Hilbert class field of . Thus is abelian, unramified at finite primes, and split at every real place, with degree . If there is nothing to prove. Otherwise the unique prime over is totally ramified in , by the permitted total-ramification fact and multiplicativity of the ramification index. Any nontrivial intermediate field of is ramified at that prime. Hence
It follows that the two extensions are linearly disjoint field extensions, and
Unramified extensions remain unramified after base change. The real places also remain split: and are totally real, so their compositum is totally real. Therefore lies inside the ordinary Hilbert class field . Its degree divides , proving
This is class number divisibility with split real places; using a class-field statement restricted to imaginary fields would unnecessarily omit the present real layers.
Let . The Galois group sequence is
For and , choose a lift and define
This is independent of the lift because is abelian. Write additively. As an abelian pro-p group, it is a compact -module, with defined by the limit of integer powers, and the conjugation action is continuous and -linear. It extends to the Iwasawa algebra
Indeed, use the finite quotients of obtained by intersecting it with open normal subgroups of ; on each quotient the action factors through one of these finite group rings. This defines the natural compact Galois module structure, even when is not finitely generated. Choosing identifies with through .
The subgroup is closed: it is the image of the compact group under a continuous map. Every element is a commutator of a lift of with . Consequently
Conversely, in the quotient by , the lift of centralizes the image of . Its powers are dense in the procyclic subgroup they generate. Since these powers map densely onto , compactness shows that is generated by and that procyclic subgroup. The quotient is therefore abelian. Hence
One can also see this by choosing a lift of . Since is a pro-p group, the closed subgroup generated by this lift is , and its map to is an isomorphism. This gives a semidirect product splitting.
The maximal abelian subextension is the fixed field of the closed commutator subgroup. Because is abelian, . Restriction of the Galois correspondence to now gives the coinvariant formula
The closed image above is important: the formula is a quotient of compact groups, not a quotient by an unclosed abstract subgroup. This is abelianization over a Zp-extension.
A number-field completion is finite. Let be the given number field and its completion. Normalize its absolute value on a field so that the restriction to is : if , use . Changing the original absolute value by this positive power does not change its completion. The closure of in is an isometric copy of .
Take a -basis of and let be its -span in . Choose a maximal linearly independent subset of that finite spanning set. The compact-sphere proof of finite-dimensional non-Archimedean norm equivalence applies to this basis too, so is complete and therefore closed in . Since is dense in , it follows that . Hence
Every finite extension is obtained this way. Let be finite. Use its extending Non-Archimedean absolute value, whose completeness and uniqueness were proved above. In characteristic zero the primitive element theorem gives ; scaling by a power of , we may arrange that it is integral. Its monic minimal polynomial belongs to . If the degree is one, is already the completion of .
Otherwise choose
where runs over the conjugates in an algebraic closure. Approximate the coefficients of by integers, obtaining a monic of the same degree. Since , sufficiently accurate approximation gives and makes . The strong form of Hensel lemma in produces a root of with .
For completeness, the required Krasner's lemma follows from the unique extension of an absolute value to a finite extension. In a finite Galois extension containing , every automorphism fixing is an isometry, and
If , this contradicts the choice of . Thus every automorphism fixing fixes , and Galois correspondence gives . Since , equality follows. In particular is irreducible over , and therefore over .
Put . It is a number field, and the closure of in contains , so is dense. Let
Every element of the ring of integers of a number field has absolute value at most one: otherwise its highest-degree term would strictly dominate all other terms of a monic integer equation. Thus reduction into the residue field of makes a prime ideal, and . The restriction of the valuation to is the valuation of this prime, up to normalization. Indeed, the localized discrete valuation ring maps into , its units have absolute value one, and its uniformizer has absolute value less than one. Density and completeness give
This proves the local realization as a completion of a number field.
The cyclotomic polynomial is irreducible: replacing by gives an Eisenstein polynomial at seven. Hence the extension has degree six, and
There is one subgroup of each order , and therefore precisely four intermediate fields. The trivial subgroup fixes ; the whole group fixes . The order-two subgroup is complex conjugation and fixes , of degree three: satisfies and is not real.
The order-three subgroup fixes . Its other conjugate is . Expanding products and using gives and . Thus , and this fixed field is , of degree two. These generators have the required degrees and are fixed by the indicated subgroups, so the Galois correspondence proves they are the full fixed fields.
A prime is completely split in an extension of degree exactly when there are primes above it. Indeed, the fundamental identity for prime decomposition is , and every summand is a positive integer. Thus primes means that every ramification index and residue degree equals one, and conversely.
By part (a), the number of primes of above is the number of right -orbits on . This set has elements. It has that many orbits exactly when every orbit is a singleton, equivalently when
This condition says for every , or
the subgroup core.
Because is the Galois closure of , it is generated by all the fields . The fixed field of is , so the fixed field of the core is their compositum, namely . The Galois correspondence therefore gives . Hence
In the Galois extension , the number of primes above is , so is equivalent to complete splitting in . This proves that complete splitting is preserved by Galois closure:
No prior unramifiedness assumption is needed: complete splitting already forces all ramification indices to be one, and the decomposition-group argument includes the ramified case.
The eleventh cyclotomic field has
The cyclic group has exactly one subgroup of each order . The Galois correspondence therefore gives exactly four subfields:
The Quadratic Gaussian period in the eleventh cyclotomic field satisfies , while generates the maximal real subfield of the eleventh cyclotomic field. Every subgroup of the abelian Galois group is normal, so all four subfields are Galois over .
Each nontrivial proper subfield has prime degree, two or five. If , then , and the tower law forces . Thus every such element is a primitive element. The displayed and are the requested examples. Finally, itself is a primitive element for .
The seventh cyclotomic polynomial is
It is irreducible over , and all its roots , , lie in . Hence is a degree-six Finite Galois extension, with
The group is cyclic of order six; for example,
By the Galois correspondence, the subfields are the fixed fields of the four subgroups of :
Thus these are all the subfields.
For the Quadratic Gaussian period in the seventh cyclotomic field, put
The cyclotomic relation gives , while direct multiplication gives . Hence
Its discriminant is , so
For the real cubic subfield of the seventh cyclotomic field, divide
by . With ,
so
This cubic has no rational root, and therefore
The requested primitive elements, minimal polynomials, and automorphism groups are consequently
More explicitly, the nontrivial automorphism of sends
and the three automorphisms of cyclically permute
Finally, is abelian, so every subgroup is normal. The subextensions of an abelian Galois extension theorem shows that
For roots , the discriminant is
and for ,
If is irreducible, its Galois group is transitive in : it is when is a square in , and otherwise. If has one root in and an irreducible quadratic factor, the group is ; if it splits, it is trivial. A repeated-root depressed cubic already has all roots in , so adds no case.
For , the rational-root test proves irreducibility and
is not a rational square. Thus . By the fundamental theorem of Galois theory, the complete subfield list is
where the three cubic fields fix the three order-two subgroups and the quadratic field fixes .
By Dirichlet theorem on primes in arithmetic progressions, choose a prime with
The cyclotomic field is Galois over , and
where the last group is cyclic because the multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic.
The cyclic group has a unique subgroup of order . By the Galois correspondence, its fixed field satisfies
Normality follows because lies in an abelian group. Thus every occurs as the Galois group of a finite extension of . This is the cyclic Galois extension of the rational numbers of every finite degree.
Krasner's lemma says that if is complete, is separable over , and
then .
To prove it, let be an automorphism of fixing . The absolute value has a unique extension to every finite extension of the complete field , so it is invariant under . If , the ultrametric inequality and the displayed strict inequality give
But and invariance gives , a contradiction. Every automorphism fixing therefore fixes , which proves the field inclusion by Galois correspondence.
Now let be finite. By the primitive element theorem, write with separable minimal polynomial . Approximate the coefficients of closely by those of a polynomial of the same degree. Continuity of roots over a non-Archimedean field gives a root of arbitrarily close to . Choose it close enough for Krasner's lemma; then
The degree bound from forces equality. If and is the prime selected by the embedding , its completion is
Thus every finite extension of is the completion of a number field at a prime ideal.
Put . The roots of are , so its splitting field is
The polynomial is irreducible over by the Eisenstein criterion at , and does not contain . The tower law for field extensions therefore gives .
Define automorphisms
They satisfy and . The eight maps and are distinct, so they exhaust the Galois group. Hence
the dihedral group of order eight.
The Galois correspondence gives all intermediate fields. The full list, with a single generator for each field, is
For example, has stabilizer , and has stabilizer ; the other entries follow similarly. Also has trivial stabilizer, so its orbit has eight elements and the primitive element theorem conclusion holds explicitly.
Finally, the normal subextension criterion says that normal intermediate fields correspond exactly to normal subgroups. In these are , , the two index-two Klein four-groups, , and , which gives exactly the “yes” rows above. This is the subfields of the splitting field of x to the fourth minus seven lattice.
For the biquadratic extension , the assumptions say that the square classes of and are independent. In particular : writing and comparing the coefficient of after squaring would force either or to be a square in . Hence
The field is the splitting field of and the characteristic is not two, so it is Galois. Its four automorphisms independently choose the signs of and , giving
By the Galois correspondence, the intermediate-field lattice is
Each of the three middle fields has degree two over , and distinct middle fields intersect in .
Let . Since
part (b) gives . The roots of are , all in , so is its splitting field and is Galois. Its action on the four roots is transitive; the order-eight entry in the list from part (a) is . Therefore
For an explicit dihedral Galois action on four radical roots, define
Then and . The subgroup lattice is determined by
Here lies in all three order-four subgroups; lie in ; and lie in .
Reversing inclusions under the Galois correspondence gives the complete field lattice
The incidence is likewise reversed: lies in ; lies in that field, , and ; and lies in that field, , and . The hint verifies the last two quartic fields through and .
Identify , with and . Its subgroups are
Their fixed fields, in the same layers, are
The real fields are , , and . This is the Galois correspondence.