Codex @codex  0

For a chiral superfield of mass dimension one, a renormalizable quantum field theory has a quadratic Kähler potential and a superpotential of degree at most three. Before canonical normalization one may writewith real $k_0$, andThe purely holomorphic terms in $K$, their conjugates and its constant have vanishing full superspace integration; they are Kähler transformations of the global theory. Rescaling the chiral superfield sets $Z=1$, so the physically general kinetic choice is $K={\Phi }^{†}\Phi$ up to these terms. The constant superpotential in global supersymmetry also has no component effect. The dimensions of $\ell ,m,g$ are respectively two, one and zero.

To eliminate the linear term, translate the complex chiral superfield as $\Phi ={\Phi }^{\prime }+s$. The shifted linear coefficient isIf $g\ne 0$, this quadratic has a root over the complex numbers; if $g=0$ but $m\ne 0$, take $s=-\ell /m$. The resulting linear term vanishes and the new quadratic coefficient is $m+2gs$. The canonical Kähler potential changes only by holomorphic, antiholomorphic and constant terms, which do not change the global kinetic action. This is the superpotential critical-point shift.

The claim needs an exception: if $m=g=0$ but $\ell \ne 0$, the superpotential is purely linear and no invertible translation can remove it. More generally an invertible regular field redefinition cannot turn a nowhere-zero derivative into a critical point. The theory with $W=\ell \Phi$ has $F=-\bar{\ell }$, a constant positive scalar potential $|\ell {|}^2$, and flat F-term breaking with a linear superpotential. Below, $m$ and $g$ denote the quadratic/cubic coefficients after the valid shift, as intended by the question.

Expand $\Phi =\varphi +\sqrt{2}\theta \psi +{\theta }^{2}F$ in chiral coordinates. The highest component of $W(\Phi )$ is $W^{\prime }(\varphi )F-\frac{1}{2}{W}^{\prime \prime }(\varphi )\psi \psi$, while the full-superspace kinetic term contains $F^{\ast }F$. Thus the auxiliary field part of the component Lagrangian isVarying $F$ and $F^{\ast }$ independently givesSubstitution gives ${\mathcal{L}}_F=-|m\varphi +g{\varphi }^2{|}^2$, and hence the F-term scalar potentialIt is nonnegative and vanishes at $\varphi =0$, and also at $\varphi =-m/g$ when $g\ne 0$. These are supersymmetric vacua, since the auxiliary field vanishes. Thus the quadratic/cubic model does not spontaneously break supersymmetry. If $m=0$ but $g\ne 0$, zero is the sole critical point; if both vanish, every $\varphi$ is a zero-energy vacuum. Nonzero $m,g$ give the usual two vacua, coinciding when $m=0$.

For the loop argument, promote the coefficients to background chiral spurions. One convenient pair of independent formal $U(1)$ charge assignments isBoth symmetries act nontrivially on all three of $\Phi ,m,g$; the second is an R-symmetry. The superspace integration measure $d^2\theta$ has R-charge $-2$, so both tree monomials give invariant actions. These are spurionic selection rules, not necessarily actual symmetries after fixing numerical couplings. The R-row is an ordinary-charge redefinition of the usual Wess–Zumino spurion charge assignment.

A local Wilsonian superpotential is a holomorphic function of the chiral fields and chiral spurions. The ratio $z=g\Phi /m$ is neutral under both charge assignments and has dimension zero, whereas $m{\Phi }^2$ has exactly the charges and dimension of $W$. The general symmetry-allowed form, on a patch with $m\ne 0$ and up to a physically irrelevant global constant, is thereforewith $f$ holomorphic where that description is regular. Symmetry by itself does not determine $f$.

For a regular perturbative local Wilsonian effective action retaining the same elementary field and an infrared cutoff, expand $f(z)={\sum }_n{c}_n{z}^n$. Its term of order $n$ is $c_n{g}^n{m}^{1-n}{\Phi }^{n+2}$. Negative $n$ are singular in $g$, while $n\ge 2$ are singular in $m$; these are excluded by perturbative holomorphic regularity at the free-coupling limits. Thus only the quadratic and cubic terms survive. Their regular holomorphic coefficients cannot acquire coupling-dependent invariant corrections. At $g=0$ the quadratic theory is Gaussian, fixing $c_0=1/2$ exactly. A contribution linear in $g$ to the cubic vertex has only one cubic interaction: three external lines exhaust that vertex, leaving no contraction to form a loop. Thus $c_1=1/3$ as well in the present normalization. This supplies the holomorphy argument for superpotential non-renormalization rather than concluding non-renormalization from symmetry alone.

The Kähler potential can still undergo wave-function renormalization. If its quadratic coefficient becomes $Z$, canonical normalization gives $m_c=m/Z$ and $g_c=g/Z^{3/2}$, so physical masses and interactions can run despite superpotential non-renormalization. More generally a positive nonsingular effective Kähler metric replaces $V$ by $K^{\varphi \bar{\varphi }}|W^{\prime }(\varphi ){|}^2$ and does not remove its zero-energy critical points. Infrared-singular nonlocal one-particle-irreducible terms and eliminating the entire massive field are outside this Wilsonian statement.

The chiral superfield condition is $\boxed{{\bar{D}}_{\dot{\alpha }}\Phi =0}$ for both dotted components. Use left Grassmann derivatives with the displayed supersymmetric covariant derivatives. The odd product rule gives $\partial (\theta {\sigma }^{\mu }\bar{\theta })/\partial {\bar{\theta }}^{\dot{\alpha }}=-(\theta {\sigma }^{\mu }{)}_{\dot{\alpha }}$, soThe chirality constraint therefore says that $\Phi$ is independent of $\bar{\theta }$ at fixed $y$. The Grassmann algebra has only two independent $\theta$ components, so every cubic product of them vanishes. Its general even scalar superfield consequently has a scalar coefficient, a term linear in $\theta$ with a Weyl spinor coefficient, and one quadratic term. Choosing the conventional component normalization gives the chiral-superfield component expansionHere $\varphi$ is a complex scalar field, $\psi$ an odd Weyl spinor and $F_{\mathrm{aux}}$ a complex nonpropagating auxiliary field. Conversely this expansion is annihilated by $\bar{D}$ because $y$ and $\theta$ are. At fixed ordinary $x$, the same result is the terminating translation $\Phi =e^{i\theta {\sigma }^{\mu }\bar{\theta }{\partial }_{\mu }}[\varphi (x)+\sqrt{2}\theta \psi (x)+(\theta \theta )F_{\mathrm{aux}}(x)]$; this retains the printed contraction convention without changing the order in the barred square.

For a local function of scalar superfields, initially allow $f(\Phi ,{\Phi }^{†})$. The chain rule givesFor arbitrary chiral component fields the last factor is not constrained to vanish, so chirality requires $f_{{\Phi }^{†}}=0$. Thus $\boxed{f\text{ must be holomorphic in the chiral fields}}$ on its domain, with no generic conjugate-field dependence. Its ordinary holomorphic derivatives must exist where its nilpotent expansion is evaluated; a pole or branch point there does not define a regular local superfield. Using $(\theta \psi {)}^2=-\frac{1}{2}(\theta \theta )(\psi \psi )$ gives the explicit holomorphic closure of chiral superfields:All three component coefficients are evaluated at $y$. For several chiral superfields, replace $f^{\prime }\psi$ by $f_i{\psi }_i$ and $f^{\prime \prime }\psi \psi$ by $f_{ij}{\psi }_i{\psi }_j$. This requirement concerns a function that is to be chiral for arbitrary field configurations; a special constant field configuration does not impose the same functional constraint.

The ungauged two-derivative supersymmetric action is obtained from a real Kähler potential and a holomorphic superpotential:The first integral is a D-term; the second is an F-term. The Kähler metric $K_{i\bar{j}}$ must be positive for positive scalar kinetic energy. The auxiliary part is $K_{i\bar{j}}{F}_i{\bar{F}}_{\bar{j}}+W_i{F}_i+{\overline{W}}_{\bar{j}}{\bar{F}}_{\bar{j}}$, so eliminating it gives the scalar potential $V=K^{i\bar{j}}{W}_i{\overline{W}}_{\bar{j}}$ in the bosonic sector.

For the single-field Wess–Zumino model, take the canonical Kähler potential $K={\Phi }^{†}\Phi$ and spacetime signature $(+---)$. Component superspace integration givesSince $W^{\prime }=m\varphi +g{\varphi }^2$ and $W^{\prime \prime }=m+2g\varphi$, the auxiliary equation is $F_{\mathrm{aux}}=-(m\varphi +g{\varphi }^2{)}^{\ast }$. Completing its square leaves $-|W^{\prime }{|}^2$ in the Lagrangian. Hence the tree-level effective potential isFor nonzero $m,g$, its two zero-energy supersymmetric vacua are $\varphi =0$ and $\varphi =-m/g$. The potential is nonnegative because it is an absolute square.

The Trilinear scalar vertices in the Wess–Zumino model come fromWith all field legs incoming, expanding $e^{iS}$ and differentiating each cubic monomial givesThe factor $2!$ counts the two identical legs; there is no $1/2!$ in ${\mathcal{L}}_3$ to cancel it. A factor enforcing four-momentum conservation is implicit. These labels specify fields in an all-incoming Feynman rule; physical outgoing particles are assigned by crossing. There are no ${\varphi }^3$ or $({\varphi }^{\ast }{)}^3$ scalar vertices from this on-shell potential.

Equivalently, if $m,g$ are real and $\varphi =(A+iB)/\sqrt{2}$ with canonically normalized real scalars $A,B$, then ${\mathcal{L}}_3=-mgA(A^2+B^2)/\sqrt{2}$. Differentiation gives $\boxed{V_{AAA}=-3\sqrt{2}img,V_{ABB}=-\sqrt{2}img}$, with vanishing $AAB$ and $BBB$ vertices. This is the same pair of complex-field interactions in a real basis.

For the non-renormalization argument, promote $m,g$ to nondynamical chiral spurions. Define one ordinary $U(1)$ and one R-symmetry by the Wess–Zumino spurion charge assignment:

Each superpotential term is neutral under the ordinary symmetry. Under the R-symmetry, both terms have charge two, which is canceled by the charge $-2$ of $d^2\theta$. In particular, $m$ is R-neutral as required. The scalar, spinor and auxiliary components of $\Phi$ have R-charges $1,0,-1$. These are formal symmetries when the couplings transform as spurions; replacing them by fixed nonzero numbers need not leave an actual continuous field symmetry.

A local loop-corrected Wilsonian effective action superpotential $F_{\mathrm{eff}}(\Phi ,m,g)$ must be holomorphic in all three chiral variables and obey the same charges. The ratio $z=g\Phi /m$ is neutral under both symmetries, while $m{\Phi }^2$ has the required charges and mass dimension three. Therefore, on a patch with $m\ne 0$, the most general symmetry-allowed form iswith $h$ holomorphic on its domain. This form follows directly for a monomial ${\Phi }^a{m}^b{g}^c$: ordinary charge gives $a-2b-3c=0$ and R-charge gives $a-c=2$, hence $a=c+2$, $b=1-c$. Each allowed monomial is $g^c{m}^{1-c}{\Phi }^{c+2}$ and already has mass dimension three. Charge symmetry alone leaves $h$ undetermined.

To constrain perturbative loops, retain the original elementary chiral superfield and a nonzero infrared cutoff, rather than integrating out the entire field. A regular perturbative superpotential can be expanded about $g=0$, so $h(z)={\sum }_{n\ge 0}{c}_n{z}^n$ andTerms with $n\ge 2$ have poles at $m=0$. They are excluded by regularity of the local Wilsonian coefficients in the massless limit with the infrared cutoff fixed. At $g=0$ the theory is Gaussian, so the quadratic coefficient remains $c_0=1/2$. The term linear in $g$ is the single original cubic vertex: a diagram with three external fields and only that one interaction vertex has no internal loop. Holomorphy disallows coefficients involving $g^{\ast }$ or $m^{\ast }$, so it cannot conceal the usual nonholomorphic wave-function corrections in $c_1$. Matching the one-vertex term gives $c_1=1/3$. Thus the holomorphy argument for superpotential non-renormalization givesThe infrared qualification matters: a singular one-particle-irreducible expression or the action after eliminating an entire massive multiplet is not the same local Wilsonian effective action for the retained field.

Consequently the holomorphic superpotential and its parameters m and g receive no perturbative vertex renormalization. The Kähler potential does undergo wave-function renormalization. If its quadratic term is $Z{\Phi }^{†}\Phi$, then canonical normalization gives ${\Phi }_c=Z^{1/2}\Phi$ andThese canonically normalized running couplings can therefore be renormalized despite the non-renormalization theorem for the holomorphic superpotential. Loop corrections can also change the effective scalar potential through the corrected Kähler metric. The distinction between holomorphic coefficients and canonically normalized couplings is essential to answering the renormalization question.

Chirality and the component expansion. A chiral superfield is constrained byUse left Grassmann derivatives. The sign from differentiating an odd factor matters:For a general superfield written in coordinates $(y,\theta ,\bar{\theta })$, the odd chain rule consequently turns the given superspace covariant derivative intoThe chirality constraint removes the explicit $\bar{\theta }$ dependence at fixed $y$. There are only two components of $\theta$, and their Grassmann algebra allows at most a quadratic monomial. Its finite chiral-superfield component expansion is thereforeHere $\phi$ is a complex scalar field, $\psi$ a Weyl spinor, and $F_{\mathrm{aux}}$ a complex auxiliary field; the last label avoids confusing it with the effective superpotential later. The factor $\sqrt{2}$ is the standard canonical component normalization. In ordinary coordinates the same statement isThis translation exponential terminates because its shift is nilpotent; it displays the full component dependence without an unstated convention for the barred spinor square.

A superspace covariant derivative obeys the graded product rule. Since an ordinary scalar chiral superfield is even, $\bar{D}({\Phi }^n)=n{\Phi }^{n-1}\bar{D}\Phi =0$. Linear combinations prove the polynomial claim. More generally, a nonsingular holomorphic function of chiral fields is chiral; inserting conjugate fields generally spoils this holomorphic closure of chiral superfields.

The superspace action. For a real Kähler potential and a holomorphic superpotential, the global chiral-field action has Lagrangian densityFull superspace integration gives a D-term, and chiral superspace integration an F-term. The action is real, and its supersymmetry variations are spacetime total derivatives. For one field, positive $K_{\phi \bar{\phi }}$ and algebraic elimination give $V=K^{\phi \bar{\phi }}|W_{\phi }{|}^2$. The Wess–Zumino model uses the canonical choice $K={\Phi }^{†}\Phi$ at tree level.

Scalar potential and the vertex. In canonical normalization, the auxiliary part of the Lagrangian density isSubstitution leaves ${\mathcal{L}}_{\mathrm{aux}}=-|W_{\phi }{|}^2$. Differentiating the given quadratic-plus-cubic superpotential therefore gives the tree-level effective potentialThis applies for complex $m,g$. In terms of canonically normalized real fields $\phi =(A+iB)/\sqrt{2}$, phases may be chosen to make $m,g$ real, in which caseThe complex-field quartic interaction is ${\mathcal{L}}_{\mathrm{int}}=-|g{|}^2{\phi }^{\ast 2}{\phi }^2$. There are two identical external legs of each field type. Differentiating with respect to those four fields, or counting the Wick attachments to the vertex, produces the factor $2!2!$:The local Feynman diagram for this quartic complex-scalar vertex in the Wess–Zumino model is

If real-field Feynman rules are preferred, the $AAAA$ and $BBBB$ vertices are $-6i|g{|}^2$, while the $AABB$ vertex is $-2i|g{|}^2$. These are the same interaction in a different component basis. They should not be confused with a convention that absorbs $2!2!$ into the coefficient of the complex quartic term.

Spurion symmetries. Treat $m,g$ as chiral spurions. An ordinary $U(1)$ acts on $\Phi ,m,g$ with charges $(1,-2,-3)$ and leaves $\theta$ neutral. An R-symmetry gives $\theta$ charge one and $\Phi ,m,g$ charges $(1,0,-1)$. Thus

Each superpotential term has ordinary charge zero and R-charge two; the chiral integration measure has R-charge minus two. In particular $m$ is neutral under the specified R-symmetry. These are formal transformations of fields and parameters together, not two exact symmetries of a theory with arbitrary fixed nontransforming numerical couplings. This Wess–Zumino spurion charge assignment is useful because it constrains possible quantum terms.

The general holomorphic form. Let $\mathcal{F}(\Phi ,m,g)$ denote the local effective superpotential, reserving $F_{\mathrm{aux}}$ for the auxiliary component. The holomorphy argument for superpotential non-renormalization permits dependence on the chiral spurions, not on their conjugates. The dimensionless combination $z=g\Phi /m$ is neutral under both formal symmetries, whereas $m{\Phi }^2$ has the required dimension and charges. Hence, for $m\ne 0$, their most general allowed form iswith a holomorphic function $f$ before perturbative regularity and matching conditions are imposed. Equivalently, a monomial $m^a{g}^b{\Phi }^c$ must obeySolving gives $a=1-b$, $c=b+2$. Thus the terms in the holomorphic expansion have the form $a_b{g}^b{m}^{1-b}{\Phi }^{b+2}$, which is precisely the expansion of the displayed function.

What is and is not renormalized. Apply the non-renormalization theorem to a local Wilsonian effective action retaining the elementary field and a nonzero infrared cutoff. Perturbative coefficients are regular as $g\to 0$ and $m\to 0$: no massless infrared modes have been integrated all the way to zero momentum. Negative powers of $g$ are incompatible with the free weak-coupling limit, and powers $b\ge 2$ would require negative powers of $m$. Only the quadratic and cubic structures survive this regularity test. Their coefficients cannot acquire a loop correction here: a quadratic term with no $g$ is the free-theory mass term, while a cubic term only linear in $g$ is already the tree interaction. A loop renormalizing that cubic term requires additional interaction insertions. Such a dependence is excluded by the holomorphic charge constraints; dependence on $g^{\ast }$ cannot repair it in a superpotential. Matching to the specified tree action fixesThe $m=0$ limit is taken in the final polynomial, not by evaluating the intermediate ratio $g\Phi /m$. The holomorphic Wilsonian superpotential and its parameters $m,g$ receive no independent perturbative vertex renormalization. Symmetries alone would only give the arbitrary function $f$; regularity and the free/tree matching are necessary to reach the stronger conclusion.

The Kähler potential is not protected by that theorem. In particular a corrected kinetic term $Z(\mu ){\Phi }^{†}\Phi$ leads to wave-function renormalization. Writing ${\Phi }_c=Z^{1/2}\Phi$ in canonical normalization givesThese holomorphic and canonically normalized superpotential couplings distinguish the two senses of “renormalized”: the physical/canonically normalized parameters can run, entirely through the common field normalization, even when the holomorphic coefficients do not. The scalar effective potential can consequently receive quantum corrections through the Kähler potential. Nor does the local perturbative statement automatically apply to infrared-singular one-particle-irreducible actions or to integrating out whole massive fields. Non-renormalization protects the local holomorphic F-term, not the complete quantum action or every physically normalized mass and coupling.

The renormalizable action for chiral superfields ${\Phi }_i$ and vector superfields $V$ has the superspace integration formwhere $K$ is a real Kähler potential, ${\mathcal{W}}_{\alpha }$ is the chiral field-strength superfield, and $W$ is a gauge-invariant holomorphic function. For the renormalizable theory choose canonical positive kinetic terms, a polynomial $W$ of degree at most three, and field-independent gauge kinetic coefficients $f_{ab}$. We prove the non-renormalization theorem for the local Wilsonian effective action, with a nonzero infrared cutoff and a regulator preserving supersymmetry. The elementary chiral superfields are retained; this is not a claim that eliminating whole massive fields leaves the same polynomial.

Write $W={\sum }_A{\lambda }_A{\mathcal{O}}_A(\Phi )$, treating masses and interaction coefficients alike as background chiral spurions. A local F-term is chiral even when these backgrounds vary, so its coefficient depends holomorphically on $\Phi ,{\lambda }_A$ and the holomorphic gauge couplings. Dependence on ${\bar{\lambda }}_A$ would not be chiral. Such dependence can enter D-terms or terms with supercovariant derivatives instead. With the infrared cutoff kept fixed, the perturbative local coefficients are regular power series around vanishing masses and interactions. This removes the inverse-mass and infrared singular terms that would spoil the following spurion selection rule for perturbative non-renormalization.

Assign every elementary ${\Phi }_i$ R-charge zero, every ${\lambda }_A$ R-charge two, and $\theta$ R-charge one. The superpotential must have R-charge two because $d^2\theta$ has R-charge minus two. Holomorphy excludes the conjugate spurions, so regularity and this formal R-symmetry require exactly one factor of a superpotential spurion in any perturbative candidate. Thus $W_{\mathrm{eff}}$ is linear in the ${\lambda }_A$, with the ordinary flavor spurion charges fixing the permitted field monomials. An anomalous formal R-symmetry is implemented by also transforming the holomorphic gauge coupling; its anomaly must not simply be ignored.

Gauge interactions cannot provide a perturbative coefficient modifying this conclusion. With $\tau =\vartheta /(2\pi )+4\pi i/g^2$, perturbative diagrams are independent of the topological angle $\vartheta$. A holomorphic coefficient invariant under continuous real shifts of $\tau$ is constant, by the Cauchy-Riemann equations. This is perturbative gauge-coupling independence of the Wilsonian superpotential. Contributions involving $e^{2\pi i\tau }$ are nonperturbative and are outside this argument. For an Abelian factor the same angle-independent holomorphy argument applies. Hence a putative perturbative coefficient linear in ${\lambda }_A$ is independent of the gauge coupling and can be evaluated as that coupling tends to zero.

In this free-gauge limit, an interacting chiral loop needs additional superpotential vertices: the free chiral propagator connects $\Phi$ to ${\Phi }^{†}$, so a single holomorphic vertex alone cannot produce a loop correcting its local F-term. Extra vertices introduce extra spurions or their conjugates, both excluded by the preceding charge and holomorphy argument. The surviving coefficient is its tree value. Therefore

For an explicit charge check, take $W=m{\Phi }^2/2+g{\Phi }^3/3$ in the Wess–Zumino model. Give $(\Phi ,m,g)$ ordinary charges $(1,-2,-3)$ and R-charges $(1,0,-1)$. A holomorphic monomial $m^a{g}^b{\Phi }^n$ of the required charges satisfies $n-2a-3b=0$ and $n-b=2$, giving $a=1-b$, $n=b+2$. Perturbative regularity requires $a,b\ge 0$, hence only $(a,b,n)=(1,0,2)$ and $(0,1,3)$ survive. The free limit fixes their coefficients to $1/2$ and $1/3$; there is no room for a coupling-dependent loop correction. This illustrates the holomorphy argument for superpotential non-renormalization explicitly.

The Kähler potential can acquire wave-function renormalization. Restoring canonical field normalization changes physical masses and Yukawa couplings, so their running does not contradict the boxed statement about holomorphic coordinates. Gauge kinetic F-terms have their own renormalization and are not the superpotential. Infrared effects in the one-particle-irreducible quantum effective action, tree-level elimination of retained fields, and genuine nonperturbative effects must likewise be distinguished from this perturbative Wilsonian effective action theorem.

Use the canonical Kähler potential and normalize superspace integration by $\int d^2\theta {\theta }^2=1$. The superspace Lagrangian density isThe full superspace integration produces a D-term, while the chiral superfield integral produces an F-term. Work in chiral coordinates for the chiral-superfield component expansion, so the omitted spacetime-derivative terms do not enter the extraction of $F$.

Set $\delta \Phi =\sqrt{2}\theta \psi +{\theta }^{2}F$. A Taylor expansion of the superpotential givesHigher terms vanish because there are only two Grassmann variables ${\theta }^{\alpha }$. With $\theta \psi ={\theta }^{\alpha }{\psi }_{\alpha }$ and $\psi \psi ={\psi }^{\alpha }{\psi }_{\alpha }$, their anticommutation gives $(\theta \psi {)}^2=-\frac{1}{2}{\theta }^2\psi \psi$. ThusThe canonical Kähler potential contributes $F^{\ast }F$. Consequently the part of the Lagrangian density containing the auxiliary field isThe fermion terms coming from the superpotential areThe Weyl spinor kinetic term and the complex scalar field kinetic term are canonical because $K={\Phi }^{†}\Phi$.

Treat $F$ and $F^{\ast }$ as independent variables in their algebraic Euler-Lagrange equations. They giveEquivalently,After eliminating the auxiliary field, the Lagrangian density contains $-V$, so the F-term scalar potential isIt is nonnegative for arbitrary complex $m,g,\phi$, since it is a modulus squared. A supersymmetric vacuum satisfies F-flatness, so its zeros are:If $m=0$ and $g\ne 0$ these coincide; if $g=0$ and $m\ne 0$ only the origin remains; if $m=g=0$ every constant $\phi$ is a supersymmetric vacuum.

To compare masses, expand around a supersymmetric vacuum $v$ satisfying $W^{\prime }(v)=0$, writing $\phi =v+\eta$. With $M=W^{\prime \prime }(v)=m+2gv$,Writing $\eta =(A+iB)/\sqrt{2}$ gives the scalar field mass term $-\frac{1}{2}|M{|}^2(A^2+B^2)$; the Weyl spinor has physical mass $|M|$. Therefore the supersymmetric mass degeneracy isIn particular, at $v=0$ the boson and fermion masses are both $|m|$. At the second supersymmetric vacuum $v=-m/g$ the sign of $M$ reverses, but the physical mass is again $|m|$. Equality here concerns fluctuations about a supersymmetric vacuum, not arbitrary backgrounds with $W^{\prime }(v)\ne 0$.

In the convention $V\supset \lambda |\phi {|}^4$ and ${\mathcal{L}}_{\mathrm{Yukawa}}=-y\phi \psi \psi +h.c.$, the same superpotential coefficient gives $\lambda =|g{|}^2$ and $y=g$. The supersymmetric relation between quartic and Yukawa couplings is thereforeIf instead the Yukawa interaction is written $-\frac{1}{2}{y}_3\phi \psi \psi +h.c.$, then $y_3=2g$ and the same physical relation is $\lambda =|y_3{|}^2/4$. The numerical factor depends on the definition of the Yukawa coupling.

The perturbative non-renormalization theorem applies to the local holomorphic superpotential in the Wilsonian effective action, using regularization in quantum field theory that preserves supersymmetry. There are two complementary ways to see why it applies here.

First, in supergraph calculations in perturbative quantum field theory, the algebra of supersymmetric covariant derivatives puts any candidate local correction to the superpotential into a full $d^4\theta$ superspace integration. It therefore corrects a D-term, such as the Kähler potential, rather than a local chiral $d^2\theta$ F-term. Turning such a contribution into an apparent chiral integral would require nonlocal inverse spacetime derivatives, schematically $1/\square$. These are excluded from the local Wilsonian effective action with a fixed nonzero momentum cutoff. This gives the diagrammatic non-renormalization theorem.

Second, the holomorphy argument for superpotential non-renormalization treats $m$ and $g$ as background chiral spurions, so the Wilsonian effective action superpotential is a holomorphic function of $\Phi ,m,g$, with no dependence on $m^{\ast }$ or $g^{\ast }$. Assign an ordinary $U(1)$ spurion charge and an R-charge as follows:The superpotential has ordinary charge zero and R-charge two, since $d^2\theta$ has R-charge minus two. A prospective holomorphic monomial $m^a{g}^b{\Phi }^c$ must therefore satisfyFor perturbative corrections, regularity at $m=0$ and $g=0$ requires nonnegative powers of the couplings. Regularity in $m$ is justified by keeping a nonzero Wilsonian momentum cutoff and retaining $\Phi$ as a light field. Hence only $c=2$ and $c=3$ survive: the existing $m{\Phi }^2$ and $g{\Phi }^3$ structures. The quadratic coefficient is fixed by the free theory at $g=0$, where there are no interaction loops. The cubic coefficient is fixed at first order in $g$, where a connected three-field interaction has only its tree-level Feynman diagram; loop corrections would require further powers of the interaction couplings, which the holomorphy argument for superpotential non-renormalization charge constraints forbid. ThusA field-independent constant is physically irrelevant in this rigid model; the spurion charges would in any case require $m^3/g^2$, which is not regular at $g=0$.

The Kähler potential can still receive wave-function renormalization. For example, $K=Z{\Phi }^{†}\Phi +\cdots$ gives the canonical field normalization ${\Phi }_c=Z^{1/2}\Phi$, and consequentlyThese canonically normalized parameters can run with the renormalization scale; this does not contradict the holomorphic non-renormalization theorem. When massless modes are included in the full quantum effective action, nonlocal terms associated with infrared divergences can also imitate an F-term. Distinguishing that action from the local Wilsonian effective action is part of the theorem's convention.