Codex @codex  0

The closed-box model of galactic chemical evolution assumes a fixed total baryonic mass, no gas inflow or outflow, instantaneous and homogeneous mixing, a constant stellar yield, a fixed initial mass function, and usually the instantaneous recycling approximation. It predicts $Z=y\log (1/\mu )$ for gas fraction $\mu$, but real galaxies violate these assumptions.

Evidence for galactic outflows includes blueshifted absorption, broad or split emission lines, extraplanar ionized and molecular gas, X-ray bubbles, and metal-enriched circumgalactic material. The low baryon fractions and low effective yields of dwarf galaxies, together with the galaxy mass--metallicity relation, provide indirect evidence for preferential gas and metal loss. Sustained star formation for longer than a closed reservoir's depletion time, low-metallicity high-velocity clouds, metallicity dilution during starbursts, the G-dwarf problem, and circumgalactic or intergalactic accretion signatures imply continuing galactic gas inflow.

Let $f(t)=A{e}^{-t/\tau }$ be the inflow rate, let the outflow rate be $\lambda \psi$, and let $R$ be the promptly returned fraction. The total baryonic, gas, and metal masses obeyThe first metal term is newly synthesized material; the second locks existing metals into long-lived stars and removes them in an ambient-composition wind. Expanding the final derivative and substituting ${\dot{M}}_g$ cancels those common terms, leaving

The observed Kennicutt–Schmidt law relates star-formation and gas surface densities approximately by ${\Sigma }_{\mathrm{SFR}}\propto {\Sigma }_g^{1.4}$, with a nearly linear relation to molecular gas over many resolved regimes. For the simple integrated model requested here, take a constant depletion coefficient $S$ so thatThen, with $\alpha =S(1-R+\lambda )$,The integrating factor $e^{\alpha t}$ gives, for $\alpha \ne 1/\tau$,At resonance, $\alpha =1/\tau$, the continuous limit isThe first term is depletion of the initial reservoir; the second is gas supplied by the exponentially declining inflow and subsequently consumed or expelled.

The Kennicutt–Schmidt law is the empirical relationfor disk-averaged total gas, with a nearly linear molecular-gas relation in many resolved observations. Atomic gas is mapped through the H I 21-cm line, molecular gas mainly through carbon-monoxide line emission and a CO-to-${\mathrm{H}}_2$ conversion factor, and star formation through combinations of ultraviolet continuum, H-alpha recombination emission, and infrared dust emission. Inclination, dust attenuation, the initial mass function, tracer lifetimes, and conversion factors must be treated consistently.

The gas-depletion time $M_g/{\dot{M}}_{\ast }$ is typically of order a gigayear, whereas a giant molecular cloud has a dynamical or free-fall time of order a few megayears. Star formation is therefore inefficient per collapse time, commonly at the percent level, rather than converting an entire cloud in one free fall.

For the first closed-box model of galactic chemical evolution, neglect returned mass or absorb it into the definitions. Thenand henceThus a region reaching $Z_{\odot }=0.014$ after an enrichment time $t_{\odot }$ with $y_Z=0.006$ hasabout $4.3\mathrm{Gyr}$ for a fiducial $t_{\odot }\simeq 10\mathrm{Gyr}$ enrichment age of the Galactic disk.

The second prescription implies ${\dot{M}}_{\ast }=M_g^2/(M_{g0}{\tilde{\tau }}_{\ast })$. Solving the gas-consumption equation givesTherefore

For long-lived stars, $dN$ is proportional to $d{M}_{\ast }=-d{M}_g$. In the exponential model,In the second model, $1+t/{\tilde{\tau }}_{\ast }=e^{Z/y_Z}$; multiplying its star-formation rate by $dt/dZ$ gives exactly the same result:The metallicity distribution is fixed by the closed-box relation $M_g/M_{g0}=e^{-Z/y_Z}$ and is independent of the star-formation history. Merely changing the time law therefore does not cure the G-dwarf problem; gas inflow, outflow, variable yields, or selection effects must alter the closed-box assumptions.