Use for . On this path , so its line integral is
The first two components of the curl vanish because the field is independent of and has zero third component. Writing , its third curl component is
Thus this azimuthal inverse-radius vector field is a curl-free vector field on , but its line integral is not path independent. This domain is not simply connected: the circle links the removed axis. A spanning disk through the axis is inadmissible for Stokes theorem, since the vector field is undefined there. Zero curl alone does not force global path independence.
The curl is constant:
Orient the spanning planar disk by the unit normal and orient its boundary by the right-hand rule, equivalently counterclockwise when viewed from the side towards which points. Stokes theorem converts the line integral to a constant flux integral through a disk of area . With this orientation
Reversing the orientation changes the sign. The centre of the circle does not enter because the curl is constant.
Symmetry of the derivative matrix means . Contracting this symmetric pair with the antisymmetric Levi-Civita symbol gives
Every circle bounds its planar disk, and the vector field is smooth on all of , including that disk. Stokes theorem therefore gives for either orientation
The global domain is essential to this argument; the same local symmetry condition on a domain with a hole need not make every closed-curve line integral vanish.
A conservative vector field on is a vector field for a globally defined smooth potential of a conservative vector field . The chain rule gives
so its line integral is path independent.
Green theorem states that, for a bounded planar region with piecewise smooth boundary and continuously differentiable on a neighbourhood of its closure,
The boundary is positively oriented: the region lies on the left while it is traversed, so outer components run counterclockwise and hole boundaries clockwise.
For the proposed potential of a conservative vector field, the fundamental theorem of calculus and differentiation under the integral sign give
Since , the last integral equals , including negative with the usual signed-integral convention. Hence the proposed potential is global and
The fact that the vector field is defined on all of ensures both straight integration segments stay inside its domain; a hole in the domain could obstruct a global potential.
Integrating the oscillatory term together with the constant components gives a potential of a conservative vector field
Direct partial derivatives recover both components of , proving it is a conservative vector field. Its line integral is therefore path independent. At an integer endpoint , the sine term vanishes, so for any of the specified paths
Any other potential has the same gradient, so differs from by a constant on the connected plane. In particular every potential changes by under and by under . Equivalently the integral from to is , whereas a unit-periodic potential would make that difference zero. There is no potential periodic with period one in both coordinate directions. This is an example of how periods obstruct a periodic potential: a periodic vector field need not have a periodic potential.
Differentiating the assumed primitive identity and using Cartan's magic formula gives
Apply the pullback of a differential form by and rearrange:
This smooth family of Hamiltonian functions proves that is a Hamiltonian isotopy in the convention of part (b).
To connect this with the preceding assertion that every is an exact differential form, the smooth choice of primitives causes no additional obstruction. Fix and normalize . Define by the line integral of from to . The fundamental theorem for line integrals makes this independent of the path. Near any , use one fixed path to a nearby chart center followed by coordinate line segments; this expression is smooth jointly in . Thus these normalized primitives form the required smooth family.
Parametrize the straight segment by , , . The line integral becomes
Because is constant, . The coordinate speed along the circle is consequently
so
For the convention in the question, take , so and .
On the circular solution, the free part of the relativistic charged-particle action is
In the gauge , the interaction is the closed line integral
The orbit is clockwise for , so . Thus
Combining the two terms and using gives the charged-particle action over one relativistic cyclotron orbit
Although the intermediate magnetic line integral depends on the chosen magnetic vector potential, the closed-orbit result is gauge invariant.
Path independence Created 2026-09-29 Updated 2026-10-03
A line integral is path independent when its value depends only on the two endpoints. On a connected domain, this holds for the line integral of every exact differential.
If a periodic vector field has a periodic potential of a conservative vector field, the line integral between points separated by a period vector must vanish, since it is the potential difference. A periodic gradient field need not satisfy this: the constant field on the plane has potential , but its integrals over the two unit translations are and . On the periodic quotient these translation integrals are nonzero periods, obstructing a single-valued potential there.