Take the outward wavenumber ; the absolute value in the source makes the two propagation directions equivalent. The phase velocity of the gravity-capillary wave obeys
Differentiate with respect to :
The second derivative is positive, and at both ends of the positive- range, so this is the global minimum. The minimum phase speed of a gravity-capillary wave is
For and the supplied surface tension and mass density,
The corresponding wavenumber is , giving wavelength . At this minimum, . Thus the group velocity and phase velocity agree for this particular ripple, although they differ for general gravity-capillary waves.
Put and take the positive-frequency branch for . The phase velocity and group velocity are
Since the square root is increasing, minimizing is equivalent to minimizing . Its derivative is , which changes sign from negative to positive at
The phase speed diverges at both positive endpoints and , so this stationary point is its global minimum. At , , giving
The relative speed is especially transparent:
A narrow wave packet moves with , while its crests move with . For , : crests move forward through the packet, from its rear towards its front. For , : crests drift backwards relative to the packet, although both absolute velocities are positive. At the leading-order relative drift vanishes. This is the minimum phase speed of a gravity-capillary wave.
Figure 1.
Phase and group speeds cross at the minimum phase speed; crest drift relative to the packet reverses there
. Details.
The free surface is material, so applying the material derivative to gives the exact kinematic boundary condition
For an incompressible fluid with constant density, the Euler equations are
Since the flow is irrotational, and . Integrating the resulting gradient equation gives a function of time on the right of Bernoulli equation. Adding a time-dependent constant to removes that function, without changing velocity, and choosing the atmospheric-pressure reference gives
The pressure immediately above the surface is atmospheric; the liquid-side pressure includes the stated surface tension jump.
At first order in wave amplitude, the products and , the slope-squared correction to curvature, and displacement corrections in evaluating at are all higher order. Hence, on ,
For , a harmonic velocity potential decaying as and satisfying the first condition is
Indeed and . Substituting in the second condition yields the dispersion relation for a gravity-capillary wave:
Taking the positive-frequency branch, the phase velocity and group velocity are
Subtracting gives
Since ,
The threshold is also the wavenumber at the minimum phase speed of a gravity-capillary wave.
Figure 1. . The curves meet at dimensionless wavenumber one, where the phase speed is minimal. Details.
For a monochromatic wave, a constant phase moves at phase velocity . For a narrow wave packet around , expansion shows that its envelope moves at group velocity . The envelope interpretation requires a sufficiently narrow spectrum and weak distortion; it is not a general identification with a causal signal front. Since and ,
For the gravity-capillary wave, put and take . Direct differentiation gives
Thus when , or
At this wavelength the gravity and surface-tension restoring terms contribute equally. Also with positive second derivative: this is the minimum phase speed of a gravity-capillary wave, . Locally the carrier crests and narrow envelope travel together. The medium has not become nondispersive: there, so a finite wave packet can still spread. In the gravity-dominated limit ; in the capillary-dominated limit it tends to .