Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2001 iii Paper 77 4 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Let be the set of finite weakly decreasing sequences of positive integers, together with the empty sequence; equivalently pad them indefinitely with zeros. The size is , the length counts positive parts, and consists of size- integer partitions. Their Young diagrams have cells with .
Diagram containment is the partial order defined by for every . Componentwise minimum and maximum give its meet and join, so this is Young's lattice. Its covers add one cell. On the dominance order on partitions isIt is not diagram containment: distinct equal-size diagrams cannot contain one another. For the reverse lexicographic order on partitions, use the descending-dictionary convention: when the first unequal pair of parts has . Thus for size four its increasing list is . This is a total order opposite to increasing dictionary order on integer partitions, not the last-differing-exponent order on polynomial monomials.
Define the elementary symmetric functions and complete homogeneous symmetric functions byFor a partition, write and . The monomial symmetric function sums each monomial with exponent multiset once.
Here is a proof of the Fundamental theorem of symmetric polynomials sufficient for the stable algebra. In variables, the lexicographically largest monomial of a symmetric homogeneous polynomial has exponents . Otherwise exchanging an inverted pair of variables produces a larger monomial with the same coefficient. The polynomialhas that monomial as its largest one, with coefficient one. Subtract a suitable multiple and continue; there are only finitely many monomials of the fixed degree, so the procedure terminates and proves generation. Distinct products have distinct largest exponents . The largest such monomial in any nonzero polynomial relation cannot cancel, proving algebraic independence. Stabilizing in each degree, where only with no greater than that degree can occur, gives
The two generating functions satisfySince the freely generate, there is a unique algebra homomorphism with . Apply it to the last identity:It follows that and . Hence the symmetric-function involution is an involutory automorphism, and
For the forgotten coefficients, it is useful to derive the required duality explicitly. Put . The logarithmic generating-function identities giveThe transition a polynomial in lower-index 's is triangular and invertible over , so the are also free generators and is a basis. Define the Hall inner product of symmetric functions byExpand the same formal kernel in two ways:The last expansion is a reproducing kernel for this inner product. Comparing it with the expansion gives . One can see this without assuming any Schur orthogonality: pair either kernel with ; the reproducing property gives , and uniqueness of its expansion proves the duality. The signs in show that is an isometry; together with this makes it self-adjoint.
If and , define the forgotten symmetric function . Its monomial coefficient is consequentlyIt remains to compute this coefficient rather than merely invoke duality. Expand the formal inverse as a geometric series in :In , choose a positive composition of each . A term is precisely when the concatenated list is a distinct rearrangement of the parts of . Its boundaries at the end of each chosen composition are exactly the prescribed prefix sums of . Conversely such a rearrangement uniquely determines the compositions by cutting at those prefix sums. Every one of its signs is , canceled by the prefactor in . ThusIdentical parts are not artificially distinguished. For example : only the order refines , while both orders refine the single block .
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2001 iii Paper 77 5 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
A skew Young diagram is the difference of two nested Young diagrams. A semistandard Young tableau is a filling of precisely those cells by positive integers, weakly increasing along each occupied row and strictly increasing down each occupied column. It can be viewed as its filled diagram, or equivalently as a chainwhere is a horizontal strip consisting of the cells labeled . Indeed, the weak row and strict column inequalities ensure that the cells labeled at most , together with , form a partition diagram, and equal labels cannot share a column. Conversely such a chain gives the tableau.
For a tableau , let count its entries , put , and defineThere are finitely many tableaux for any fixed number of allowed letters, and the sum has total degree .
To prove symmetry directly, use a Bender-Knuth involution for each adjacent pair of letters . Pair any and that occur in the same column and leave them fixed; strictness makes them consecutive in that column. In a row the remaining unpaired entries have the form , between any fixed paired letters. Replace that block by . Rows stay weakly ordered. A free can be changed to without equaling the entry below, because such a below entry would have been paired with it; likewise changing a free to cannot equal the entry above. Other neighboring letters are outside , so strict columns are preserved. The paired cells remain the same, and repeating the operation restores each free block. The paired letters contribute equally to the two contents, while every free block exchanges its contributions. Thus the involution is a weight-preserving bijection after exchanging . Adjacent exchanges generate all finite variable permutations, provingThe skew Jacobi–Trudi identity gives a second proof, since its determinant entries are already symmetric.
Define the Kostka number to count straight-shape Semistandard Young tableaux with shape and content , meaning copies of label . Suppose such a tableau exists. Strict columns imply that an entry in row is at least . Therefore all entries from lie in the first rows, givingHenceFor content , the copies of have nowhere to go except row one and fill it. The copies of then fill row two, and induction fills row with . This filling exists and is unique, so .
Symmetry identifies equal coefficients for each rearrangement of a content, henceThe monomial symmetric functions form a basis. In any total order extending dominance, this change-of-basis matrix is triangular with diagonal one. It is invertible in each degree, so