Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2015 Paper 1 Section B B9 Solution 2026-10-20
Exchange constraint. Exchange of two identical particles cannot change physical predictions. For the usual three-dimensional bosonic or fermionic state space, the exchange operator obeys , so its allowed eigenvalues are . bosons use the symmetric overall wavefunction, ; fermions use the antisymmetric overall wavefunction, . Exchange includes the spatial coordinates and all internal labels. The identity alone does not prove which particle species has which statistics; that assignment is the Spin-statistics theorem.
Factored fermion states. If and both factors have definite exchange symmetry, their exchange signs must multiply to . Thus a symmetric spatial factor requires an antisymmetric spin factor, and an antisymmetric spatial factor requires a symmetric spin factor. For two spin-one-half particles, the former spin factor is the singlet ; the latter factors are the three triplet states. A more general entangled spin-space state need not factor, but must still be antisymmetric overall.
hydrogen spin isomers. The two protons are identical spin-one-half fermions. parahydrogen has total nuclear spin , the antisymmetric singlet; orthohydrogen has , the symmetric triplet. Here is a spin quantum number, distinct from the moment of inertia used below.
Rotational restriction. In the electronic and vibrational ground state, these two factors are symmetric under nuclear exchange. Exchanging the protons reverses the internuclear axis, . The spherical harmonic rotational state contributes the exchange sign . Overall antisymmetry therefore requiresHence parahydrogen has even ; orthohydrogen has odd . The here labels molecular rotation, rather than the angular momentum obtained by also coupling the nuclear spins.
Conversion heat. The ortho-para conversion heat follows from the linear rigid rotor approximation, with . Thus conversion of one molecule from to releasesNeglecting the small electron contribution to the molecular mass, a sample of mass contains molecules. Only the initial orthohydrogen fraction releases this energy, givingThe estimate uses pm, kg and J s. Handbook-level rounding and the rigid rotor approximation justify about three significant figures, not a high-precision thermochemical prediction.[ref]
Storage consequence. The internal conversion is a delayed heat source even in a well insulated container, causing warming or additional evaporation of the liquid. Insulation reduces external heat transfer but does not remove this source. Converting to predominantly parahydrogen during liquefaction, while removing the released heat, reduces the subsequent storage heat load. No evaporation fraction can be calculated without a latent heat and a model for how the heat is removed.