Past exam of the fluids course of the University of Oxford / 2022 / 1 / c / Solution

Under spherical symmetry, the continuity equation and Darcy's law giveHence $q_r=C/r^2$, and integrating the pressure gradient from infinity givesThe boundary condition at $r=a$ fixes $C={\Pi }_{1}a\Delta p/\eta$. Therefore spherical Darcy injection hasHere $q_r$ is the superficial Darcy velocity, not the pore velocity $q_r/\phi$.

For the comparison, assume geometrically similar pore networks, equal porosity, the same source radius and far boundary geometry, and equal pump efficiency. Dimensional analysis then gives ${\Pi }_1=C_{\mathrm{geom}}{d}^2$ with the same dimensionless factor. ConsequentlyAt a fixed desired volumetric flow rate, the required excess pressure and pumping power areAquifer A requires half the pumping power at equal throughput, or half the energy to inject the same volume over the same time. This compares the excess pressure-volume work dissipated by the Darcy flow; any different baseline compression or other plant costs need separate accounting.

The imposed comparison matters. At fixed $\Delta p$, A takes twice the volumetric flow rate and twice the instantaneous power, but the same excess energy per injected volume. The pore spacing alone does not determine permeability of a porous medium if network geometry or porosity changes; without the geometric assumptions the preference cannot be inferred from $d$ alone.