Past exam of the genetics course of the University of Cambridge / 2025 / Paper 2 / 2 / Solution

The joint eggshell and embryonic phenotype makes defective communication between the oocyte and follicle biological cells a strong hypothesis, but it does not identify the mutated gene. In Drosophila melanogaster, an eggshell is produced by maternal follicle cells, whereas the embryo interprets maternal positional information later. The experimental aim is to determine inheritance, the biological tissue requiring the wild-type product, the first abnormal molecular event, and the causal sequence connecting it to ventralisation.

First establish a reproducible phenotype. Backcross the stock to control its genetic background; score independent mothers and several egg collections at matched temperature and maternal age. Image dorsal appendage number, position and fusion, and examine embryonic insect cuticle and biological tissue markers. Record unhatched and fertilised eggs separately. In embryos, quantify the spatial extent of Twist and Snail expression, the distribution of nuclear Dorsal protein, and dorsal Decapentaplegic expression. Expanded ventral molecular identities, rather than lethality or abnormal shape alone, establish embryonic ventralisation. Appendage defects alone are insufficient because their formation has additional regulatory requirements.

Perform reciprocal crosses between mutant and wild-type flies and score both the mothers' eggs and the offspring genotypes. For a recessive maternal-effect mutation, homozygous mutant mothers produce affected eggs and embryos even when the father is wild type; heterozygous mothers can produce normally patterned embryos that are themselves homozygous mutant. A zygotic-effect mutation instead tracks the embryo's genotype. Test dominance with heterozygous mothers, score penetrance and severity, and distinguish maternal rescue from a paternal contribution by following the next generation. Do not impose a simple Mendelian ratio if the lesion is sex-linked, semidominant or affects fertility.

Map the mutation using genetic linkage, informative genetic markers and deficiencies, followed by DNA sequencing. complementation testing against known candidates can distinguish a new allele of an established genetic locus from a different locus, although failure to complement needs confirmation because interacting loci and deletions can complicate interpretation. Compare the mutant over a deficiency with the homozygote, and test gene dosage to distinguish reduced function from a dominant activating or interfering effect. The decisive causal package is rescue by a suitably expressed wild-type genomic copy, recreation of the candidate sequence change in a clean background, and reversal by precise repair. Check that rescue restores both eggshell and embryonic pattern, rather than merely viability.

The normal information flow supplies a series of discriminating readouts. Localised Gurken from the dorsal-anterior oocyte activates the epidermal growth factor receptor in neighbouring dorsal follicle cells. This represses Pipe there, leaving its activity ventrally restricted.^[ref] The modified extracellular environment biases a proteolytic cascade that activates Spätzle; this ligand activates Toll receptor ventrally. Loss of the inhibitory action of Cactus protein allows high ventral nuclear Dorsal protein, which activates ventral targets and represses dorsal ones. Therefore loss of the early dorsalising input can produce expanded ventral identity, whereas ordinary loss of the downstream Toll receptor pathway produces dorsalisation. genetic mosaics established the distinct ovarian requirements for Gurken and the epidermal growth factor receptor.^[ref]

Use genetic mosaics to make mutant germ biological cells within wild-type ovarian soma, and mutant follicle cell clones around wild-type germ biological cells. Mark clones independently and verify their size and location. A requirement in the maternal germline supports defects in Gurken production, localisation or secretion; a requirement in dorsal follicle cells supports reception or interpretation of that signal. Include wild-type clones generated by the same procedure and tissue-specific wild-type rescue. If both compartments contribute, test whether the locus has two functions rather than forcing it into one category.

Then localise the first defect during oogenesis. Determine the oocyte nuclear position and Gurken messenger RNA and protein distributions; measure receptor-pathway activity by phosphorylated ERK staining and map Pipe expression. Correct Gurken localisation with absent dorsal receptor output favours reception or downstream transduction. Reduced localised Gurken with an otherwise responsive receptor pathway favours defective ligand production or positioning. Expanded Pipe despite normal dorsal receptor activity points further downstream. Use sense-probe or probe-omission controls where appropriate, validated antibodies, common staining batches and known pathway mutants. Temporal staging matters: a late normal-looking pattern cannot exclude an earlier transient failure.

Apply epistasis and bypass tests with explicit predictions. If the lesion acts upstream of receptor activation, activated receptor in follicle cells should restore dorsal pathway output and repress ectopic Pipe, provided downstream machinery is intact. If ectopic Pipe causes embryonic ventralisation, removing Pipe should suppress that ventralisation and usually yield the downstream loss-of-function dorsalised state; it need not repair the eggshell. Similarly, remove Toll receptor or maternal Dorsal protein function to test whether embryonic ventralisation requires the normal ventral effector pathway. Persistence after a verified downstream block demands an alternative mechanism or multiple lesions. Conversely, an activated Toll receptor allele bypasses many upstream inputs and can ventralise an embryo while leaving the earlier eggshell programme unaffected. Suppression of an embryonic defect and restoration of the eggshell are different rescue criteria.

Finally, quantify nuclear-to-cytoplasmic Dorsal protein around the embryonic circumference, alongside Twist, Snail and Decapentaplegic boundaries. Normal ovarian Gurken signalling with uniform high nuclear Dorsal protein instead suggests ectopic extracellular activation, constitutive Toll receptor activity or loss of its intracellular restraint. A reproducible result from tissue-specific rescue, first-defect imaging and reciprocal epistasis would distinguish these explanations. Neither resemblance to a known mutant nor a candidate sequence variant alone establishes how this novel lesion acts.