Past exam of the physics 1 paper of the University of Oxford / 2015 resit / 2 / Solution

The disc carries mass $M_d=2M/3$ and the thin rim carries $M_r=M/3$. About the wheel's central normal axis, add the moment of inertia of a uniform disc and the thin rim's moment of inertia:Treat the wheel as a thin planar lamina, as implied by the disc-and-thin-rim model. Interpret the requested perpendicular axis as perpendicular to the wheel's original axis and tangent to the rim: if the wheel lies in the $xy$ plane, choose the tangent line $x=R,z=0$, parallel to the $y$ diameter. By rotational symmetry, the two diametral moments of inertia are equal. The perpendicular axis theorem therefore givesThe parallel axis theorem then gives the tangent-axis inertia of an axisymmetric lamina:The axis direction matters. If “perpendicular” were intended to mean perpendicular to the wheel's plane, an axis through a rim point would instead be parallel to the original wheel axis, giving $I_{\mathrm{rim},\mathrm{normal}}=I_z+M{R}^2=5M{R}^2/3$. The $4M{R}^2/3$ answer uses a tangent axis perpendicular to the original axis; the $5M{R}^2/3$ value belongs to the different, explicitly identified normal axis. Finite wheel thickness would require additional information for the in-plane moment of inertia.