Past exam of the quantum matter course of the University of Oxford / 2025 / 1 / d / Solution

At $N=M$, the two spin occupations per site are $x$ and $1-x$. With $\tau =|t|>0$, the trial energy per site isIts derivative is $e^{\prime }(x)=-4\tau \cos (\pi x)+V[4x-2-(2/\pi )\sin (2\pi x)]$. Since $x=0$ is a boundary point, its local minimum test is one-sided: $e^{\prime }(0)=-4\tau -2V$. At $V=-2\tau$, where this derivative vanishes, its Taylor series begins $e(x)-e(0)=(2{\pi }^2\tau /3)x^3+O(x^4)>0$ for small positive $x$. HenceThe same applies to $x=1$ by spin interchange.

The symmetry $e(x)=e(1-x)$ makes $x=1/2$ a stationary point for every $V$. Here $e^{\prime \prime }(1/2)=4\pi \tau +8V$, so the second-derivative test settles all cases except equality. Writing $y=x-1/2$, at $V=-\pi \tau /2$ the Taylor series is $e(1/2+y)-e(1/2)=({\pi }^3\tau /6)y^4+O(y^6)$. ThusThe minimizing branches interpolate continuously. To find all of them, put $u=\pi (1/2-x)$ on $0<x<1/2$. An interior stationary point obeysThe right side decreases strictly from $-\pi /2$ to $-2$, sinceThe positivity follows from $u-\sin u\cos u={\int }_0^{u}2{\sin }^{2}vdv$. There is therefore exactly one such stationary point on each side of $1/2$ when $-2<V/\tau <-\pi /2$. The signs of $e^{\prime }$ show that both are global minima, whereas $1/2$ is then a local maximum. The complete answer isThe pair merges through a supercritical pitchfork bifurcation at $V/\tau =-\pi /2$. Comparing only $e(0)$ and $e(1/2)$ would miss the intervening ground states with partial spin polarization.