Past exam of the superconductivity and Quantum Coherence course of the University of Cambridge / 2015 / Paper 1 / 1 / c / Solution

The superconducting order is a coherent pair amplitude, schematically $\Delta \propto ⟨c_{\downarrow }{c}_{\uparrow }⟩=|\Delta |e^{i\varphi }$. Under a global fermion phase change $c\mapsto e^{i\alpha }c$, it acquires phase $2\alpha$. A symmetry-broken thermodynamic description selects a pair phase. This must be distinguished from electromagnetic gauge freedom: a local gauge transformation changes the phase and potentials together and is a redundancy of the description, not an observable symmetry that the material literally violates.

A conventional centrosymmetric s-wave superconductor usually has an even-parity orbital pair state and a spin singlet state, consistent with the antisymmetry of two fermions. Its ordinary zero-field equilibrium state preserves time reversal. The electromagnetic coupling makes phase dynamics and screening part of the Anderson-Higgs mechanism in a superconductor; the Meissner effect is a measurable consequence. The condensate phase description does not imply that electric charge is no longer conserved.

In an unconventional superconductor, the gap can transform nontrivially under the crystal point group or have other nonstandard pairing structure. A common example is d-wave superconductivity, with sign changes and possible nodes in the gap. This does not automatically imply an additional observable fourfold-rotation breaking: a rotation that reverses the gap's sign can be accompanied by a gauge phase change. A nematic superconducting state instead breaks an actual crystal rotation symmetry in its gauge-invariant responses.

A chiral combination such as $p_x+i{p}_y$ can break time reversal, while a spin-triplet order parameter can also distinguish spin directions when the applicable spin-rotation and spin-orbit constraints permit it. Helium-3 superfluidity illustrates paired-fermion order with richer spin and orbital structure. These possibilities must be tested rather than equated: unconventional pairing does not by itself mean spin-triplet pairing, time-reversal breaking, or nematicity. Gap angular dependence, phase-sensitive interference, spin response and spontaneous magnetic signatures probe different symmetry questions. The phase-sensitive test of d-wave pairing is more specific than inferring a gap sign merely from its magnitude.