Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2019 ii Paper 2 34B Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-03
For a normalized trial state , expand it in an orthonormal basis of energy eigenstates, . The Rayleigh quotient is thenThis is the quantum variational principle: minimizing the expectation of the Hamiltonian operator over any trial family gives an upper bound on the ground-state energy.
Let be the normalized ground-state wavefunction and form the normalized dilation . Its kinetic and potential expectations areThe true ground state makes the energy stationary at , soThus the power-law quantum virial theorem gives
If and , the two sides have opposite signs, because and . If , the scaled energy tends to as , since , so the Hamiltonian is not bounded below. If , the free particle has no normalizable ground state. Hence there is no normalizable ground state for .
For take the normalized Gaussian functionThe Gaussian integral givesand thereforeIts unique minimum satisfiesAt this point , consistently with the virial theorem, and the resulting variational estimate is
Quantum variational principle Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
The quantum variational principle estimates the lowest energy by choosing a trial wavefunction and computing its expectation value, without solving the Schrödinger equation exactly. Minimizing over a manageable family of trial wavefunctions gives an upper bound; enlarging that family can improve the estimate.
Let be a self-adjoint operator bounded below, and put . For in its operator domain ,Trial states may also lie in the form domain , where . Then use the quadratic form of a positive quantum Hamiltonian shifted by :This extends the expectation value beyond without requiring to exist. Equality for a normalized state holds exactly in the energy eigenspace at , if that eigenvalue exists. [ref]
https://www.mat.univie.ac.at/~gerald/ftp/book-schroe/schroe.pdf. Gerald Teschl, Mathematical Methods in Quantum Mechanics, Theorem 2.19 and equations (3.50)–(3.51)
.A short proof makes the direction of the bound memorable. If has a complete orthonormal basis of energy eigenstates , writeThe expectation value is a weighted average of allowed energies:Equality requires every occupied energy eigenstate to have energy . [ref]
https://live.ocw.mit.edu/courses/8-05-quantum-physics-ii-fall-2013/61bc31b8d8bf0680c322733910a71aa0_MIT8_05F13_Chap_01.pdf. Barton Zwiebach, MIT 8.05 Wave Mechanics, section 5, Variational Principle
. With continuous spectrum, the spectral theorem replaces the sum by an integral against the scalar spectral measure; the same nonnegative-difference argument works.For an unnormalized trial wavefunction, divide by its squared norm: is the form version of the Rayleigh quotient. The quantum variational principle supplies an upper bound on ; it supplies neither a lower bound on nor, by itself, a guarantee that a bound state exists.
To see the method at work, choose the real Gaussian wave packetThe Gaussian integral gives wavefunction normalization and the two useful position averages:Thus its position probability density is a normal distribution with standard deviation : large means narrow confinement. In units , integration by parts and give the kinetic energyThese smooth, rapidly decaying trial wavefunctions belong to the operator domains of both polynomial Quantum Hamiltonians below. Narrowing the Gaussian wave packet increases its kinetic energy; widening it increases the potential energy in either confining potential.
For the quantum harmonic oscillator, take :The trial values at are respectively . The derivative changes sign at , where kinetic energy and potential energy are both . Here the trial family contains an exact ground state:The zero-point energy remains positive even at the best width. For comparison, removing the potential leaves as : the free Quantum Hamiltonian on the line has spectral bottom zero but no normalizable zero-energy energy eigenstate. A sequence of ever broader trial wavefunctions need not approach an actual bound state.
Gaussian trial widths and the kinetic–potential energy tradeoff
. Normalized Gaussian wave packets with have different position probability densities. The bars show the competing kinetic energy and harmonic potential energy ; their sum is smallest at . Details.For a pure quartic oscillator, keep and set the quartic coefficient to one:The trial values at are respectively . Setting the derivative to zero givesThe sign of this derivative changes from negative to positive at the optimum, giving the smallest energy within this Gaussian wave packet family:At this width, and , so , as expected from the power-law quantum virial theorem for a scale-optimized trial wavefunction. The number is an upper estimate of the ground-state energy, not an asserted exact energy eigenvalue. Indeed,depends on for every , so no member of this trial family is an energy eigenstate. Nevertheless, a single width parameter already turns a difficult Schrödinger equation into a useful, explicit energy estimate.

