In a negligible-mass, non-burning stellar envelope with and Kramers' opacity law , the stellar radiative temperature gradient is . It decreases inward as the temperature rises, so the inner edge of efficient convection is where it equals . If outer matching gives , then , since and . Hence .
The global Eddington closure , combined with a representative stellar gas-pressure fraction, makes the exterior stellar radiative temperature gradient approximately when the luminosity is constant outside the core. Matching it to the adiabatic temperature gradient estimates the displayed boundary mass. This is a closure estimate: imposing exactly uniform throughout a finite-mass radiative envelope also conflicts with constant luminosity, as described by the constant-beta radiative-envelope obstruction.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2006 iii Paper 71 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Consider a small outward displacement of a fluid element. It adjusts to the ambient pressure while retaining its specific entropy and stellar composition, so an adiabatic process gives . Its excess mass density over the new surroundings is, to first order,Restoring buoyancy requires this bracket to be positive. With , the Schwarzschild criterion is thereforeEquality is neutral stability. For uniform mean molecular weight, the ideal gas law gives . Since hydrostatic equilibrium pressure decreases outward, the inequality is equivalent to . Dividing the radiative diffusion in a star and hydrostatic equilibrium stellar structure equations givesThis is the stellar radiative temperature gradient test for stellar convective stability.
In the thin upper stellar atmosphere take , and use gas pressure dominance. The prescribed opacity becomes . Dividing the two structure equations then yieldsAt zero optical depth, the atmospheric boundary has and negligible gas pressure. Integrating from that boundary, with , givesTo locate the onset, put . Logarithmic derivative gives , henceThis starts at zero at the outer boundary and increases inward. It first reaches atThe corresponding optical depth is , so the onset lies inside the stellar atmosphere. This is grey-atmosphere convection onset with thirteenth-power opacity.
Let the interior of the fully convective star have , with spatially constant. At its boundary is fixed, so the atmospheric pressure formula givesThe Stefan–Boltzmann law, with , consequently impliesThe ideal gas equation transforms the interior relation intoFor completeness, the mass-radius scaling follows by taking and with . Hydrostatic equilibrium and mass conservation reduce to the Lane-Emden equation , with , . Its fixed dimensionless profile gives and . Eliminating gives , or . Thus at fixed stellar composition. Equating this with the atmospheric expression gives , and henceThis Hayashi relation with thirteenth-power opacity concerns the interior of a fully convective star beneath a thin stellar atmosphere. The coefficient may vary between stars; spatially constant specific entropy does not mean equal specific entropy across the whole sequence.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2007 iii Paper 66 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For the Schwarzschild criterion, displace a small gas parcel upwards. Assume its composition is unchanged, it remains in pressure balance with its surroundings, and it moves quickly enough that heat exchange is negligible. The parcel obeys the adiabatic equation of state . Combining this with the ideal gas equation gives , so its adiabatic temperature gradient is .
Let the surrounding temperature gradient be . For an upward displacement , the parcel's temperature relative to its new surroundings isIf , this is negative: the parcel is cooler and, at equal pressure and composition, denser than its surroundings. It therefore sinks back; a downward displacement likewise gives a restoring buoyancy force. If the inequality is reversed, the displaced parcel continues to rise. The stability condition is thusEquality is the neutral boundary. There is no composition-gradient term because the ideal-gas parcel and the background have the same mean molecular weight.
In the thin upper stellar atmosphere, take a plane-parallel approximation with constant , optical depth increasing inward, and zero overlying pressure . Hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth gives . The ideal gas equation converts the stipulated opacity intoDefine , so the given grey atmosphere relation is . Integrating from the surface givesThis proves the required pressure law. In particular times a function only of and .
For the grey-atmosphere convection onset with density-linear opacity, differentiate the two profiles to obtain the radiative temperature gradient:It increases monotonically from zero, since , and first reaches the adiabatic temperature gradient at . ThereforeBelow this point the radiative stratification is unstable and convection must transport some of the outward energy flux.
At the outer convection boundary, depends only on , so and for fixed . The matching constant in is . ConsequentlyThis temperature form of the polytropic relation follows from an ideal monatomic adiabat; its is not the density-polytrope coefficient in Question 3.
For the deep radiative boundary beneath a power-law-opacity convective envelope, negligible envelope mass and absent local energy generation give and . Divide the radiative temperature equation by the pressure equation to get the stellar radiative temperature gradientThis is the gradient that would be needed if radiation alone carried , and it is the quantity to compare with even while the actual region is convective. The deeper Kramers' opacity law gives . Substituting yieldsAs rises inward this decreases, so the transition back to a stable radiative interior is atThus . Using the outer matching and the Stefan–Boltzmann law,The mass and radius cancel. Hence, at fixed opacity coefficients and composition,This uses the same adiabat through the convection zone and distinguishes its inner transition temperature from its outer onset temperature.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 55 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
In stellar homology, the dimensionless radial profiles are the same after scaling radius, enclosed mass, pressure, temperature and luminosity. At corresponding radii let , , , and . The printed is understood as this local radial scaling, with surface radius .
Let and keep composition, opacity coefficient and nuclear coefficient fixed first. Mass conservation gives , and hydrostatic equilibrium gives . The ideal gas law then gives . Scaling the stellar energy-generation rate equation and the stellar radiative temperature gradient gives respectivelyThe second follows from , not from energy production. Equating the two luminosity scalings givesThis assumes the denominator is nonzero and a consistent homologous family exists. If the mean molecular weight differs by , then andRatios of the opacity and energy-generation coefficients multiply the right-hand side. Thus fixed composition is a real restriction, not an automatic property of every stellar sequence.
Use the Stefan–Boltzmann law to locate the family on a Hertzsprung-Russell diagram. It implies andFor proton–proton chain burning take the usual local approximation , with Kramers' opacity law , . ThenFor the CNO cycle with electron-scattering opacity, , soA conventional local choice gives and slope . Choosing instead gives slope . The source specifies no numerical nuclear exponents, and the effective exponent changes with temperature; the general expression is the unambiguous answer.
Idealized radiative homology branches on a Hertzsprung-Russell diagram, with pp exponent 4 and CNO exponent 16
. Details. The Hertzsprung-Russell diagram places hotter stars to the left. Its branches rise toward higher luminosity and mass, and the CNO cycle/electron-scattering opacity branch has the steeper logarithmic slope. Their illustrative joining point and normalization are arbitrary because the proportional opacity and reaction laws do not specify absolute stellar scales. These are the fully radiative ideal-gas homology predictions, not exact observed main sequence relations: convection and increasing radiation support limit those assumptions in real stars.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2015 iii Paper 58 3 c Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
Let , , , and . Consider a small radial fluid displacement whose sound-crossing time is short enough to keep its pressure equal to its surroundings. Its composition is frozen and its heat exchange negligible. This is the local stellar convective stability test.
For gas-pressure-dominated ideal gas matter, . The ambient gradient is thereforeThe displaced element conserves specific entropy and mean molecular weight, giving , where . The parcel-minus-environment mass density difference isIts buoyancy acceleration is minus times this difference. ThusPositive stellar buoyancy frequency squared gives a restoring force. The gas-pressure-dominated Ledoux criterion is thereforeEquality is marginal in this ideal adiabatic test. For monatomic gas . An inward increase of mean molecular weight has and stabilizes the layer; uniform composition recovers the Schwarzschild criterion. For a radiative layer one substitutes the stellar radiative temperature gradient, .
More generally define and . The same displacement argument gives and stability for . Both coefficients equal one in the gas-dominated ideal-gas limit used above. This is local dynamical stability against convection; it is distinct from global radial collapse and from instabilities requiring heat or composition diffusion.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 iii Paper 317 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
Let denote specific entropy, reserving from the first question for envelope thickness. The stellar adiabatic exponents are defined at fixed composition byIt is useful to introduce , so .
Take the stellar gas to be a fully ionized, nonrelativistic monatomic ideal gas, with fixed specific gas constant . Its mixture with thermal radiation hasHere is specific internal energy, and the stellar gas-pressure fraction is . The assumption of monatomic gas fixes its heat capacity; the perfect-gas pressure law alone would not determine it.
At fixed and fixed , respectively, the pressure derivatives areFor an isentropic process, the first law of thermodynamics gives . Differentiate the internal energy rather than artificially holding fixed during the perturbation:The parenthesis is , givingSince ,Using the relation between the exponents gives the adiabatic exponents of a monatomic gas-radiation mixtureThe requested values, including the adiabatic temperature gradient, areThe pure-radiation and pure-gas rows are understood as limits of the mixture.
For uniform composition, the Schwarzschild criterion for stellar convective instability isTo test whether a radiative configuration becomes unstable, use its required stellar radiative temperature gradient for . Since , the equivalent radial condition isAn outward-displaced parcel then cools less than its new surroundings, remains less dense at the same pressure, and is further accelerated outward.
The requested Eddington-model convective-core mass fraction follows from the usual global constant- closure. At the outer radiative surface, put , , and . Dividing the radiation-pressure gradient by the stellar hydrostatic equation givesThere is no energy generation outside the convective core, so use there. The local radiative-gradient formula isThe same representative has been used in the global luminosity closure and at the boundary. Setting this gradient equal to at producesThis is , , and for , respectively, with a marginal radiation-dominated limit.
There is a consistency qualification to this last model estimate. It cannot be an exact stellar solution if all the printed assumptions are enforced pointwise. An exactly uniform nonzero radiation fraction would give at every radiative point. The exact equations would then requireIf is constant throughout an envelope with positive mass density, increases with radius, so this equality cannot hold there. Equivalently uniform fixes the actual gradient to , whereas for . The boxed core fraction is the intended Eddington closure and boundary estimate, which relaxes exact constancy of in the detailed envelope. The constant-beta radiative-envelope obstruction identifies the missing approximation; it is not legitimate to silently assert exact compatibility.
