Borromean handle-pair evaluation 2026-10-25
For a charge- component threading a pair of zero-framed auxiliary components in the standard Borromean rings surgery arrangement, color both auxiliary components by the normalized Kirby color. Relative to the bare strand, eliminating this pair contributes . The two-strand Kirby projector applied to the two oppositely oriented portions of the component supplies a factor at each of the two eliminations. This local evaluation underlies the surgery calculation of the handle-cut formula for anyon ground-state degeneracy.
Borromean link group 2026-10-14
With group commutator convention , the displayed group presentation describes the fundamental group of the Borromean rings complement. Its abelianization is , since each relator is a group commutator and hence imposes no abelian relation. It embeds discretely in the Gaussian Bianchi group by sending the meridians to , and .
Use the Witten-Reshetikhin-Turaev invariant with the source's normalized Kirby color on all surgery components. Since the signature of the linking matrix is zero, the framing-anomaly factor is one, and the TQFT partition function isAll evaluations in this part use the isotopy normalization of anyon diagrams and preserve the indicated blackboard framing.
Expand the long component as and fix its charge . Each pair of auxiliary components is in the Borromean rings arrangement with this component. Eliminate such a pair using the two-strand Kirby projector from c: bend the long component to expose its two oppositely oriented portions, viewed as equally oriented strands labeled . The first encircling normalized Kirby color loop replaces these by a vacuum cup-cap with coefficient . This vacuum connection opens the second encircling loop so that the same two-strand Kirby projector applies once more. Removing the resulting vacuum edges and straightening the bends restores the original charge- strand. Thus the Borromean handle-pair evaluation multiplies the bare strand byThere is no residual twist. This is a relative strand evaluation: the final closure of the long component is counted separately. As a normalization check, when the two auxiliary components become two unlinked normalized Kirby color loops, each of value , giving .
The pairs occupy disjoint portions of the long component, so their factors multiply. Closing that component gives its quantum dimension . Combining this with its normalized Kirby color coefficient givesApplying the overall surgery prefactor yieldsFinally, the topological quantum field theory assigns the identity map to a cylinder over . Closing its time direction takes the trace of that identity, soThis independently reproduces b. For the surgery link is one zero-framed normalized Kirby color unknot: its value cancels the surgery prefactor and gives . For the result is the number of simple anyons, as required for the torus.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2005 iii Paper 19 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
We use . To obtain a Wirtinger presentation, choose an oriented regular knot diagram, cut its strands at undercrossings, and give each resulting arc a positively oriented meridian of a knot. The complement of the arcs above the projection plane has a free fundamental group on these meridians. At a crossing, pushing an understrand meridian past the overstrand conjugates it by the overstrand meridian. Thus, if is the overstrand generator and are the incoming and outgoing understrand generators, the relation is , where is determined by the crossing orientation. Applying the Seifert-van Kampen theorem while adjoining the crossing neighborhoods gives one such relation per crossing. The remaining three-dimensional region adds no fundamental-group relation. For a connected diagram one crossing relation is redundant. This derives a group presentation from any tame knot diagram, rather than just specifying a recipe without its topological justification.
For the Borromean rings, choose three meridians and call the other three arc meridians . Base paths and orientations can be chosen so the six crossing relations readEliminate the primed generators with the first row. The second row says respectively that commutes with , that commutes with , and that commutes with . The last relation is redundant, just as one crossing relation is redundant in the Wirtinger presentation. Alternatively the Hall-Witt identity, after conjugating its three factors, shows that any two of these cyclic relations imply the third. Hence the Borromean link group isBoth relators have zero exponent sum in each generator. Passing from the free group to its abelianization therefore imposes no relations beyond commutation, andEquivalently the three linking-number maps to independently detect the three meridians.
Here is an explicit representation, followed by a faithfulness argument:Each determinant is one. Direct multiplication verifies the two relators. For example , which commutes with . Merely checking those relators would not prove faithfulness, so we identify the image's complete group presentation.
Write , the Gaussian Bianchi group, and use its four generators from the allowed presentation. In the three proposed generators areThe last equality is in , so an overall minus sign in matrix multiplication is immaterial. Reduce matrices modulo in , and then quotient by . The finite image has order : the residue field is , has order six, and each of the three subsequent local-ring layers has a kernel of order , before the final quotient by . Elementary elimination over this local ring shows that the images of generate it. The subgroup has order , as multiplication in this finite ring verifies. Let be its inverse image in ; then .
For completeness the following gives the coset computation needed to check the subgroup presentation explicitly. Cosets are right cosets ; columns record right multiplication by . Representatives are words in the allowed generators.Apply the Reidemeister–Schreier theorem: for a transition , use generator , omitting the 23 tree transitions. Rewrite each of the eight allowed ambient relators starting at each of the 24 rows. There are 73 remaining Schreier generators. Adjoin the names , , and eliminate the Schreier generators using relations in which they occur once. The remaining relations, with an uppercase letter denoting the inverse of the corresponding lowercase one, are the wordsThis table and the rewriting rule determine every relation without an appeal to a guessed presentation. In this notation cyclically reduced versions of the two desired relators are and . Elementary substitutions of relator segments, with cyclic reduction at each step, giveusing ; conversely using . These substitutions show equality of the two normal closures. For example the first substitution replaces in the cyclic rotation of by , as allowed by , and then the initial is replaced by using . Thus has exactly the presentation of , with represented by . In particular these three matrices generate , and
To identify the actual link complement as a hyperbolic three-manifold, rather than only on a manifold with an isomorphic group, cut along the projection-plane regions, making the usual small crossing detours above and below. The octahedral projection graph has eight triangular regions. The upper and lower pieces are ideal octahedra; corresponding faces are matched with one-third-turn corner permutations, with opposite directions on adjacent checkerboard faces. Reversing these cuts reconstructs the link complement. Give both pieces the regular ideal hyperbolic space octahedron metric. All triangular face maps are isometries and each edge cycle has four dihedral angles , so the metric has no edge singularity. Equal horospherical truncations match in Euclidean squares and assemble into three flat tori, giving complete torus cusps. The compact truncated remainder and these cusps show completeness and finite volume. Thus the Borromean complement is a complete finite-volume hyperbolic three-manifold. This also supplies a geometric discrete faithful holonomy, independently of the subgroup calculation.