All geometric 2-torsion is rational: its points are . We will construct the required finite quotient directly, without assuming any theorem about finite generation or two-descent on an elliptic curve.
Choose with and define the halving cocycle with rational two-torsion
Such a half exists because the nonconstant multiplication morphism on a smooth projective elliptic curve is surjective over an algebraic closure. Since is rational, . A different half is with rational and gives the same cocycle. Replacing by , with , allows the half and again changes nothing. Adding chosen halves shows additivity in . If the cocycle is zero, the half is fixed by the absolute Galois group and lies in , so . This proves, rather than assumes, an injection
The fixed field of is exactly . Its Galois group is the image of , so its degree is at most four. This also follows from the permitted biquadratic description.
Let be the finite set of primes dividing . At a place the displayed integral cubic has unit elliptic-curve discriminant, hence good reduction of an elliptic curve, and the residue characteristic is odd. Choose a half of the reduction of over the algebraic closure of the residue field. Its coordinates belong to a finite residue extension; let be the corresponding finite unramified extension. Smoothness and the Hensel lemma lift to some . The difference reduces to zero and belongs to the formal kernel of a minimal Weierstrass equation. In its integral formal group law the doubling series is , with unit linear coefficient. The prime-to-residue-characteristic multiplication on a formal group gives a unique in this kernel such that . Thus is a half of defined over an unramified local extension. Every other half differs by rational 2-torsion, so it too is unramified. We have proved the unramified halving fields for a split cubic assertion at every .
There are only finitely many bounded-degree extensions with restricted ramification of of degree at most four. This is the permitted number-field finiteness consequence of the Hermite–Minkowski theorem: bounded local degrees bound the discriminant exponents at the finitely many allowed ramified primes, so absolute discriminants are bounded. Each possible halving field is Galois, and there are only finitely many homomorphisms . The injection constructed above therefore has finite image. Consequently is finite. No elliptic-curve finiteness or descent theorem was used in this argument.
For , write . Each coordinate of in a basis of is a quadratic Galois character unramified outside . Its quadratic extension has a signed square-free integer representative , : an odd valuation outside would ramify there. There are at most choices, including the trivial character. Hence the pair of characters gives at most cocycles. Each prime in is at most , because the three root differences have absolute values at most and . Among the integers up to there are at most primes: two, together with at most odd candidates. The rational halving quotient bound from root size is therefore
For an integral Minimal Weierstrass equation, let be the subgroup of points whose reduction is a smooth point of the reduced cubic. Its reduction is a homomorphism to the smooth-locus group of a singular Weierstrass cubic, or to the whole reduced elliptic curve in the good-reduction case. Define the formal kernel of a minimal Weierstrass equation by
It consists of the identity and the points reducing to the identity at infinity. For a nonidentity affine point this is equivalent to and for some positive integer .
The local parameter , with , gives the group isomorphism
where is the formal group of an elliptic curve. To see the local coordinates, put in the Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curve. The resulting relation is , and its unit linear coefficient gives a unique integral series . Thus and have valuations and . The chord-and-tangent group law expressed in this parameter is precisely the integral formal group law . This description includes bad reduction; only the smooth identity neighborhood is involved.
In the one-dimensional commutative convention, a formal group law over is a formal power series satisfying , , and . The formal inverse is a series with . For all these series converge on , which becomes a group with operation .
Repeated formal addition gives the multiplication isomorphism of a formal group law . If , the coefficient is a unit in the p-adic integers. We can construct an inverse by coefficient recursion. At degree , the equation has the form ; dividing by the unit keeps integral. The inverse is two-sided by uniqueness of formal composition inverses. Since integral coefficients multiplied by successive powers of tend to zero, both series converge on that set and their formal identities hold there. This proves prime-to-residue-characteristic multiplication on a formal group:
The argument also applies at for odd ; it does not require a logarithm or torsion-freeness.
In this setting a formal group law means a one-dimensional commutative series with identity zero and
It starts with ; there is a unique inverse series satisfying . For coefficients in , the series and its inverse converge on , making this ideal a topological abelian group under .
Set , and write . The formal logarithm is
Differentiate associativity in the third variable at zero. It gives , so . Subtracting leaves a series independent of , whose value at zero is . Thus .
For odd , the logarithm converges on : the valuation of its degree- term is at least , which tends to infinity. Put . For , factor to obtain
for every and odd . Hence is a contraction with constant at most and maps into . The equation is equivalent to ; the contraction mapping theorem gives a unique solution in for every . The same estimate shows , so the logarithm is a topological group isomorphism. Dividing its values by gives
This is the deep logarithm subgroup of a formal group argument, here with depth one.
For , the degree-two estimate at depth one need not be strict. At depth two, however,
so the same proof gives . This subgroup has index two in , because when .
Indeed the topological structure of a formal group on twice the 2-adic integers has just two possibilities. Let , let its index-two subgroup have topological generator , and choose . Write , with , using group notation. If is odd, generates and generates , giving . If is even, has order two and lies outside , giving . The multiples are defined by continuity in this compact pro-two group.
For explicit contrasting examples, the formal additive group gives , which is a torsion-free group. The formal multiplicative group is identified by with . Its element corresponds to and has order two. Moreover
and the logarithm identifies the second factor with . The two resulting groups are and , so they are not isomorphic.
In this one-dimensional setting, a commutative formal group law over a commutative ring is a formal power series with
In particular terms of total degree at least two. There is a unique formal inverse ; coefficient recursion solves .
A morphism from formal group law to is satisfying
The invertible morphism criterion for formal group laws is
Necessity follows by differentiating at zero for an inverse . Conversely, write with a unit. In constructing , the coefficient of fixes ; at degree , the equation has the form an already known expression . This determines every over . The same construction gives an inverse on the other side, and uniqueness makes the two inverses agree. Finally apply to the morphism identity with to obtain
Thus the inverse is itself a morphism of formal group laws, not merely an inverse formal power series. Over a general ring, nonzero derivative is insufficient: it must be a unit.
Here a formal group means a one-dimensional commutative formal group law. Over a ring , it is a formal power series satisfying
In particular, terms of total degree at least . A formal inverse with is obtained recursively. An isomorphism of formal group laws from to is a series with invertible linear coefficient and
Its compositional inverse exists over by coefficient recursion.
For , all these series converge on ; the operations preserve that set and make it the group . Use the uniformizer and normalize the valuation by , and write .
We explicitly construct its formal logarithm. Define
Then put
This is a formal series over with linear coefficient . Differentiating associativity in its last variable at gives
It follows that the -derivative of is , the same as that of . Evaluating at therefore proves
The differential is the invariant differential of a formal group law.
Choose an integer . In degree , the coefficient of has valuation at least . Thus the scaled series
has
Here , and the coefficient valuations tend to infinity. Consequently with a convergent integral power series on . Such a series is -Lipschitz. For any , the equation is equivalent to , a strict contraction, to which the contraction mapping theorem applies on the complete ring . It has exactly one solution.
The deep logarithm subgroup of a formal group is obtained as follows. The formal group exponential is the formal compositional inverse of , obtained recursively; equivalently it solves , with . The preceding contraction, applied to the scaled series, constructs its convergent inverse on and agrees with that formal inverse. This supplies the required convergence sketch for as well as a bijectivity proof for the logarithm.
The integral formal law and inverse preserve , so this is a subgroup. The logarithm identity and bijectivity give
Reduction of the formal law modulo has kernel . Its underlying image set is , which has size , where . Thus this subgroup has finite index, explicitly .
An elliptic curve has good reduction over if it admits an integral Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curve with unit elliptic-curve discriminant. Equivalently, the reduction of its Minimal Weierstrass equation is a nonsingular cubic over the residue field . Its smooth integral projective model is a group scheme with the point as identity.
Choose homogeneous coordinates in the valuation ring with at least one coordinate a unit, and reduce them modulo its maximal ideal . This defines . The chord-and-tangent group law extends over the smooth integral model, so reduction is a group homomorphism. For any point of , choose an affine projective chart containing it. Smoothness means some partial derivative of its equation is nonzero in . Lift the other coordinate arbitrarily and apply the Hensel lemma to the coordinate with unit derivative. This constructs a point of above the prescribed point, proving the surjectivity of good reduction over a local field.
The kernel of reduction of an elliptic curve consists precisely of points reducing to . The parameter at gives a bijection between this kernel and : the integral formal-coordinate series solve the equation uniquely near . Addition in these coordinates is the formal group of an elliptic curve, not ordinary addition in . Thus
Here the group operation on the last expression is its formal group law.
In this setting a formal group law means a one-dimensional commutative series with
These identities force terms of total degree at least two. There is a unique formal inverse with .
A morphism to another formal group law is a series satisfying . The invertible morphism criterion for formal group laws is
Necessity follows by comparing linear coefficients in . For sufficiency, solve recursively for a compositional inverse : at every stage the new coefficient is obtained by dividing by the unit , so all coefficients stay in . Applying to the morphism identity shows that is itself a group homomorphism of formal group laws.
In particular, the multiplication series satisfies . Since , the multiplication isomorphism of a formal group law makes invertible over . Its series and inverse converge on , so multiplication by is bijective on , and on for every finite extension .
For , the displayed integral equation has nonzero elliptic-curve discriminant modulo , so it has good reduction. Let be the Legendre symbol, with . Counting the two, one, or zero possible ordinates over each gives
If , then and the terms for and cancel. The term at zero vanishes. Thus the count is .
For the converse, suppose , and put . The Euler criterion and the sum of powers over a finite field show that the Trace of Frobenius satisfies
Indeed, among the positive exponents in this polynomial, of degree , only has a nonzero sum over , and that sum is . Since , the coefficient formula for trace of Frobenius modulo p yields
Neither nor the binomial coefficient vanishes modulo . Hence , proving the point-count criterion for y squared equals x cubed plus k x:
We use the following formal logarithm fact, also useful for the next part. For a formal group law over , its logarithm has coefficients with , obtained by integrating its integral invariant differential. If is odd and , every term of degree has valuation strictly greater than , since . Thus the logarithm converges and is nonzero at . Its homomorphism into the additive characteristic-zero group proves torsion-freeness of the formal group over Qp for odd p. Consequently reduction injects the entire rational torsion subgroup at any odd prime of good reduction, including its -primary torsion. In particular the torsion subgroup is finite, and its order divides at every good .
By the Dirichlet theorem on primes in arithmetic progressions, choose a good prime . Then , bounding the two-primary part by four. For any odd prime dividing the torsion order, the Chinese remainder theorem and the Dirichlet theorem on primes in arithmetic progressions give a good prime with and , avoiding the finitely many primes dividing . But then , a contradiction. Therefore
The order four does occur. For , the elliptic-curve addition formula gives , so has order four. More precisely, the only nonzero rational 2-torsion point when is , so order four means a cyclic group with a rational half of this point. The duplication formula is
Such a half must have . Writing , positivity of forces . Then , so is a rational square, equivalently for an integer . Conversely is a half of when . The rational torsion on y squared equals x cubed plus positive k x is therefore cyclic of order four exactly for these , and otherwise cyclic of order two.
Fix a non-Archimedean local field , its valuation ring , a uniformizer , and a residue field with cardinality . The construction below applies both in mixed and equal characteristic. A one-dimensional commutative formal group law is with identity, associativity and commutativity, and higher-degree terms. It has a unique formal inverse. Its morphisms are series with ; a unit linear coefficient makes such a morphism invertible by recursive coefficient comparison. Evaluating its integral series on the maximal ideal of a finite extension of is legitimate because the series converge there.
Choose a Lubin–Tate series satisfying
A useful choice is . The Lubin–Tate functional equation lemma constructs a unique series with any prescribed linear form and satisfying
Here is its coefficient argument. If terms below degree have been found, the unknown homogeneous degree- term appears with multiplier . The already known error has every coefficient divisible by : after reduction, the equation becomes , valid because the residue coefficients lie in . Since is times a unit for , the next term is uniquely determined and integral. Recursion proves existence and uniqueness.
Use to construct , and to construct for every . Uniqueness gives and . Comparing with , which satisfy the same functional equation and have the same linear form, proves that is an endomorphism of the law. The same uniqueness applied to three variables proves associativity: and have the same linear form and functional equation. It also proves commutativity and the identities
Thus this Lubin–Tate formal group is equipped with an action of the whole ring , not only its integers. For a unit , the inverse of is . The same recursion, with two series for the fixed , gives a unique strict Lubin–Tate change of series. Its integral series and inverse converge on torsion points, so it identifies their torsion fields. We may compute with without losing the general construction for that uniformizer.
Write and . The Lubin–Tate torsion of level is
For , its primitive points are the roots of
This is a monic polynomial of degree . Modulo it is , and its constant coefficient is exactly . Thus the Eisenstein layers of Lubin–Tate torsion are Eisenstein polynomials. A root generates a totally ramified extension of degree , and has in the uniquely extended valuation. Also , so it has exact level .
The map
is well-defined and injective. If with and a unit, then , because is invertible and is primitive. Conversely every multiple of kills it. The image therefore contains distinct roots of the degree- polynomial , so it is all of . This proves, without merely assuming the torsion cardinality,
Its primitive generators are exactly with .
Define the Lubin–Tate extension . Every integral endomorphism series evaluated at converges in the complete field , so all torsion points already lie there. Hence
It is the splitting field of , which has distinct roots by the module calculation. Thus it is Galois. Every K-automorphism preserves the uniquely extended absolute value on a field, hence is continuous and commutes with limits of the integral endomorphism series. Its automorphisms therefore commute with the endomorphism action and send a primitive generator to a primitive generator. There is a unique unit class such that . The Lubin–Tate Galois action on primitive torsion gives an injective homomorphism
Both sides have order , so it is an isomorphism. In particular every finite layer is abelian and totally ramified.
For an example, take , , and the equally admissible series . Its formal group law is the formal multiplicative group , with for . The binomial polynomials make its coefficients integral. Its level- torsion points are with . Thus the Lubin–Tate cyclotomic example gives and Galois action . The order formula includes , when the first field and its Galois group are trivial over .
Finally choose primitive points compatibly, . They exist by taking a root of in the algebraic closure; its roots have positive valuation and exact level . Then , and restriction of Galois automorphisms corresponds to reduction of unit classes. The Lubin–Tate tower consequently has the topological Galois group
The final isomorphism uses completeness of the discrete valuation ring . This computes the finite-layer and infinite-tower Galois groups directly from the formal action and the primitive Eisenstein polynomials.
A one-dimensional commutative formal group law over a ring is a series satisfying
An isomorphism is a series with a compositional inverse and
The multiplication series is defined recursively by , and , with the formal inverse handling negative . Its linear term is
By the invertible morphism criterion for formal group laws, it is an isomorphism exactly when its linear coefficient is a unit of . Indeed, when , recursive coefficient comparison constructs a unique compositional inverse; applying the morphism identity for shows that the inverse also respects . Conversely, an invertible series must have a unit linear coefficient. Therefore
A one-dimensional commutative formal group law over is a power series satisfying
For , the ideal becomes a group, denoted , under ; convergence follows because both inputs lie in the maximal ideal.
Over the characteristic-zero field , there is a unique formal logarithm
satisfying . Its coefficients have bounded denominator growth, so for sufficiently large both and its inverse formal group exponential converge on and preserve that ideal. They give
where the final isomorphism is multiplication by .
A one-dimensional commutative formal group law over a ring is a series satisfying
The identity axiom gives terms of total degree at least two. Seek
After have been chosen, the coefficient of in is plus a known expression in the earlier coefficients. There is therefore a unique choice of making it zero. Recursion constructs the formal inverse with and .
A one-dimensional commutative formal group law over a ring is a power series satisfying , commutativity, and associativity. A morphism is a series satisfying
Express the isogeny of part b in the formal coordinates of part d and set
Part c shows that points approaching map to points approaching , so . Since is a group homomorphism, applying the parameter to gives
Thus is the formal-group morphism induced by an isogeny .
A one-dimensional commutative formal group law over is a power series satisfying
A morphism is a series satisfying
If , the invertible morphism criterion for formal group laws says that is an isomorphism whenever . Indeed, recursive coefficient comparison constructs a unique compositional inverse ; applying to the morphism identity shows that is a morphism in the opposite direction.
The multiplication series has
Since , its linear coefficient is a unit, so is an automorphism of the group . Its kernel is therefore zero, and