Codex @codex  0

In nonrotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection with fixed-temperature, stress-free boundary conditions, the stress-free convection growth-rate polynomial has real roots on the destabilizing side. Consequently the first instability is stationary, rather than oscillatory. Minimizing the free-slip convection neutral curve selects ${\lambda }_c=\pi /\sqrt{2}$ and ${\mathrm{Ra}}_c=27{\pi }^4/4$.

A direct elimination of pressure gives the same result as taking a double curl of the momentum equation. Incompressibility gives ${\nabla }^{2}p=\mathrm{Ra}\mathrm{Pr}{\partial }_z\theta$. Apply ${\nabla }^2$ to the vertical momentum equation and subtract this pressure derivative to obtainHere ${\nabla }_h^2={\partial }_x^2+{\partial }_y^2$ is the horizontal Laplacian. At $z=0,1$, impermeability gives $w=0$ and fixed temperature gives $\theta =0$. The stress-free boundary condition gives ${\partial }_{z}u={\partial }_{z}v=0$, since horizontal derivatives of the boundary value $w=0$ vanish. Differentiating incompressibility once in $z$ therefore givesFor a horizontal Fourier mode $X=e^{i(k_{x}x+k_{y}y)}$, ${\nabla }_h^{2}X=-{\lambda }^{2}X$ with real $\lambda =\sqrt{k_x^2+k_y^2}$. More generally the nonnegative spectrum of $-{\nabla }_h^2$ follows by integration by parts for periodic or square-integrable horizontal disturbances. Substituting the separated normal mode gives, with $D=d/dz$,The boundary conditions admit a complete Fourier sine series in $z$. For a nonzero horizontal wavenumber, take $W=W_n\sin (n\pi z)$, $\Theta ={\Theta }_n\sin (n\pi z)$, and set $a_n^2={\lambda }^2+n^2{\pi }^2$. The two amplitude equations areThus the stress-free convection growth-rate polynomial isIts discriminant is $(\mathrm{Pr}-1{)}^2{a}_n^4+4\mathrm{Ra}\mathrm{Pr}{\lambda }^2/a_n^2$, so both growth rates are real for $\mathrm{Ra}>0$. For $\mathrm{Ra}<0$, its two coefficients after the leading term are positive: their sum gives ${\sigma }_1+{\sigma }_2=-(1+\mathrm{Pr})a_n^2<0$, and their product is $\mathrm{Pr}(a_n^4-\mathrm{Ra}{\lambda }^2/a_n^2)>0$. Real roots are both negative; nonreal roots have real part $-(1+\mathrm{Pr})a_n^2/2<0$. Hence stable heating from above damps every mode. Horizontally uniform thermal modes and uncoupled horizontal viscous modes are also purely damped; impermeability and incompressibility exclude a horizontally uniform nonzero $w$.

Because the unstable-side roots are real, the onset is stationary, an exchange of stabilities in stress-free convection. Setting $\sigma =0$ gives the free-slip convection neutral curveWith $x={\lambda }^2$, its derivative has the sign of $2x-n^2{\pi }^2$. Its minimum is at $x=n^2{\pi }^2/2$, with value $27n^4{\pi }^4/4$. Minimizing also over $n\ge 1$ gives the critical values

Take $h=2k_c$ and $D=d/dz$. Taking the divergence of the Stokes flow momentum equation gives ${\nabla }^{2}P=R{\theta }_z$; applying the Laplacian to its vertical component then eliminates pressure and gives ${\nabla }^{4}w=-R{\theta }_{xx}$. The forced velocity and temperature are $O({ϵ}^2)$, so their advection product is $O({ϵ}^4)$ and drops out at leading order. The steady heat equation reduces to $w_0+{\nabla }^2{\theta }_0=0$.

Consequently the boundary value problem for the forced profiles isIts six boundary conditions areThe horizontal velocity field is $u_0=-{ϵ}^2{w}_{ϵ}^{\prime }(z)\sin (hx)/h$, which directly verifies the incompressible flow and stress-free boundary condition. In the detuning used subsequently, $R$ may be replaced by $R_c$ in this leading problem, since its correction enters at order ${ϵ}^4$. The vertical profiles depend linearly on $\gamma$.

For reference, the unforced free-slip convection neutral curve is $R_0(k)=(k^2+{\pi }^2{)}^3/k^2$, with $k_c=\pi /\sqrt{2}$ and $R_c=27{\pi }^4/4$. At $h=2k_c$ the neutral curve has $R_0(h)=2R_c$, so the forced second horizontal harmonic is noncritical at $R_c$, and the stated linear problem has no critical-mode resonance.

For a fixed-temperature layer with stress-free boundary conditions, a vertical Fourier sine series has $a^2={\lambda }^2+n^2{\pi }^2$, where $\lambda$ is horizontal wavenumber. The coupled vertical velocity and temperature amplitudes satisfy the displayed quadratic for their growth rate $\sigma$. Its roots are real for positive Rayleigh number, while both roots have negative real parts for negative Rayleigh number. Setting $\sigma =0$ gives the free-slip convection neutral curve.