For homogeneous fiber equations of fixed degrees in , put for . The linear map has image the degree- component of their homogeneous ideal. Hence it is surjective exactly when that ideal contains : the degree- monomials generate this power. In a family, the matrix entries are regular functions on the base. Failure of surjectivity is therefore a closed determinantal variety, cut out by the maximal-size matrix minors.
The identification with means that is a smooth plane conic. An arbitrary singular or nonreduced conic over an algebraically closed field cannot be identified with the projective line, so this is a necessary qualification implicit in the requested description.
Choose an equation for and a degree-two equation whose restriction to defines . Its homogeneous ideal in is . These equations form a regular sequence: is a non-zero-divisor in the polynomial ring, and modulo the ring is a polynomial ring in three variables, in which the nonzero quadratic is again a non-zero-divisor. The generator classes therefore form a basis of the conormal sheaf, with their grading shifts:
One can verify the absence of relations from the two-generator Koszul complex: a relation between is a multiple of , whose coefficients become zero modulo . This is the normal sheaf of a projective complete intersection calculation. Dualizing the conormal sheaf gives
These twists are restrictions from , not intrinsic degree-one twists on . A line in the plane cuts the degree-two curve in two points counted with multiplicity, so the degree of a line bundle is two. The Picard group of the projective line then gives
Equivalently, the degree-two Veronese embedding pulls each linear coordinate back to a quadratic. Thus the normal bundle of a smooth plane conic is
The same splitting follows from the normal sequence for the two embeddings:
Its outer terms are and . The extension group class lies in , by the preceding Čech cohomology calculation, so the sequence splits. Both methods distinguish the ambient twist from the intrinsic degree on the curve.
Use the graded ring homomorphism
where source degree maps to target degree . The homogeneous ideal of the twisted cubic is : a homogeneous polynomial vanishes on the parametrized curve precisely when its substitution vanishes identically. Here is infinite, being an algebraically closed field, so vanishing at all parameter points implies the polynomial identity.
Let be generated by
Their substitutions vanish, hence . To prove the reverse inclusion as an equality of ideals, we need more than a set-theoretic description of the zero locus.
Modulo , replace by , by , and by . Each replacement strictly decreases the sum of the exponents of and , so the reduction terminates. It shows that the degree- quotient is spanned by the standard monomials of the twisted cubic
For there are of these. For the sole monomial is . Their substituted images have -exponents respectively , and , so they are exactly the distinct monomials
These are linearly independent. Consequently any degree- polynomial in , after reduction modulo , has all its reduced coefficients zero. It belongs to . Applying this to each homogeneous component gives
This also proves that the quotient embeds in the domain , so the displayed ideal is prime; no radicalization or saturation correction is concealed in the argument. Its image is the third Veronese subring , and the calculation gives the Hilbert polynomial , consistent with degree three and genus zero.
Take nef and big on a complex K3 surface, and put . The K3 linear system dichotomies are successive alternatives, so each later statement assumes that the exceptional cases in the earlier ones have been excluded.
The first dichotomy separates basepoint-free systems from monogonal linear systems on a K3 surface. In the exceptional case,
Otherwise is basepoint-free. There are no isolated base points left after excluding the fixed-section case; this is the first dichotomy.
For a basepoint-free system, the second dichotomy separates hyperelliptic linear systems on a K3 surface from birational maps to normal images. The degree-two cases are characterized by
Their images are surfaces of minimal degree: the plane, a rational normal scroll, or the Veronese surface. In the birational case, the map is an embedding away from the -curves with , which it contracts to Du Val singularities. Thus “birational” does not assert an embedding of the original surface. These are the degree-two and birational projective-model alternatives.
In the third dichotomy, the birational image is either defined scheme-theoretically by quadrics or has an exceptional cubic requirement. The exceptional threefold containing it is for , a quadric hypersurface in for , a rational normal threefold scroll in the higher-genus trigonal case, or the cone over the Veronese surface in the plane-quintic case. For , trigonal sections come from an elliptic pencil with ; the plane-quintic exception has
All other birational cases have homogeneous ideal generated by quadrics. For , the exceptional ideals are generated by quadrics and cubics. For , the image is a quartic hypersurface in and its ideal needs its degree-four defining equation; that case must not be included in the cubic-generation assertion. The geometric alternatives, including the low-genus exceptions, are the plane-quintic exception to the third dichotomy; the higher-genus trigonal conclusion is also stated in the projective-model theorem.
The point of the final exception is that a plane quintic is not a trigonal curve. Its canonical model is the degree-two Veronese embedding of the plane curve, and its quadrics retain an ambient Veronese surface. Accordingly, one must include the cone-over-Veronese case instead of calling every failure of quadratic generation “trigonal.”
Work in the classical setting of varieties over an algebraically closed field . A prevariety is separated when its diagonal morphism is a closed immersion; for prevarieties the diagonal is already an immersion, so this is equivalent to its image being closed. A complete variety has the following closed-projection property: for every variety , projection maps closed subsets to closed subsets. This is universal closedness; since a variety is separated and of finite type, it is equivalent to the structural map being proper.
First consider projective space. In two sets of homogeneous coordinates its diagonal is defined by
These equations hold exactly when the two nonzero coordinate vectors are proportional. They are homogeneous in each coordinate set, so they define a closed subset of . On a common affine chart, the diagonal map is the usual closed immersion defined by equality of the affine coordinates. Thus projective space is separated. If is a projective embedding, its diagonal is the intersection of that closed diagonal with . Consequently every projective variety is separated.
Here is an algebraic proof of completeness, rather than an appeal to projective compactness in an analytic topology. It suffices to prove closedness of projection from projective space over an affine chart , with coordinate ring . A closed subset is cut out by a homogeneous ideal . Put and write for its degree- part. Each is a finitely generated -module, because it is a quotient of the free module on the degree- monomials.
Suppose the fibre over is empty. The specialized homogeneous equations then have no nonzero common zero. By the Hilbert Nullstellensatz, some power of each belongs to the specialized ideal. If those powers are , then every monomial of degree belongs to that ideal. Hence
The Nakayama lemma gives . Since is finitely generated, there is with : choose generators and multiply finitely many elements annihilating their localizations. On the principal open subset , all graded pieces of degree at least vanish too, since the quotient is generated in degree one. Every fibre over is therefore empty: a projective point would have a nonzero coordinate whose degree- power could not vanish. Thus the complement of the projection of is open, proving the required closed-projection property.
An affine open cover of an arbitrary establishes the same result there. Finally, a closed subset of is closed in when is a projective variety, so its image is closed by the preceding argument. Therefore
Over a non-algebraically-closed field, the corresponding statement concerns schemes or geometric points. Projection of rational points alone need not be closed, so it must not replace the completeness definition.
A filtration of a ring is an exhaustive increasing family of additive subgroups , indexed by the integers, with and . A compatible filtration of a module on a right module satisfies . The associated graded module has components , and its action by the associated graded ring is
Changing either representative changes the product only by an element of , so the action is well-defined.
The subspace filtration on is . The quotient filtration is . Inclusion induces an injective map , and the quotient induces a surjective map to . If maps to zero in its degree- quotient, write with and . Then , so the kernel is exactly the image of . We have the short exact sequence
which is exactness of associated graded modules for induced filtrations.
For the negative case, for . Completeness means that is an isomorphism; in particular the filtration of a ring is separated. If and , then . The geometric series
converges in the complete negative filtration and is a two-sided inverse of , by the finite geometric identity and continuity of multiplication. The unit criterion for the Jacobson radical now gives
Let be any right ideal. The associated graded module for its subspace filtration is a homogeneous ideal on the right in . If is a right Noetherian ring, choose homogeneous generators that lift to , with degrees .
For , cancel its degree- symbol by a sum with . The remainder belongs to . Repeat the cancellation in each succeeding degree. After steps,
For every , the coefficient series converges to some by completeness. Passing to the limit gives . Thus these finitely many generate the actual right ideal ; no assumption that is closed is needed. Since every right ideal is finitely generated, is right Noetherian, by complete negative filtered-graded transfer of Noetherianity.
By part (a), work first with an affine base and its homogeneous equations. Put , write for its finite-dimensional degree- vector space, and use for . At each base point define the graded multiplication map for a projective fiber
Its image is exactly , since taking the degree- part of any expression in the homogeneous ideal discards all other degrees. Moreover
because degree- monomials generate .
Choose monomial bases for the domain summands and codomain. Every entry of the resulting matrix is a coefficient of one of the , hence a regular function of . If , failure of surjectivity is the vanishing of all -by- matrix minors. It is therefore a closed rank-defect locus . If the matrix has fewer than columns, the failure is automatic and , also closed. Constants and are covered by the same construction.
Part (c) gives , an intersection of closed subsets, hence closed. Apply part (a) to pass back to arbitrary . Thus projection from sends every closed subset to a closed subset. This proves the closedness of projection from projective space without assuming the properness result being proved.
The field convention matters: a rational-point projection need not be Zariski closed. Over , the closed equation in has real-point image . Indeed would force , so a solution exists precisely when is a square in . This infinite proper subset of the affine line is not Zariski closed. The valid arbitrary-field theorem uses scheme or geometric images, for which the matrix argument remains valid at every residue field.
Apply a projective linear transformation sending the first points to the coordinate points
The next point has every homogeneous coordinate nonzero by general linear position, so a diagonal projective transformation fixing the sends it to
Write the last point as . Again general linear position implies that every is nonzero. It also implies for : otherwise , , and the coordinate points other than would lie in the hyperplane .
Put and define the degree- homogeneous polynomials
The associated map is a rational normal curve. It sends to , sends to , and sends to , because
is one common nonzero scalar times . This proves existence.
For uniqueness, parametrize any rational normal curve through these points and choose a coordinate on its source so that the preimages of and are respectively and . If the preimage of is , then its th coordinate polynomial must have all the other as roots. It is therefore
The value at is , so all are equal and may be removed by a common rescaling. The value at is , so is proportional to . Thus all are obtained from the by one common rescaling of the coordinate on . This merely reparametrizes the curve, proving uniqueness.
For , choose the monomial basis . The resulting curve is the twisted cubic
Its homogeneous ideal is generated by the three quadratic matrix minors
the minors of
For an algebraically closed field , the strong Hilbert Nullstellensatz says that every ideal satisfies
Its weak form says that exactly when . Now let and let be a homogeneous ideal. The affine zero set of is the affine cone over together with the origin. Hence, when the projective zero set is empty, either
or the affine zero set is exactly the origin. In the latter case the Hilbert Nullstellensatz gives
the irrelevant ideal of projective space. Equivalently, some power is contained in . These are precisely the alternatives in the Projective Nullstellensatz.
Let be a smooth quadric surface. After a projective linear transformation, the Segre embedding identifies
Choose distinct points . The two fibres
are the promised disjoint curves on a smooth quadric surface: each is a smooth projective line, and . By the Bézout theorem, any two nonempty curves in the projective plane intersect. An isomorphism of algebraic varieties preserves intersections and takes projective curves to projective curves, so these disjoint curves prove
Next let be a smooth projective curve and let be a rational map to a projective variety. At a point outside its initial domain, write
using elements of the function field . The local ring of a smooth algebraic curve at is a discrete valuation ring. If , multiplying every coordinate by a function of valuation makes all coordinates regular at and at least one a unit there. They therefore define a morphism near . Repeating this at the finitely many missing points proves the extension of a rational map from a smooth projective curve.
Smoothness is essential. Let be the normalization of a nodal curve for a rational nodal cubic . The inverse is a rational map on the smooth locus. If it extended to a morphism , then would agree with the identity on a dense Zariski-open subset of and hence everywhere. But the two distinct points above the node would satisfy
a contradiction. This is the failure of rational-map extension on a singular curve.
Finally take the Fermat cubic curve
and define the projective hypersurface
Because and have no common irreducible factor, the bihomogeneous polynomial is irreducible, so is an algebraic variety. Let
be the second coordinate projection. Every homogeneous cubic in three variables has a projective zero over , so every fibre is nonempty and is a surjective morphism. Over the fibre is the Fermat cubic curve, which is smooth and has genus
Over the fibre is
the union of exactly three distinct projective lines, hence exactly three irreducible components. This is the cubic pencil with a triangular member required by the question.
Projective Nullstellensatz Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
Let be a homogeneous ideal over an algebraically closed field, and let
be the irrelevant ideal. Then exactly when either or . For a proper homogeneous ideal this is also equivalent to for some .
It is the homogeneous projective version of the Hilbert Nullstellensatz.
Over the real numbers, the closed equation in projects on real points to , which is not Zariski closed. Projective properness concerns scheme or geometric images, not the image of rational points over an arbitrary field. Similarly, has no real projective zero, but its homogeneous ideal contains no power of the irrelevant ideal of projective space, since it has a complex projective zero.
Modulo the three quadric relations of the twisted cubic, replace by , by , and by . Each replacement reduces the total exponent of . The resulting monomials are , , and . In degree their images under are all distinct monomials of degree . They are linearly independent, so the three quadrics generate the full homogeneous ideal, not merely its radical. The quotient is the third Veronese subring of .