Part (a) makes for all sufficiently large , while part (b) would make whenever were nonzero. Hence some derivative of vanishes identically, so is a polynomial.
Let its degree be . Then is a nonzero constant. Substituting into the differentiated equation annihilates both derivative terms and gives
Thus , and
The nonzero regular solutions are therefore constant multiples of the Legendre polynomial of degree .
The scattering amplitude is defined by
For a central potential its partial-wave expansion is
Using orthogonality of the Legendre polynomials in gives
Let be the angle between and the positive -axis. By superposition of the electric potential of point charges,
For , the Legendre polynomial expansion gives
Therefore
The three displayed terms are respectively the monopole, dipole, and quadrupole terms of the electric multipole expansion. In particular, the total charge is and the electric dipole moment is . This is the multipole expansion of three collinear charges.
Project the photon Boltzmann equation onto Legendre polynomials. The angular average uses and , so the collision term has no monopole and
For the dipole, the recurrence relation makes free streaming couple to and . The gravitational term contributes , while projection of gives the baryon-velocity source. Thus
Neglecting the photon quadrupole gives
For a vacuum electric potential, put in Laplace's equation in spherical coordinates. Multiplication by separates the radial and angular terms. With separation constant and , the angular Legendre differential equation is
Regularity at both polar axes selects nonnegative integers and the Legendre polynomials. The radial equation is , whose independent solutions are and . Hence the angularly regular axisymmetric vacuum solution is
The radial domain and its boundary conditions determine which terms are admissible.
For the given charge density, only is forced. Write . The interior radial Poisson equation is . The identity for the Poisson equation with a spherical harmonic source gives the particular solution , since the radial operator takes to four. Finiteness at zero and decay at infinity therefore give
Continuity of the electric potential and its radial derivative at requires and . Solving gives , , so
All other angular modes have zero coefficients after imposing regularity, matching and decay. At the origin the interior expression is , which extends with a continuous gradient and value zero. The angular charge density has no unique value exactly at that point; Poisson's equation holds classically for and as a weak solution through the origin. There is no additional point charge.
Write . The Taylor expansion gives the near-axis result
To extend off the axis, work separately above and below the charged plane. In either source-free half-space the regular axisymmetric solid harmonics are . Matching the positive-axis coefficients, using , and then reflecting in the disk gives
Here is a Legendre polynomial. The quadratic term is . The linear term is above and below; it represents the discontinuity of the normal electric field. A single regular spherical expansion across the entire charged sheet would incorrectly remove that jump.
Put in Laplace's equation, multiply by , and separate the two variables:
With , the angular equation becomes . Requiring a smooth axisymmetric harmonic function at both poles selects and the Legendre polynomial , for nonnegative integers . The radial Cauchy-Euler equation has solutions and . Superposition over the angular eigenfunctions therefore gives
This expansion assumes regularity on each whole angular sphere; without it, singular angular solutions would also be possible. The boundary data in the shell involve only the modes. Define the spherical-shell harmonic interpolation weights
Each equals one at the inner boundary and zero at the outer one, and does the reverse. Hence the steady temperature is
Each term is a harmonic function, and substitution verifies both prescribed boundary values. Uniqueness follows from the maximum principle for harmonic functions.
Termwise differentiation of the convergent Frobenius series and collection of powers in the Bessel differential equation gives the lowest coefficient , the next coefficient , and, for , the coefficient . Since , the stated choices , and the recurrence make all coefficients vanish.
For , the two resulting even-coefficient series are
and
These are linearly independent on and give the Bessel functions of order one half, up to normalization. The specified condition is sufficient; in the negative-exponent branch at this particular order the next coefficient equation alone would allow to be free, adding a multiple of the positive-exponent solution.
For the Legendre differential equation, substitution gives the full conditions
Thus permits arbitrary , while requires . This Frobenius recurrence for the Legendre equation separates the even and odd series. The nearest singular points of the differential equation are , so the series about zero has radius at least one, and the generic nonterminating solutions have radius exactly one. Particular cancellations can give a larger radius.
Termination occurs when the degree reaches a nonnegative integer with . For this gives
Choose the even branch for even or the odd branch for odd to obtain a Legendre polynomial. The recurrence then terminates and gives a solution for all real , with infinite radius of convergence. A nonzero entire solution at other is impossible: each nonterminating parity has coefficient ratio tending to one in the variable , and so radius one.
Set and multiply the Laplace equation by . Separation of variables gives
With , the angular equation is . Regularity at both poles selects the Legendre polynomials and . The radial Cauchy-Euler equation has solutions . Expanding the angular data in this complete orthogonal system therefore gives
with the usual convergence required of a harmonic expansion on the region considered. Angular Legendre functions singular at the poles are excluded.
For , the outer data have expansion , while the inner data are pure . Thus only degrees zero and two are needed. A radial interpolation matching each pair of boundary values gives
The first term is a linear combination of and takes values at the two radii. The second is a combination of and takes values zero and . These checks establish both boundary conditions; each term is harmonic. The maximum principle for harmonic functions gives uniqueness. This is an example of axisymmetric harmonic interpolation between concentric spheres.
For a nonnegative integer , the chain of the same parity as reaches , where the numerator of the recurrence relation vanishes. The next coefficient and every later coefficient in that chain are zero, producing a polynomial of degree . Normalizing it at gives the Legendre polynomial .
The opposite-parity chain never reaches . Its other possible zero, , is negative and cannot occur, so a nonzero initial coefficient produces a nonterminating power series. It is linearly independent of and can be scaled to the Legendre function of the second kind .
The degree statement requires , as the examples in part (c) indicate. For a negative integer , the same equation has the nonnegative degree , because . A polynomial cannot literally have negative degree.
For the terminating even solution is constant; for the terminating odd solution is proportional to . For , the recurrence gives ; for it gives . Imposing the Legendre polynomial normalization at yields
For normalized Legendre polynomials, and . Near the endpoints the integral factor has the asymptotics
and
Thus an independent solution, for which , has the logarithmic endpoint singularities
The constants are understood for a solution continued consistently across the ordinary interior points. Adding any multiple of cannot cancel these logarithms. This explains why boundedness at an endpoint selects the Legendre polynomial and excludes the independent Legendre function of the second kind.
Put . Orthogonality of the Legendre polynomials lets us match each degree separately. Continuity of the field and its radial derivative gives
Eliminate by multiplying the first equation by and adding it to the second. A nonzero mode therefore requires
This argument avoids dividing by a potentially zero boundary value. Apply the supplied recurrence with :
Consequently spherical Helmholtz matching to a decaying harmonic exterior gives
where for the sector.
The original PDF has an index error here: it prints rather than in the resulting eigenvalue condition. This cannot be repaired by silently choosing another normalization. If itself were zero at a positive matching root, the boundary equation would also give , contradicting uniqueness for this nonzero solution of a regular differential equation at that point.
For separation of variables, write . The exterior Laplace equation separates into
With , angular regularity at the poles selects and the Legendre polynomial . The radial equation is , an Euler-Cauchy equation with solutions . Decay at infinity excludes the first branch for every , including its constant case. Therefore
The expansion uses axisymmetric spherical harmonics. The written scalar boundary-value problem permits the term; any additional physical exclusion of that sector must be stated separately.
Resolve the angular surface charge density into Legendre polynomials:
For a single degree , write the common surface potential as . Regularity and decay require radial factors inside and outside. Their exterior-minus-interior radial derivative at is . Thus spherical harmonic matching with a derivative jump gives .
Only degrees zero and two occur, yielding
Both expressions have surface value , and their derivative difference is , checking both interface conditions. The interior quadratic is regular at the origin, and the exterior potential tends to zero.
The leading far-field term is the monopole term. Indeed the total charge is , and the normalization of the specified jump gives . No extra permittivity factor is inserted into the supplied normalization. Regularity here means finite piecewise smooth potential; its normal derivative necessarily jumps at the charged surface.
Use separation of variables, writing . After multiplication by , the radial and angular terms are functions of independent variables, so set
With , the angular equation is
Regularity at both poles selects , , and the Legendre polynomials ; the other angular branch is singular at a pole. The radial Euler-Cauchy equation is . A power gives , hence .
Superposing these axisymmetric spherical harmonics gives
The coefficients must give convergence appropriate to the domain. In a region containing the origin, regularity removes the negative powers; in an exterior region with zero potential at infinity, it removes the growing powers and the constant. No such radial restriction is needed for a general annular region.
For a separated axisymmetric harmonic function , multiplying the Laplace equation by gives
The two sides depend on different variables, hence both equal a constant. Put in the angular equation. Since , it becomes the Legendre differential equation
Regularity on both parts of the polar axis restricts , with , and selects the Legendre polynomial . The other angular solution is singular at an endpoint.
The radial Euler differential equation is
Trying gives , so or . Superposition of these separated harmonic functions gives
The Legendre polynomials form the angular expansion for regular data with rotational symmetry about the polar axis; the radial domain and the boundary conditions determine which coefficients survive and where the expansion converges.
With , the boundary data have the finite Legendre polynomial expansion
Inside the sphere, every term is singular at the origin and must be absent. Matching at therefore gives
In the exterior, decay at infinity excludes all terms, including the constant term at . Thus
Both harmonic functions have the prescribed Dirichlet boundary condition, and each is finite throughout its own domain. The interior expression is regular even at the origin because and . Uniqueness of the Dirichlet problem identifies these as the respective solutions. Their normal derivatives need not match: the two Dirichlet problems do not require a single harmonic function across the bounding sphere.
Substitute into the axisymmetric Laplace equation and multiply by . The radial and angular terms must be separate constants:
Thus
With , the angular equation becomes
Requiring boundedness on the entire polar interval, and using the supplied characterization of bounded Legendre polynomial solutions, gives and for . Trying gives , hence or .
The globally angular-regular separated modes and their superposition are therefore
Coefficients and convergence are determined by the radial domain and boundary data. A domain containing the origin excludes negative radial powers for a regular solution. If the angular domain excludes a polar axis of the spherical coordinate system and singular angular behavior is allowed, additional Legendre-function branches are possible; the displayed family is the one regular over the complete sphere, as intended by the hint.
Seek a nonzero separated solution . Substitution into the heat equation and division by the product gives
The left side depends only on time, so set it to . Multiplication by then separates the angular dependence, with separation constant . The three ordinary differential equations are
The temporal solution is . With , the angular equation is the Legendre differential equation; regularity at both angular endpoints selects and , the Legendre polynomial. The radial equation has the Spherical Bessel functions and for . Regularity at , if imposed, excludes the singular second solution. For the radial powers are and . Without specified radial boundary conditions, no discrete set of is selected; is a convention for the temporal separation constant.