Past exam of the chemistry course of the year 3 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge / 2022 / Paper 2A / Section B / 23 / g

In the electronic state correlation diagram, the singly occupied reactant orbitals for triplet oxygen have symmetries $B_1$ and $A_2$, so their spatial product is $B_2$. The reactant state is therefore a triplet ${}^3{B}_2$, whereas the closed-shell product is ${}^1{A}_1$. A strictly spin-conserving path cannot correlate triplet reactants directly to the ground-state product. It correlates to an excited triplet product configuration or requires intersystem crossing; the symmetric direct reaction consequently has a substantial electronic obstacle.

Simply changing the oxygen spin does not repair the occupied carbon-orbital correlation. The lowest oxygen singlet manifold has spatial components of $A_1$ and $B_2$ symmetry in this subgroup. The $A_1$ singlet can have an avoided crossing with another $A_1$ configuration and reach the product singlet; the $B_2$ singlet cannot mix directly with the product ${}^1{A}_1$ while $C_{2v}$ is maintained. Following either closed-shell oxygen singlet component in the orbital diagram still leaves the carbon-pi electron pair in the rising ${\sigma }_{+}^{\ast }$ orbital. Its redistribution into the final occupied orbitals requires configuration mixing at an avoided crossing. A barrier is therefore expected even for the symmetry-constrained concerted singlet addition; singlet does not imply barrierless. The state curves in the original diagram are schematic, illustrating this avoided-crossing argument rather than computed energies.^[ref]

The real singlet reaction can lower this obstacle through asymmetric or stepwise pathways that are absent from the stipulated direct approach. A primary multireference study explicitly distinguishes singlet and triplet addition through biradical intermediates, supporting that limitation of a one-coordinate symmetry argument.^[ref] Neither correlation alone nor a spin label supplies a numerical activation energy.