Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2004 / iii / Paper 3 / 2

Put $\bar{i}=2n+1-i$ and let $E_{ij}$ denote a matrix unit. The antidiagonal matrix satisfies $J^{-1}=J$, so the orthogonal condition is $A=-J{A}^{T}J$, or entrywise $A_{ij}=-A_{\bar{j}\bar{i}}$. Consequently the diagonal Cartan subalgebra isWe first take $n\ge 2$. Since $[H,E_{ab}]=(H_{aa}-H_{bb})E_{ab}$, the matrix root basis of the even orthogonal Lie algebra givesThe zero weight space is $\mathfrak{t}$; its basis is $H_i=E_{ii}-E_{\bar{i}\bar{i}}$. No vector of weight $2{\epsilon }_i$ occurs, because the corresponding matrix unit is forced to be its own negative. These spaces account for $n+2n(n-1)=n(2n-1)$ dimensions, exhausting the Special orthogonal Lie algebra. Thus its decomposition as a $\mathfrak{t}$-module and its Dn root system areEach nonzero root space has dimension one; the zero weight has multiplicity $n$.

The upper triangular root spaces are precisely those of weights ${\epsilon }_i-{\epsilon }_j$ and ${\epsilon }_i+{\epsilon }_j$ with $i<j$. ThereforeThese $n$ roots form the simple roots. To check that they generate the chosen positive system with nonnegative coefficients, write ${\epsilon }_i-{\epsilon }_j={\sum }_{k=i}^{j-1}{\alpha }_k$. For $j<n$,and for $j=n$ use ${\epsilon }_i+{\epsilon }_n={\sum }_{k=i}^{n-2}{\alpha }_k+{\alpha }_n$. Empty sums are zero. Their linear independence and these expansions identify the base of the root system.

Equip the real span of the roots in ${\mathfrak{t}}^{\ast }$ with the inner product making the ${\epsilon }_i$ orthonormal. All roots then have squared length two. The coroots of ${\epsilon }_i\pm {\epsilon }_j$ are $H_i\pm H_j$, so the fundamental weights of Dn, characterized by ${\omega }_i({\alpha }_j^{\vee })={\delta }_{ij}$, areTaking their pairings with $H_j-H_{j+1}$ and $H_{n-1}+H_n$ verifies the defining identities directly. For each pair $i<j$, the sum of its two positive roots is $2{\epsilon }_i$. Hence the half-sum of positive roots is

The Dynkin diagram has a chain ending at ${\alpha }_{n-2}$, which is joined to both ${\alpha }_{n-1}$ and ${\alpha }_n$. Every edge is a single bond because the root lengths agree; the nonzero off-diagonal simple-root pairings are minus one. The labelled Dn Dynkin diagram and its low-rank versions are shown below.

For $n=2$, ${\alpha }_1={\epsilon }_1-{\epsilon }_2$ and ${\alpha }_2={\epsilon }_1+{\epsilon }_2$ are orthogonal, giving two disconnected A1 root systems. For $n=3$, the diagram is the chain ${\alpha }_2-{\alpha }_1-{\alpha }_3$, of type A3 root system; the displayed weight formulas still apply. If $n=1$ is allowed, ${\mathfrak{so}}_2=\mathfrak{t}$ is one-dimensional and abelian: there are no roots or fundamental weights, and $\rho =0$.

In dimension four, the two positive roots are $\alpha ={\epsilon }_1-{\epsilon }_2$ and $\beta ={\epsilon }_1+{\epsilon }_2$. Using the matrix root basis of the even orthogonal Lie algebra, defineThe matrix unit identity $[E_{ij},E_{kl}]={\delta }_{jk}{E}_{il}-{\delta }_{li}{E}_{kj}$ gives $[e_{\gamma },f_{\gamma }]=h_{\gamma }$, $[h_{\gamma },e_{\gamma }]=2e_{\gamma }$, and $[h_{\gamma },f_{\gamma }]=-2f_{\gamma }$ for $\gamma =\alpha ,\beta$. Thus each triple spans an sl2 Lie algebra.

The two triples commute. Their Cartan actions on one another vanish because $\alpha (h_{\beta })=\beta (h_{\alpha })=0$; their mixed root-vector brackets vanish because none of $\pm \alpha \pm \beta$, namely $\pm 2{\epsilon }_1$ and $\pm 2{\epsilon }_2$, is a root. This can equally be checked from the displayed matrix units. The six vectors are linearly independent, occupying the four distinct root spaces and two independent Cartan directions, so they exhaust the six-dimensional so4 Lie algebra. The two commuting spans are consequently ideals, andThis gives an explicit Chiral decomposition of the complexified so4 Lie algebra, including generators for both factors.

Identify $\mathfrak{t}$ with the coordinate vector $t=(t_1,\dots ,t_n)$ through $H(t)$. A root reflection is $s_{\alpha }(H)=H-\alpha (H){\alpha }^{\vee }$. Since $({\epsilon }_i\pm {\epsilon }_j{)}^{\vee }=H_i\pm H_j$, for $i<j$ the two possibilities areEvery other coordinate is unchanged, and $s_{-\alpha }=s_{\alpha }$, so these formulas cover every root. The complete diagonal matrix is reconstructed with its last $n$ entries the reversed negatives of the first $n$ entries.

The Weyl group of Dn consists of all permutations of the $n$ coordinates together with an even number of coordinate sign changes. Equivalently,Its order is $2^{n-1}n!$. The difference-root reflections give ordinary transpositions; composing a sum-root reflection with the corresponding difference-root reflection negates precisely the two selected coordinates. These describe the generators of all even signed permutations. For $n=2$ the group has four elements; for the toral case $n=1$ it is trivial.

In the defining representation $V={\mathbb{C}}^{2n}$, the basis vectors $v_i$ and $v_{\bar{i}}$ have weights ${\epsilon }_i$ and $-{\epsilon }_i$, respectively, each with multiplicity one. Thus its formal character isThe vector $v_1$ is killed by every positive root space, since all positive-root matrices are upper triangular, and is a highest-weight vector. Any nonzero invariant subspace splits into weight spaces and therefore contains one of the natural weight vectors, since those weight spaces are one-dimensional. The root matrices connect that vector to all the others, so this representation is irreducible for $n\ge 2$. In terms of the fundamental weights of Dn, its highest weight is ${\omega }_1$ for $n\ge 3$ and ${\omega }_1+{\omega }_2$ for $n=2$.

The flip of the two tensor factors is equivariant, henceUse the invariant symmetric bilinear form $Q(u,v)=u^{T}Jv$. Contraction $C(u\otimes v)=Q(u,v)$ is an equivariant map to the trivial Lie algebra representation. Its inverse-form tensoris invariant and satisfies $C(\tau )=2n$. ConsequentlyThe traceless summand contains the highest-weight vector $v_1\otimes v_1$ of weight $2{\epsilon }_1$. The Weyl complete reducibility theorem states that every finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra representation is a direct sum of irreducible representations, so the submodule generated by this highest vector is $L(2{\epsilon }_1)$. The Weyl dimension formula verifies that it is the entire traceless space: only positive roots involving ${\epsilon }_1$ change their factors, andThis equals $\dim {\mathrm{Sym}}^{2}V-1=n(2n+1)-1$. Thus the traceless symmetric square of the defining even orthogonal representation is irreducible, including $n=2$.

For the other summand, the exterior square of the defining orthogonal representation has the equivariant identificationThe image is skew relative to $Q$, and in a basis making $Q$ the identity the images are the independent elementary skew matrices. The map is therefore an isomorphism onto the Adjoint representation of a Lie algebra. For $n\ge 3$, the connected Dn Dynkin diagram gives a simple Lie algebra (with $D_3=A_3$); its adjoint module is irreducible because its invariant subspaces are exactly its ideals. Its highest weight is ${\epsilon }_1+{\epsilon }_2$, and $v_1\wedge v_2$ is a highest vector. The tensor-square decomposition of the defining even orthogonal representation is consequentlyThe three dimensions are $(n+1)(2n-1)$, $n(2n-1)$ and one, adding to $4n^2$. The highest weights are $2{\omega }_1$, ${\omega }_2$ and zero for $n\ge 4$; for $n=3$ the middle weight is ${\omega }_2+{\omega }_3$.

For $n=2$, the Chiral decomposition of the complexified so4 Lie algebra splits the adjoint module into its two three-dimensional ideals. ThusThe weights are $2{\omega }_1+2{\omega }_2$, $2{\omega }_1$, $2{\omega }_2$ and zero. Equivalently, labelling highest weights by the two sl2 Lie algebra factors, this is $(2,2)\oplus (2,0)\oplus (0,2)\oplus (0,0)$. If $n=1$ is allowed, the abelian algebra has $V=L({\epsilon }_1)\oplus L(-{\epsilon }_1)$ and $V\otimes V=L(2{\epsilon }_1)\oplus 2L(0)\oplus L(-2{\epsilon }_1)$; there is then no single highest weight for an irreducible natural module.