Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2007 / iii / Paper 54 (String Theory)

Use the mostly-positive target Minkowski spacetime metric and a closed string coordinate $0\le \sigma <2\pi$. In conformal gauge, variation of the Polyakov action gives $({\partial }_{\tau }^2-{\partial }_{\sigma }^2)X^{\mu }=0$. The compact coordinate, denoted $X^{25}$, can change by $2\pi Rw$ around the closed string, with $w\in \mathbb{Z}$. Write $w^{\mu }=w{\delta }^{\mu ,25}$. Integrating the two chiral wave solutions and expanding their periodic parts gives the closed-string mode expansionReality imposes ${\alpha }_{-n}=({\alpha }_n{)}^{\ast }$ and the analogous condition in the other chirality. The classical compact momentum is continuous; quantization of a wavefunction on the circle subsequently gives $p^{25}=n/R$ with $n\in \mathbb{Z}$. The momentum and winding modes are most conveniently packaged asFor noncompact directions both zero modes are $\sqrt{{\alpha }^{\prime }/2}{p}^{\mu }$. Thus the formula includes both independent string oscillator families and all compact topological sectors.

Define the worldsheet stress-energy tensor by ${\theta }_{ab}=-2(-\gamma {)}^{-1/2}\delta I/\delta {\gamma }^{ab}$. Its normalization and components areAn overall rescaling of the named worldsheet stress tensor does not alter its vanishing. Variation of the independent worldsheet metric imposes ${\theta }_{ab}=0$, equivalently $(\dot{X}+X^{\prime }{)}^2=(\dot{X}-X^{\prime }{)}^2=0$. These are the Virasoro constraints that restrict the otherwise general wave solution.

The conjugate momentum density is $P_{\mu }={\dot{X}}_{\mu }/(2\pi {\alpha }^{\prime })$. The gauge-fixed Hamiltonian generating $\tau$ translation is thereforewith the analogous tilded generators. In particular, before imposing the Virasoro constraints,The target momentum includes its timelike component, so this is not a positive particle-energy formula. On the classical constraint surface the reparameterization Hamiltonian vanishes; target energy is the separate charge $p^0$. The difference $L_0-{\tilde{L}}_0=0$ imposes the residual spatial constraint.

In the quantum theory the same quadratic expressions require normal ordering: $[{\alpha }_m^{\mu },{\alpha }_n^{\nu }]=m{\eta }^{\mu \nu }{\delta }_{m+n,0}$ makes different orderings differ by divergent constants. Their regularized finite remainder is the normal-ordering constant of a string, or string intercept. The Virasoro central extension also appears. In the critical 26-dimensional bosonic string theory, the 24 transverse string oscillators give one-unit string intercept in each chirality. For example their regulated chiral vacuum energy is $24{\sum }_{k>0}k/2=-1$ using zeta function regularization. The physical zero-mode constraints are $(L_0-1)|\Psi ⟩=({\tilde{L}}_0-1)|\Psi ⟩=0$.

Let $M$ be the mass seen in the remaining 25 noncompact dimensions. Substituting the compact zero modes in these two constraints givesTaking their mean and difference yieldsThis sign of compact-circle closed-string level matching follows from assigning tildes to the left-moving sector. Under T-duality, set $R^{\prime }={\alpha }^{\prime }/R$, $n^{\prime }=w$, $w^{\prime }=n$. Then $p_L^{\prime }=p_L$ and $p_R^{\prime }=-p_R$, so reversing the compact right-moving string oscillators implements the transformation while leaving $N,\tilde{N}$ unchanged. Both the mass equation and closed-string level matching are invariant. This proves invariance of the full closed string spectrum, including its string oscillator degeneracies, rather than only the zero-mode contribution.

A D-brane with $p$ spatial worldvolume directions, called a D$p$-brane, is a $(p+1)$-dimensional timelike submanifold on which open string endpoints have Neumann boundary conditions tangentially and Dirichlet boundary conditions transversely. Apply T-duality to the compact coordinate by $\tilde{X}=X_L-X_R$. The differential relationsinterchange the two endpoint conditions. Consequently a D$p$-brane wrapping the original circle becomes a D$(p-1)$-brane localized on the dual circle. Its compact Wilson line specifies that position. This is T-duality of D-brane boundary conditions.

The separated-brane configuration must instead have the circle transverse to the D-branes. Two parallel D-branes wrapping the same circle cannot be separated along that worldvolume direction. Thus the latter part describes a new orientation, with both endpoints subject to compact Dirichlet boundary conditions. If their positions differ by $L$, an oriented Open string stretched between D-branes has displacementOn $0\le \sigma \le \pi$, its compact classical solution has a linear part $y_1+L_w\sigma /\pi$, plus sine modes vanishing at the endpoints. This adds $L_w^2/(4{\pi }^2{\alpha }^{\prime })$ to the Virasoro generator zero mode. Thus, for momentum $\mathbf{p}$ along the D-branes,The second equation is the quantum rest-energy squared of the string oscillator ground state; the smallest one uses the shortest allowed compact separation $|L_w|$. Classically the straight string energy is $T|L_w|=|L_w|/(2\pi {\alpha }^{\prime })$. The quantum ground state is a tachyon if $|L_w|<2\pi \sqrt{{\alpha }^{\prime }}$, so in that regime it is an instability rather than a state with real rest energy. Dropping the string intercept would describe the classical stretched string, not its quantum ground state.

The transverse-circle T-duality changes these two D-branes to D$(p+1)$-branes wrapping the dual circle. Their positions become the eigenvalues $A_i=y_i/(2\pi {\alpha }^{\prime })$ of a constant gauge connection. The Wilson loop phases are $e^{i2\pi R^{\prime }{A}_i}=e^{i{y}_i/R}$. A string connecting D-brane $1$ to D-brane $2$ has dual compact momentumIts momentum contribution to $E^2$ is exactly the former stretching term, including every winding sector. Qualitatively the two geometrically coincident wrapped D-branes are distinguished by their Wilson lines, and their connecting strings have shifted momentum quantization. This is how brane separation becomes a Wilson line.

In conformal gauge, a free closed bosonic string has $({\partial }_{\tau }^2-{\partial }_{\sigma }^2)X^{\mu }=0$, periodicity in $\sigma$, and the two Virasoro constraints $(\dot{X}\pm X^{\prime }{)}^2=0$. Its left- and right-moving string oscillator families have independent Virasoro generators $L_n$ and ${\tilde{L}}_n$. In old covariant string quantization, a physical string state obeyswith $a=1$ in the critical bosonic string theory. The two zero-mode conditions also impose closed-string level matching. For an open string, keep just one string oscillator family. Negative-mode constraints are adjoints on bras, not additional annihilation conditions on physical string states.

A spurious string state is a Virasoro descendant orthogonal to every physical string state: if $|s⟩={\sum }_{n>0}{L}_{-n}|{\chi }_n⟩$, then $⟨\Phi |s⟩=0$ follows from $L_n|\Phi ⟩=0$ and $L_n^{†}=L_{-n}$. A null string state is a spurious state that is itself physical. It consequently has zero norm and is removed in the null-state quotient of a string. The calculations below concern one string oscillator family and use

For $|n_1⟩=L_{-1}|{\chi }_1⟩$ with $L_0|{\chi }_1⟩=0$ and all positive modes zero, $L_0|n_1⟩=|n_1⟩$. AlsoIt is therefore physical for string intercept one and spurious by construction. In particular $\Vert n_1{\Vert }^2=⟨{\chi }_1|2L_0|{\chi }_1⟩=0$. This proves the requested level-one descendant is null.

For the scalar descendant, write $|v_b⟩=(L_{-2}+b{L}_{-1}^2)|{\chi }_2⟩$ with $L_0|{\chi }_2⟩=-|{\chi }_2⟩$ and positive modes zero. Direct commutation givesFor instance $[L_1,L_{-1}^2]|{\chi }_2⟩=-2L_{-1}|{\chi }_2⟩$ and $L_2{L}_{-1}^2|{\chi }_2⟩=-6|{\chi }_2⟩$. Modes $m\ge 3$ annihilate $|v_b⟩$ because every remaining positive mode annihilates its parent. Hence the physical scalar descendant requires $b=3/2$ and $d=26$:It is spurious, so physicality also proves orthogonality and zero norm without an extra positivity assumption.

The printed coefficient $3/4$ does not give this null string state. It instead gives $L_1|v_{3/4}⟩=\frac{3}{2}{L}_{-1}|{\chi }_2⟩$, generally nonzero. For a normalized highest-weight parent with weight $-1$ at $d=26$, the descendant Gram matrix isThus the printed vector has norm $9/4$, whereas the corrected vector has norm zero. This is a genuine PDF coefficient error. Away from 26 dimensions even the corrected coefficient does not give the claimed physical null string state; the remaining condition is $L_2|v_{3/2}⟩=(d-26)|{\chi }_2⟩/2$.

The level-two open string state also needs a source correction: its vector string oscillator must be ${\alpha }_{-2}^{\mu }$, not the printed ${\alpha }_{-1}^{\mu }$. A single ${\alpha }_{-1}$ has level one and cannot share the stated mass-shell condition with the two-${\alpha }_{-1}$ term. Put $q^{\mu }={\alpha }_0^{\mu }=\sqrt{2{\alpha }^{\prime }}{p}^{\mu }$, and write the genuine level-two state asThe mass-shell condition $L_0=1$ gives ${\alpha }^{\prime }{p}^2+2=1$, so $q^2=-2$. The commutators above giveFor the second formula, the contraction from the two ${\alpha }_{-1}$ operators is exactly $a^{\mu }{}_{\mu }$, not twice that value. Modes $m>2$ vanish automatically. We have derivedThe coefficient formulas in the question are consequently consistent after the string oscillator correction and with $d=26$.

To prove the full level-two open-string polarization decomposition, not merely check one candidate, defineThe constraints give $q\cdot b=-t/2$ and therefore $q\cdot A=0$. Contracting $c$ with $q$ givesIts trace is $t-t(26+3q^2)/20-2q\cdot A=0$. Thus $c$ is symmetric, traceless and transverse. Conversely, arbitrary $t$, a vector $A$ with $q\cdot A=0$, and such a tensor $c$ giveand direct contraction verifies both constraints. The number $20$ uses $d=26$; it would not reproduce the same unrestricted trace in arbitrary dimension.

Finally the two unphysical pieces are precisely the descendants already proved null. The vector part iswhose parent has $L_0=0$ and all positive modes zero because $q\cdot A=0$. For the scalar part useThenhas exactly the scalar tensor $t(3q_{\mu }{q}_{\nu }+{\eta }_{\mu \nu })/20$ and vector $t{q}_{\mu }/4$. The momentum vacuum has $L_0=-1$ and positive modes zero, as required. HenceThe physical quotient contains only the transverse traceless tensor. Its massive little-group space has dimension $25\cdot 26/2-1=324$, agreeing with the light-cone gauge in string theory count $24\cdot 25/2+24=324$ at level two.

For an oriented Euclidean string worldsheet with metric $h_{ab}$, use the string nonlinear sigma model actionHere ${ϵ}^{ab}$ is an antisymmetric density with ${ϵ}^{12}=1$. The factor $i$ in the Euclidean Kalb–Ramond field term follows from continuing the real Lorentzian two-form coupling; reversing orientation or the convention for $B$ reverses its sign. The conventional positive Euclidean dilaton coupling is being used. With worldsheet boundaries its curvature coupling also needs ${\int }_{\partial \Sigma }\Phi kds/(2\pi )$, where $k$ is the boundary geodesic curvature, to have the proper topological normalization for constant $\Phi$.

All three terms are invariant under worldsheet diffeomorphisms. Target-coordinate changes act on $X,G,B,\Phi$ by their ordinary scalar and tensor transformation rules, making the target description covariant as well. For the two-form there is also the target gauge symmetry $B\mapsto B+d\Lambda$. Its change in the closed-worldsheet action is an integral of an exact two-form and hence zero. With boundaries it is instead $i{\int }_{\partial \Sigma }{X}^{\ast }\Lambda /(2\pi {\alpha }^{\prime })$; an endpoint gauge field with $\delta A=-\Lambda /(2\pi {\alpha }^{\prime })$ cancels it.

Under a local Weyl transformation $h_{ab}\mapsto e^{2\omega }{h}_{ab}$, the metric term is invariant because the two-dimensional factors $\sqrt{h}$ and $h^{ab}$ cancel. The $B$ term is independent of $h$ and is separately invariant. The curvature transforms asOn a closed surface the dilaton variation is consequentlyThus a general nonconstant dilaton term is not separately invariant under Weyl transformations. Its variation is the Weyl variation of a nonconstant dilaton coupling; it vanishes for constant $\Phi$ after the boundary completion where necessary.

For $\Phi ={\Phi }_0$, the Gauss-Bonnet theorem gives $S_{\Phi }={\Phi }_0\chi (\Sigma )$. In the Euclidean path integral the resulting weight isFor a connected orientable genus-$g$ surface with $b$ boundaries, $\chi =2-2g-b$, so the weight is $g_s^{2g+b-2}$. A closed-string handle therefore adds two powers of string coupling. External vertex normalizations add their own coupling factors; they are distinct from this dilaton Euler-characteristic weighting. The constant dilaton controls the string genus expansion, rather than adding a force to the classical embedding equation.

Quantization treats the target fields as position-dependent couplings of a two-dimensional interacting quantum field theory. Expanding $X$ around a background embedding gives fluctuation vertices involving target curvature and derivatives of $B$ and $\Phi$. Short-distance contractions require local counterterms, so the target fields become renormalized couplings. In particular a curvature vertex contracted once yields a Ricci tensor counterterm proportional to ${\alpha }^{\prime }{R}_{\mu \nu }$. Each additional sigma-model loop brings another power of ${\alpha }^{\prime }$ and more target derivatives. The expansion is useful when the target variation scale is large compared with $\sqrt{{\alpha }^{\prime }}$; it is not the separate expansion in powers of $g_s$.

After gauge fixing, a worldsheet Weyl anomaly would make amplitudes depend on the discarded local conformal factor. Quantum consistency therefore requires the trace anomaly to vanish, including the reparameterization worldsheet ghost field contribution. In a conventional renormalization scheme the resulting bosonic sigma-model Weyl anomaly coefficients start asThe barred quantities include the dilaton stress-energy tensor improvement; ordinary coupling sigma-model beta functions can differ by field redefinitions or target diffeomorphisms. Setting these coefficients to zero gives differential equations for the background fields order by order, including the metric gravitational equation and the antisymmetric-field equation. These conventions for the leading coefficients are described in the background-field lecture notes. Higher orders supply higher-curvature and higher-derivative corrections. This explains how spacetime dynamics follows from quantum gauge consistency of the worldsheet, not from asking only for a classical stationary worldsheet in an arbitrarily chosen background.

The apparently noninvariant dilaton term is essential outside the critical dimension because its stress-energy tensor improvement can cancel the quantum central charge mismatch. A flat constant-dilaton background has matter central charge $d$ and worldsheet ghost field central charge $-26$. If $d\ne 26$, changing the constant value of $\Phi$ only changes $g_s$ and cannot cure that mismatch.

A concrete solution is the linear dilaton conformal field theory with $G=\eta$, $B=0$, and $\Phi ={\Phi }_0+V_{\mu }{X}^{\mu }$. Its metric and antisymmetric-field anomaly coefficients vanish, while the scalar condition isOne can also see this cancellation directly from the improved holomorphic stress-energy tensor. With the positive Euclidean curvature convention above,The free-field contraction is $X^{\mu }(z)X^{\nu }(w)\sim -{\alpha }^{\prime }{\eta }^{\mu \nu }\log (z-w)/2$. Differentiating it twice at each point gives a fourth-order pole $3{\alpha }^{\prime }{V}^2/(z-w{)}^4$ from the improvement. Since the fourth-order stress-tensor pole is $c/2$, the matter central charge becomes $c=d+6{\alpha }^{\prime }{V}^2=26$. The worldsheet ghost field contribution then cancels it. This is why a classical Weyl variation need not mean inconsistency: it can cancel the quantum variation of the other terms. For $d<26$ the required gradient is spacelike; for $d>26$ it is timelike in the Lorentzian target theory. Such backgrounds are not flat constant-dilaton Minkowski vacua with full target Lorentz symmetry, nor does a central charge cancellation by itself prove stability or unitarity of every noncritical background. If the conformal factor is instead retained dynamically, its Liouville field theory supplies the corresponding noncritical description.

Take ${\partial }_{\pm }=({\partial }_{\tau }\pm {\partial }_{\sigma })/2$ on the strip $0\le \sigma \le \pi$. Varying the Grassmann-odd worldsheet Majorana fermions gives ${\partial }_{-}{\psi }_1=0$, ${\partial }_{+}{\psi }_2=0$ and, up to the orientation of the strip boundary, the surface termAt each endpoint it vanishes if ${\psi }_1=\eta {\psi }_2$ with $\eta =\pm 1$, with the same relation on variations. A common sign can be absorbed by redefining one chiral field, so set ${\eta }_0=+1$. Since ${\psi }_1=f(\tau +\sigma )$ and ${\psi }_2=f(\tau -\sigma )$, the second endpoint imposes $f(u+2\pi )={\eta }_{\pi }f(u)$. Equal endpoint signs give the periodic Ramond sector, and opposite endpoint signs give the antiperiodic Neveu–Schwarz sector:These gluing choices preserve the Neumann-endpoint worldsheet supersymmetry conditions and give integer or half-integer worldsheet Majorana fermion modes, respectively.

First fix a normalization issue in the original PDF. With its stated canonical string oscillator algebra, the standard superconformal current mode iswithout the printed factor $1/2$. To check the Ramond supercurrent zero-mode square directly, pair positive and negative integer modes:The zero-mode Clifford relations give $({\alpha }_0\cdot {\psi }_0{)}^2={\alpha }_0^2/2$. Different $Q_m$ anticommute, and so do $Q_m$ with the zero-mode term. The two same-sign terms in $Q_m^2$ vanish by antisymmetry of the fermions and symmetry of the bosonic product. The cross terms giveThe second term comes from commuting ${\alpha }_m$ through ${\alpha }_{-m}$, so the frequency factor $m$ is essential. ThereforeHere $L_0^R$ uses vacuum-annihilating Ramond normal ordering; its string intercept is zero. A plane-to-cylinder central shift must be included consistently if a different zero-mode convention is used.

For the mode $F_r=G_r/2$ actually printed, the algebra instead gives $\{F_0,F_0\}=L_0^R/2$. Already the oscillator-free term gives $\{F_0,F_0\}={\alpha }_0^2/4$, whereas $2L_0^R={\alpha }_0^2$. Thus the requested identity is not valid with both that prefactor and the supplied string oscillator algebra. Removing the prefactor gives the identity just derived. Renaming $L_0^R/4$ as $L_0$ would fix this isolated equality but would spoil the usual Virasoro normalization and the subsequent mass formula. We use the standard normalized modes $G_r$ in the remaining physical constraints; their vanishing is unaffected by a common nonzero rescaling.

The RNS string physical-state conditions in the two sectors areThe last condition is the fermionic zero-mode constraint; its square implies the Ramond mass-shell condition. Physical null string states are quotiented. Matter central charge is $3d/2$, while the reparameterization worldsheet ghost fields and superconformal ghosts contribute $-26+11=-15$. Thus $d=10$ is the critical dimension of the RNS superstring, with $a_{NS}=1/2$ and $a_R=0$.

To solve the constraints, choose $X^{\pm }=(X^0\pm X^9)/\sqrt{2}$, so ${\eta }_{+-}=-1$, and work on a patch with ${\alpha }_0^{+}=\sqrt{2{\alpha }^{\prime }}{p}^{+}\ne 0$. In light-cone gauge in string theory fix all nonzero ${\alpha }_n^{+}$ and all ${\psi }_r^{+}$ to zero. For the Ramond sector, the printed restriction to nonzero fermion modes is not by itself complete: one must also reduce the longitudinal fermionic zero modes using the zero-mode supersymmetry constraint. The usual reduced light-cone description sets the remaining ${\psi }_0^{+}$ to zero as well and retains the transverse Clifford algebra. Covariantly this reduction is the Dirac equation on the ground-state particle polarization; it is not an extra unconstrained canonical string oscillator.

With this reduction the string oscillator generators have the formRepeated $i$ runs over the eight transverse directions. The coefficient in $L_n^{\perp }$ comes from the fermion worldsheet stress tensor $-\psi \partial \psi /2$; for $n=0$, positive and negative $r$ combine to give the occupation energy $r{\psi }_{-r}{\psi }_r$. Thus the light-cone super-Virasoro constraints are explicitly solved byHere $a$ is $1/2$ in the NS sector and zero in the R sector. The zero-mode equation says $2p^{+}{p}^{-}=p_i^2+(N-a)/{\alpha }^{\prime }$. All longitudinal excitations are consequently determined by transverse bilinears. The critical dimension and string intercepts are necessary for the resulting quantum theory to preserve the target Lorentz algebra.

The frequency-weighted Neveu–Schwarz level operator isThe PDF's displayed number operator omits the fermion frequency weights and the $r=1/2$ term. With the stated anticommutators that cannot be a level operator: it would assign no level to the first fermionic excitation. The bosonic term already includes its frequency through $[{\alpha }_n,{\alpha }_{-n}]=n$, whereas the fermionic term must include its frequency explicitly.

One independent way to obtain the string intercept is the transverse zero-point energy. Each periodic boson contributes $\frac{1}{2}{\sum }_{n\ge 1}n=-1/24$. Each antiperiodic real fermion contributes $-\frac{1}{2}{\sum }_{r\ge 1/2}r=-1/48$, with the minus sign due to fermionic normal ordering. For example a common exponential cutoff givesSubtracting the local divergent terms leaves $8(-1/24-1/48)=-1/2$, so the NS string intercept is $a=1/2$. In the Ramond sector the integer fermions instead contribute $+1/24$ per component and cancel the bosonic contribution, giving $a_R=0$.

The unprojected NS sector oscillator vacuum has $N=0$ andIt is a spacetime scalar tachyon. The first excitation ${\psi }_{-1/2}^i|0;p⟩$ has $N=1/2$ and is massless, with eight vector particle polarizations. Covariantly its particle polarization obeys $p\cdot ϵ=0$ modulo the longitudinal null particle polarization, leaving the same eight degrees of freedom.

The R sector oscillator vacuum is also massless, but it is degenerate because $\{{\psi }_0^{\mu },{\psi }_0^{\nu }\}={\eta }^{\mu \nu }$. The operators ${\Gamma }^{\mu }=\sqrt{2}{\psi }_0^{\mu }$ give the target Clifford algebra, and $G_0|u;p⟩=0$ becomes $p_{\mu }{\Gamma }^{\mu }u=0$. At nonzero null momentum this Dirac equation leaves sixteen unprojected on-shell spinor states. Equivalently the eight transverse zero modes give the sixteen-dimensional spin representation $8_s\oplus 8_c$ of $SO(8)$. Thus the Ramond ground state describes spacetime fermions, not a single scalar oscillator vacuum.

To define the GSO projection explicitly, let $f_{NS}$ count excited NS fermions and give its vacuum even parity. ThenIt retains odd fermion number, removes the tachyon, and retains the eight massless vector particle polarizations. In the Ramond sector let ${\Gamma }_{\ast }$ be transverse chirality and $f_R$ count nonzero-mode fermions. Choose one consistent chirality sign $s=\pm 1$ and useEach operator squares to itself. At the ground level $P_R$ retains one eight-dimensional spinor chirality, so the retained spectrum has eight massless bosonic and eight massless fermionic states. The parity convention can instead assign the NS vacuum odd parity and write a plus projector; the retained states are identical.

Equality continues at every mass level. Let $q$ count ${\alpha }^{\prime }{M}^2$, suppressing common momentum and endpoint-label factors, and set $D(q)={\prod }_{n\ge 1}(1-q^n{)}^8$. The projected string oscillator generating functions areThe Ramond factor eight follows because either chirality projector selects eight ground states for every nonzero-oscillator parity. The Jacobi abstruse identity makes the bracket equal to $16q^{1/2}{\prod }_{n\ge 1}(1+q^n{)}^8$, soThis proves level-by-level equality of bosonic and fermionic multiplicities. The appropriate spacetime supercharge from an RNS spin field relates the two sectors; the projection ensures that it acts within the retained state space. These sector and chirality conventions agree with the primary superstring lecture notes. Equal total counts alone are not the definition of the projection; they follow from the stated parity selection and the string oscillator identity.