Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2014 / iii / Paper 68 / 3 / Solution

A rigorous Mumford–Shah functional permits nonsmooth image signals and free discontinuities. One classical admissible class consists of relatively closed countably rectifiable sets $K\subset \Omega$ with finite Hausdorff measure ${\mathcal{H}}^1(K)$, and $u\in W^{1,2}(\Omega \setminus K)\cap L^{\infty }(\Omega )$ with finite energy. No exterior boundary values are prescribed. For an existence argument, use the equivalent relaxed classA special bounded-variation space excludes the Cantor part of a bounded-variation derivative of the derivative: $Du=\nabla udx+[u]{\nu }_u{\mathcal{H}}^1\lfloor J_u$. The jump set of a bounded-variation function $J_u$ is the relaxed image edge set. Clipping to $[-M,M]$ decreases squared fidelity, does not increase the gradient term, and does not create jumps, so this bound loses no minimizers.

Take a minimizing sequence and compare with a constant image signal. Its $L^2$ gradient norms and jump lengths are bounded. Alsoso the sequence is bounded in $BV$. The SBV compactness theorem for bounded values, superlinear gradient growth and bounded jump measure yields an $L^1$ limit in $SBV$, weak convergence of gradients in $L^2$, and lower semicontinuity of both the Dirichlet term and the jump measure. The uniform value bound upgrades convergence to $L^2$, so fidelity converges. This proves existence of a relaxed minimizer. Essential closedness of Mumford–Shah jump sets then supplies a relatively closed representative $K=\overline{J_u}\cap \Omega$, without added length, and $u\in W^{1,2}(\Omega \setminus K)$. This completes the outline for the classical pair problem. Arbitrary Hausdorff convergence of image edge sets alone is not an adequate substitute for these compactness and regularity results. No uniqueness is claimed for segmentation.

As $\alpha \to \infty$ with $\beta$ fixed, bounded energy forces $\nabla u\to 0$ in $L^2$. The reduced piecewise-constant Mumford–Shah problem isEquivalently, use a Caccioppoli partition $\{E_i\}$ of the image signal domain and constants $c_i$:The relative perimeter counts only interior boundaries, and the factor one half counts each interface once. Adjacent equal-valued regions can be merged, removing unnecessary boundaries.

For fixed $K$, let $E_i$ be its positive-area regions. Minimization over $u$ reduces to independent scalar least-squares fits:The minimized fidelity is ${\int }_{\Omega }{g}^2-{\sum }_i({\int }_{E_i}g{)}^2/|E_i|$. Thus region means in piecewise-constant segmentation give the optimal grey values for a fixed segmentation.

For a fixed full spatial function $u$, the image edge set must contain its jumps; any extra curve only adds length. The optimal choice is its essential jump set, with a relatively closed representative when appropriate. There is no independent relocation of boundaries while that full function is held fixed. A different common alternating step fixes the values $c_i$ but allows the labels $E_i$ to move. It minimizes the fidelity-plus-perimeter partition functional above. Without the perimeter term each point takes its nearest grey value; with it, interface length is penalized. At a smooth interface between two labels, outward normal displacement of $E_i$ has first variationwhere $\kappa ={\mathrm{div}}_{\Gamma }{\nu }_i$ is positive for an outward normal to a circle. The stationary segmentation interface curvature balance isThis is the geometric interpretation of optimizing boundaries with fixed grey levels, and distinguishes it from fixing the whole spatial image signal.

As $\beta \to \infty$ with $\alpha$ fixed, a constant competitor bounds the minimum independently of $\beta$, forcing ${\mathcal{H}}^1(J_u)\to 0$. compactness in the relaxed formulation leaves no jump or Cantor part of a bounded-variation derivative, so the limit is in $W^{1,2}(\Omega )$ on the connected rectangle. The reduced edge-free Mumford–Shah limit isA set of zero length can be omitted; this does not impose a zero image signal or a Dirichlet boundary value. Comparison with any fixed $H^1$ competitor and lower semicontinuity justify the limit minimization.

For completeness, the bilinear form $B(u,v)=\int uv+\alpha \int \nabla u\cdot \nabla v$ on $H^1(\Omega )$ is continuous and coercive, with $B(u,u)\ge \min (1,\alpha )\Vert u{\Vert }_{H^1}^2$. The right-hand side $\int gv$ is bounded because $g\in L^2$ on the bounded rectangle. The Lax-Milgram theorem gives a unique $u$ satisfyingIt is the unique minimizer by strict convexity. Formally,with the Neumann condition understood through this weak formulation. Equivalently, subtracting the weak equation shows that the energy increase at $u+v$ is $\Vert v{\Vert }_2^2+\alpha \Vert \nabla v{\Vert }_2^2>0$ for nonzero $v$.