Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Oxford / 2023 / Prelims / Mathematics IV / 2 / c

Write $N=(n_1,n_2,n_3)$. Restriction to the plane $z=0$ givesThis is an equation of degree at most two in two Cartesian coordinates, the general algebraic form of a conic, with possible degenerate conics and an empty set of real points. No determinant hypothesis is needed for this substitution.

For an arbitrary plane, choose a point ${\mathbf{x}}_0$ and an orthonormal basis $\mathbf{e},\mathbf{f}$ of its direction linear subspace. Put $B=(\mathbf{e}\mathbf{f})$ and $\mathbf{x}={\mathbf{x}}_0+B\mathbf{\xi }$, where $\mathbf{\xi }=(s,t{)}^T$. With $S=(M+M^T)/2$, the symmetric part of a matrix, the restricted equation isThis proves the plane-section result whenever “conic” allows the appropriate degeneracies. A rigid motion taking the chosen plane to $z=0$ gives the same argument.

The source's assumption $\det M\ne 0$ does not guarantee a nondegenerate conic. Even with $M=I$ and $f=x^2+y^2+z^2-1$, the section $z=1$ is a single point, and $z=2$ has no real points. With the nonsingular symmetric matrix giving $f=2xz+y^2$, the section $z=0$ is the repeated straight line $y=0$.

There is a further literal omission: the source does not assume $M$ is symmetric. Forone has $\det M=2$ but $f=2xz$. Thus the section $z=0$ is the entire plane, rather than a conic. Only $S$ controls the quadratic form; invertibility of an arbitrary $M$ cannot remove this exception. If the intended hypothesis is that $M$ is symmetric and nonsingular, the quadratic restriction to a plane cannot vanish identically: otherwise $B^{T}MB=0$, so $M$ would map a two-dimensional linear subspace injectively into its one-dimensional orthogonal complement, which is impossible. Degenerate and empty sections still remain possible.