Past exam of the options II course of the University of Oxford / 2011 / G (Calculus of Variations)

For a regular isoperimetric constraint, introduce a constant Lagrange multiplier $\lambda$ and set $L=F-\lambda G$. With fixed endpoint values, the Euler-Lagrange equation isIf $F$ and $G$ have no explicit $x$ dependence, the Beltrami identity gives the first integralThe regularity assumption excludes the exceptional case in which the constraint itself has zero first variation for every admissible perturbation.

Parametrize the surface of revolution by $r(z,\theta )=(f(z)\cos \theta ,f(z)\sin \theta ,z)$. The magnitude of $r_z\times r_{\theta }$ is $f\sqrt{1+f^{\prime 2}}$. Integrating the resulting surface area element over $\theta$, and integrating the circular cross-sectional areas for the volume, givesHere $f\ge 0$ because it is a radius. For a regular connected closed surface, take $f>0$ in the interior; the closing endpoints can have unbounded $f^{\prime }$ even when the surface itself is smooth.

After dividing $A-\lambda V$ by $\pi$, its integrand is $L=2f\sqrt{1+f^{\prime 2}}-\lambda f^2$. The Euler-Lagrange equation and Beltrami identity becomeAs $f$ tends to zero at an endpoint, $0\le 2f/\sqrt{1+f^{\prime 2}}\le 2f$ also tends to zero, so $C=0$. On the positive interior this implies $\lambda >0$ and, writing $R=2/\lambda$,The Euler-Lagrange equation also yields $f^{\prime \prime }=-R^2/f^3$. Thereforeincluding at the maximum where $f^{\prime }=0$. Integrating and using the first integral givesThus the regular extremal is a sphere. The two zeros fix its center and radius:Equivalently, the prescribed volume fixes $R=(3V/(4\pi ){)}^{1/3}$. If $a,b$ are fixed in advance, their separation and the prescribed volume must be compatible with these equations; there is no positive regular stationary profile of the stated type for an incompatible volume.

For minimality, the three-dimensional isoperimetric inequality states that every sufficiently regular closed surface enclosing volume $V$ haswith equality precisely for a sphere. Our extremal has $A=4\pi R^2$ and $V=4\pi R^3/3$, so it attains equality and is a global minimum of area at the fixed volume. This also makes clear the connected-surface assumption behind uniqueness: allowing several disconnected components introduces stationary collections of spheres, rather than the single positive generating profile used here.