Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge / 2014 / Paper 1 / Section C / C11 / a / Solution

For a normalized top-hat wavefunction of width $L$ centred at zero, $\psi (x)=L^{-1/2}$ inside the interval and zero outside. Its position distribution has $⟨x⟩=0$ and $\Delta x=L/\sqrt{12}$. With Fourier convention $(2\pi \hslash {)}^{-1/2}$, the momentum amplitude isThe momentum density has long oscillatory $1/p^2$ tails. Consequently $\int p^2|\tilde{\psi }{|}^{2}dp$ diverges: the ideal discontinuous top hat has infinite r.m.s. momentum spread. Its symmetric momentum density has formal principal-value mean zero, but no finite absolute first moment either. The finite-variance form $\Delta x\Delta p\ge \hslash /2$ is therefore not saturated and cannot be evaluated using the width of the central diffraction lobe as $\Delta p$.

The first momentum zeros occur at $p=\pm 2\pi \hslash /L$, showing the inverse-width scale. Smoothing the edges sufficiently gives a finite momentum variance and restores the ordinary finite-variance uncertainty comparison; sharper edges require larger high-momentum components. It is the ideal jump, not a violation of the uncertainty principle, that causes the divergence.