Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge / 2016 / Paper 2 / Section D / D13 / a

The free electron model replaces the detailed periodic potential by a constant background, treating conduction electrons as mobile particles with approximately parabolic dispersion $E={\hslash }^2{k}^2/(2m)$. It is useful to distinguish the classical Drude model from the quantum free electron gas. They share a simple transport picture, but differ fundamentally in occupation statistics.

With a momentum-relaxation time $\tau$, both lead in a simple isotropic one-band approximation toThis explains approximately Ohmic longitudinal conduction and a carrier-density scale from the Hall effect. The relaxation time is phenomenological: introducing it does not itself predict scattering from defects or phonons. A four-probe resistance measurement separates the sample's longitudinal response from current-contact voltage drops; field and current reversals isolate the transverse signal.

The classical model incorrectly assigns roughly $3N{k}_B/2$ of electronic heat capacity, far too large in a degenerate metal. Fermi-Dirac statistics fixes this: most occupied states cannot change occupation after a small thermal perturbation because nearby low-energy states are already filled. Only a fraction of order $k_{B}T/E_F$ near the Fermi energy participates. For $T\ll T_F$,The quantum model also gives a finite Fermi velocity even at zero temperature and Pauli paramagnetism. Under predominantly elastic scattering, its electronic heat and charge conductivities obey the Wiedemann-Franz law,This is a quantum success; classical equipartition does not give the correct small heat capacity and Lorenz number together.

Its limitations are equally instructive. Without the periodic potential it has no band gaps, so it cannot distinguish a filled-band insulator from a metal or explain semiconductor doping. The simplest single-electron Hall formula cannot explain positive Hall coefficients; band curvature and electron holes, or a multiband transport treatment, are needed. It neglects much Fermi-surface anisotropy and detailed optical interband absorption. Noninteracting electrons alone do not explain ferromagnetism or superconductivity, and lattice thermal behavior needs phonons. The nearly-free electron model, which allows reciprocal-lattice Fourier components of the potential to mix plane waves, provides a controlled first correction near Bragg planes.

Its main success is a simple quantitative baseline for degenerate conduction electrons; its main failure is treating the crystal and interactions as too featureless. A fit of conductivity alone is not a test of the whole model: compare heat capacity, Hall sign, optical response and temperature dependence using independently constrained parameters.