Past exam of the physics B course of the University of Cambridge / 2019 / Paper 1 / Section C / C9 / Solution

The dynamical method. In Lagrangian mechanics, choose independent generalized coordinates $q_j$ consistent with the constraints, form the Lagrangian $\mathcal{L}=T-V$, and solve the Euler-Lagrange equations,This form applies to a Newtonian system with ideal constraints, so constraint forces do no allowed virtual work, and with the remaining forces derivable from the stated potential. Smooth holonomic constraints can be built into the coordinates. Additional nonconservative generalized forces would appear on the right. Prescribed shaft rotation is a driven constraint; its constant $\Omega$ is a parameter, not a conserved angular momentum.

Energy of the two balls. The diagram labels each ball $m/2$, so their combined mass is $m$. It also shows $\theta$ between an arm and the downward vertical, rather than the full angle between the arms. Each ball has horizontal radius $l\sin \theta$, vertical coordinate $-l\cos \theta$, and squared speed $l^2{\dot{\theta }}^2+l^2{\Omega }^2{\sin }^2\theta$. ThusandThe massless connecting rods and sliding collar enforce the geometry but contribute no energy.

Effective potential. Define ${\omega }_0^2=g/l$. At fixed $\Omega$,This effective potential determines the reduced $\theta$ dynamics. Its conserved effective energy is not the full lab-frame mechanical energy: the shaft drive can exchange work and angular momentum with the balls.

The change of stability. Near $\theta =0$,For $|\Omega |<{\omega }_0$, the downward state is a minimum. At $|\Omega |={\omega }_0$, its quadratic stiffness vanishes but the quartic coefficient is $+{\omega }_0^2/8$. Above that speed, the downward state becomes a maximum and stable nonzero openings appear. This is the gravity-restored centrifugal governor bifurcation.

The physical opening is nonnegative; the two minima in the signed extension represent opposite transverse displacements. The stable opening increases continuously from zero toward a right angle as $|\Omega |$ grows. The apparatus is frictionless in the model, so a displaced system oscillates rather than automatically settling at the equilibrium shown by the minima.

Equilibria. Differentiation givesHence the downward equilibrium is $\theta =0$, and the open equilibria satisfyThe signed extension includes the negative of this angle. Formally $\theta =\pi$ is also stationary, but it is an unstable inverted configuration and lies outside the usual opening range of the mechanism.

Small oscillations. Write $\theta ={\theta }_{\mathrm{eq}}+\eta$. The linear equation is $\ddot{\eta }+{\nu }^2\eta =0$, whereAt the downward state and at a nonzero open state, respectively,These are angular frequencies in ${\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$; ordinary frequencies are $\nu /(2\pi )$. Negative ${\nu }^2$ indicates exponential instability rather than an oscillation. At $\theta =\pi$, ${\nu }^2=-{\omega }_0^2-{\Omega }^2<0$. At the critical speed, the linear frequency is zero and the positive quartic potential gives amplitude-dependent nonlinear restoring motion.