Past exam of the physics course of the year 1 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge / 2012 / Paper 1 / Section B / B9 / Solution

For a fixed set of bodies in an inertial frame, total linear momentum is constant if the resultant external force vanishes. Summing Newton's second law cancels internal force pairs by Newton's third law. For an open subsystem, momentum carried across its boundary must also be included.

For an equal-intake-fuel mass-loading rocket, enclose the original craft and the stationary material collected during $dt$. Its initial momentum is $mu$. At the end, the craft has mass $m-\mu dt$ and the exhaust has mass $2\mu dt$. To first order,The first term is rocket thrust; the second is the momentum cost of collecting stationary matter. It vanishes in the conventional rocket equation, which therefore has no analogous fixed exhaust-speed ceiling in Newtonian mechanics. Here the acceleration vanishes at $u_{\max }=2u_0$; from rest it stays positive below that value while fuel remains. Relativistic limits are outside this model.

For constant $\mu$, mass conservation gives $m=m_i-\mu t$. Separating variables,ThereforeThe formal limiting speed would require $t=m_i/\mu$ and zero remaining craft mass. A positive rocket dry mass and finite carried fuel terminate the burn earlier. Maintaining nonzero collection rate even at rest is an idealization explicitly prescribed by the problem.