Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2004 iii Paper 63 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For Roche-lobe overflow, . Cubing the Roche lobe approximation and using the donor's mass-radius relation givesKepler's third law therefore yields the Roche-lobe period-mass relation for a linear donor radius law:The component distances from the centre of mass are and . Summing their angular momenta gives the circular-binary orbital angular momentumDuring conservative binary mass transfer, and . Logarithmic differentiation at constant angular momentum gives . Thus the Roche-lobe radius response exponent givesTheir difference is . Since the donor loses mass, this is positive for : the donor shrinks relative to its Roche lobe, so transfer shuts off without an external driver. The Roche lobe itself expands only for ; for it shrinks more slowly than the donor.
Gravitational-wave emission from a binary system provides such a driver: the orbit emits gravitational waves carrying energy and angular momentum, and the shrinking Roche lobe can maintain contact. Allowing , the binary mass-transfer contact equation becomesIt gives a negative transfer rate for .
For the classical nova, assume isotropic re-emission from a binary star: ejecta carry the accretor's specific angular momentum . The eruption lasts many orbital periods, so the orbit responds approximately adiabatically and remains nearly circular; an instantaneous asymmetric kick would be a different model. To first order,Differentiating the circular-binary orbital angular momentum formula during the ejection givesThe accompanying Roche lobe change is thereforeThe donor does not change mass in the eruption and moves inside its expanded Roche lobe: this is nova-induced binary detachment.
Put for the constant external loss. During detachment the component masses are fixed, so the Roche lobe shrinks at fractional rate . Closing the fractional gap takes . During the subsequent semidetached binary phase, the binary mass-transfer contact equation gives , so accumulating the next eruption's mass takes . ConsequentlyBoth times are evaluated to first order in , with the same equilibrium donor mass-radius relation; changes of and the transfer rate within one cycle affect higher orders.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 iii Paper 63 4 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Since the donor fills its Roche lobe, use and substitute its equilibrium mass-radius relation into the lobe approximation:Kepler's third law then givesso the Roche-lobe period-mass relation for a linear donor radius law isThe total binary mass cancels, rather than being assumed equal to the white-dwarf mass.
The orbital radii about the center of mass are and . Summing the two orbital angular momenta givesWith transferred matter retained by the accretor, total mass is fixed. Logarithmic differentiation givesFor , the separation response is . Since at fixed total mass,The second relation uses the supplied equilibrium donor sequence. As the donor loses mass, . If , its Roche lobe shrinks fractionally faster than this donor radius, so the excess filling increases and drives more transfer: it is positive feedback. If , infinitesimal loss instead reduces overfill on that assumed sequence, so some continuing driver is needed to retain contact.
There are two limits to the literal dynamical interpretation. The given initial range is , so is an extrapolated instability test, not a state inside that range. Also, a true dynamical stability of binary mass transfer test needs the donor's adiabatic stellar radius response exponent , rather than its thermal-equilibrium exponent. In general,Thus is the result for the assumed response. A fully convective idealized donor has , giving a dynamical threshold , already below . The equilibrium radius law alone should not be used to assert a universal dynamical threshold.
One continuing driver is magnetic braking of a binary star. A magnetized wind carries away the donor's spin angular momentum; tides that maintain near-synchronous rotation replenish that spin from the orbit, removing orbital angular momentum. With an external , the lobe response becomesEquating this to the donor response proves the binary mass-transfer contact equation in this model:A negative torque therefore drives mass loss while maintaining contact for , subject to the chosen donor response and braking assumptions.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 56 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Let . At Roche-lobe overflow contact, the supplied equilibrium radius relation givesKepler's third law then impliesThus the Roche-lobe period-mass relation for a linear donor radius law isHere and denote the solar radius and solar mass. Cancellation of the total mass is the special Roche-lobe-filling period-density relation combined with .
Between eruptions the conservative binary mass transfer has constant and . Neglecting spin, writeIts logarithmic derivative givesDifferentiating the Roche lobe relation consequently givesFor , the Roche-lobe radius response exponent is . If the donor follows its specified equilibrium radius sequence, . Its logarithmic overflow therefore changes bySince , gives negative feedback in this equilibrium-response model, whereas gives increasing overflow. For , loss of donor mass shrinks its Roche lobe faster than its modeled stellar radius, increasing transfer and hence amplifying the original disturbance. The comparison is a formal extension; the initial system is specified to have .
The word dynamically needs a qualification. Thermal equilibrium specifies , but actual dynamical stability of binary mass transfer depends on the adiabatic stellar radius response exponent , which need not equal one. Stability after a rapid small mass loss requires , because . The equilibrium relation alone does not supply this adiabatic response. As a formal counterexample to deriving a universal dynamical threshold from it, a radius model with a dimensionless entropy label , , can have equilibrium , giving but at fixed . At , , so that model is dynamically stable despite the extrapolated condition. This shows the missing response hypothesis, not a claim that this toy radius law describes the given low-mass star.
A more relevant illustration is an ideal fully convective adiabatic stellar polytrope of index . At fixed entropy its polytropic mass-radius relation is , giving and a dynamical critical ratio under the same Roche lobe approximation. For example, can be unstable dynamically even though the equilibrium comparison has negative feedback. The requested threshold is the intended result with instantaneous response ; it is not a universal dynamical criterion. The subsequent cycle calculation uses the supplied equilibrium sequence and presumes a physically stable, sufficiently slow transfer regime.
Two important angular-momentum-loss mechanisms are gravitational-wave emission from a binary system and magnetic braking of a binary star. Gravitational waves directly remove orbital energy and angular momentum. A magnetized stellar wind removes donor spin angular momentum with a large magnetic lever arm; tidal synchronization replenishes that spin from the orbit, so the net effect is orbital angular-momentum loss. Treating the wind mass loss as small compared with the Roche-transfer flow is consistent with the conservative approximation used here; otherwise the mass and angular-momentum equations must both be modified. Neglecting the stored spin does not eliminate the torque transmitted through it.
Such losses shrink the Roche lobe and offset the donor's tendency to move inside it. Maintaining contact on the equilibrium sequence requires , hence the binary mass-transfer contact equation becomesFor and , this drives and maintains the modeled semi-detached binary.
Now take for the mass expelled from the accretor in one classical nova. The white dwarf loses , while the donor has and the total mass change is . Isotropic ejection in the accretor rest frame supplies no mean kick and carries the accretor's specific orbital angular momentum. Its orbital radius is , soThis is the angular-momentum budget for isotropic re-emission from a binary star, without an additional spin or frictional torque on the ejecta. The general logarithmic change of isUsing gives the first-order nova changesThe donor mass and its assumed equilibrium radius are unchanged during the eruption. It is therefore left inside the enlarged Roche lobe, and Roche-lobe overflow ceases in this sharp-contact model. An extended atmosphere, irradiation-induced donor expansion or additional ejecta torques would require a different treatment.
The stipulated circular orbit is an important idealization. Isotropic loss that is slow compared with the orbital period can preserve circularity. If it is truly impulsive compared with that period, an initially circular point-mass orbit instead acquires eccentricity. With unchanged velocity and position, its new specific orbital energy is and its squared specific angular momentum stays . The Kepler orbit energy and eccentricity relations then give and . The latter still has the same first-order separation increase. The question assumes circularity; its first-order circular budget is consistent with adiabatic orbital mass loss or with subsequent circularization that changes the separation only at second order. Work symbolically with , since the printed numerical layer mass has no explicit unit.
Finally put , constant over both intervals as specified, and let denote their leading-order values over one small cycle. While detached, masses and donor radius are fixed, so . The fractional gap closes afterOnce contact resumes, the contact equation gives . Accumulation of the next layer takesDividing yields the detached-to-semidetached time ratioBoth times are first-order in . Corrections to either time are second-order in that small mass fraction, so the displayed ratio has relative corrections of order . The positive denominator, negligible eruption duration relative to the cycle, fixed donor radius during detachment and common external loss rate are all essential to this idealized nova-induced binary detachment cycle.