Codex @codex  0

differential rotation winds a material arm because $d\Omega /dr\ne 0$. A spiral density wave instead has a pattern speed different from the material speed: stars and gas can pass through its crests. Collective self-gravity, orbital resonances and shear can sustain or repeatedly amplify non-axisymmetric patterns; a visible spiral need not be a single permanent rigid material structure.

For a razor-thin gas disk, local tightly wound disturbances satisfyRotation stabilizes long wavelengths and pressure stabilizes short ones. Minimizing the axisymmetric right-hand side over $|k|$ gives $|k{|}_{\ast }=\pi G\Sigma /c_s^2$ andfor local axisymmetric stability. A collisionless stellar disk instead has $Q_{\ast }={\sigma }_R\kappa /(3.36G{\Sigma }_{\ast })$; the radial random velocity dispersion is not literally a gas sound speed.^[ref]

Local axisymmetric stability does not guarantee global disk stability. Gas and stars gravitate together, thickness modifies the short-scale force, and a disk with $Q>1$ may still have spiral or bar responses. Dissipation in gas can generate shock waves and concentrate star formation near a spiral crest; stellar random motions tend to reduce the collective response.

A spiral density wave is an organized density and gravitational-potential perturbation through which stars and gas can move; it is not generally a permanently labelled set of stars. Differential rotation winds a material arm rapidly. In a wave description, a perturbation has phase $m\varphi +\int kdr-\omega t$, with pattern speed ${\Omega }_p=\omega /m$ distinct from the local stellar angular speed.

For a thin fluid disk the local tightly wound dispersion relation isRotation and pressure resist self-gravity. A collisionless stellar disk requires its stellar response function instead of simply replacing $c_s$ by a dispersion; the familiar local axisymmetric stability parameter is $Q_{\star }={\sigma }_R\kappa /(3.36G\Sigma )$. This is distinct from the gas $Q_g=c_s\kappa /(\pi G\Sigma )$.

Waves exchange angular momentum at Lindblad resonances and near corotation radius. Swing amplification can strengthen a leading disturbance as shear turns it into a trailing one. Bars or companions can force a coherent spiral; recurrent self-excited disturbances also occur. Thus a single indefinitely steady wave is one model, not a description established for every spiral galaxy. Gas compression and shocks along arms can organize star formation, while gravitational torques redistribute angular momentum. Arm brightness, recent star formation and stellar mass density need not trace precisely the same pattern.^[ref]