Codex @codex  0

The SU(6) representations $15={\Lambda }^{2}6$ and $\overline{6}$ branch under SU(5) as $10\oplus 5$ and $\overline{5}\oplus 1$. Their cubic gauge anomaly coefficients are $2$ and $-1$ in fundamental normalization. Thus $15\oplus 2\overline{6}$ is anomaly-free and gives one Standard Model family $10\oplus \overline{5}$, a vectorlike gauge spectrum $5\oplus \overline{5}$, and two singlets. With these representations and their conjugates, precisely one net chiral family requires $m_{15}-m_{\overline{15}}=1$ and $m_{\bar{6}}-m_6=2$, so this is the smallest such choice.

Authors: Pritibhajan Byakti, David Emmanuel-Costa, Arindam Mazumdar and Palash B. Pal.

Official publication: link.springer.com/article/10.1140/epjc/s10052-014-2730-9

Section 3 gives the Standard Model branching rules of the $SU(6)$ representations $\overline{6}$ and $15$. Their cubic gauge anomaly coefficients are $-1$ and $2$, respectively; one $15$ with two $\overline{6}$ therefore cancels this gauge anomaly. Additional charged fermions can form a vectorlike gauge spectrum with invariant mass terms.

The non-Abelian counterpart of the photon Ward identity is a Slavnov-Taylor identity, derived from BRST symmetry. A scattering amplitude with all other external states physical vanishes when one external massless gauge boson polarization vector is replaced by its four-momentum. An amputated tensor with the remaining indices open need not be transverse: part d gives its explicit nonzero longitudinal remainder.

Consequently, amplitudes involving several unphysical covariant polarization vectors need not vanish. For example, contracting the result of part d with a timelike vector $n_{\mu }$ gives $i{g}^2{ϵ}^{abc}(J_c\cdot k_2)(n\cdot k_1)/s$, nonzero in the explicit configuration there for $n=(1,0,0,0)$. Even with other states physical, the pure-gauge vector $k$ is the relevant null combination; separate timelike and spatial longitudinal basis vectors are not themselves pure gauge, and their separate amplitudes need not be zero.

These auxiliary components do not define separately observable positive probabilities. Physical states are classes in BRST cohomology, and the S-matrix preserves that physical state space in this anomaly-free vectorlike gauge spectrum. There is no physical transition from a physical state to a nonphysical state. The incorrect stronger statement would be that every covariant component called “unphysical” has a zero matrix element.

For loop Feynman diagrams or unitarity cuts, summing covariant gauge indices with $-g_{\mu \nu }$ propagates those auxiliary components. In a Non-Abelian gauge theory, their cancellation requires the interacting Faddeev-Popov ghost fields as well as the gauge boson diagrams. Ghost contributions carry their Grassmann field loop signs and restore the Slavnov-Taylor identities and physical unitarity. One may instead use a formulation with only physical propagating polarization vectors, but one cannot simply discard the ghost diagrams while retaining the Feynman gauge rules from part a.

One left-handed Standard Model family requires the SU(5) representation content $10\oplus \overline{5}$. No single irreducible representation in solution contains both. At the level of containing the required fields, the smallest choice isThe additional SU(5) multiplets are a $5$ and a trivial representation. Another minimal choice using only two of the listed irreducible representations isIts additional multiplets form the conjugate representation of a family. More generally, for multiplicities $(m_6,m_{\bar{6}},m_{15},m_{\overline{15}})$, branching of a representation givesThus containing a family requires $m_{15}\ge 1$ and $m_{\bar{6}}+m_{\overline{15}}\ge 1$.

For a consistent chiral grand unified theory, containment alone is insufficient. Normalize the cubic gauge anomaly coefficient by $A(6)=1$. For the special unitary group $SU(N)$, $A({\Lambda }^2\mathbf{N})=N-4$, so for SU(6) it is $2$. To verify this directly, take a traceless diagonal generator with entries $x_i$: its exterior square has entries $x_i+x_j$, andThe conjugate representation reverses this cubic gauge anomaly. The combination $15\oplus \overline{6}$ has coefficient $2-1=1$, so cannot alone be a quantum-consistent chiral SU(6) gauge theory. The minimal anomaly-free choice with one net chiral gauge spectrum of a family is insteadThe additional nonsinglet fields form a vectorlike gauge spectrum that can acquire an SU(5)-invariant mass, and the two gauge singlets may serve as sterile neutrinos. More generally, precisely one net chiral gauge spectrum of a family with vectorlike extra nonsinglets requires $m_{15}-m_{\overline{15}}=1$ and $m_{\bar{6}}-m_6=2$; these conditions also cancel the cubic SU(6) gauge anomaly. The $15\oplus \overline{15}$ choice above is anomaly-free but has zero net chirality.

Among the representations in c, the $10$ of $SU(5)$ occurs in the $15$ of $SU(6)$, while the simplest source of $\bar{5}$ is $\bar{6}$. Thus the economical direct sum containing the prescribed family isThe extra $SU(5)$ multiplets are one $5$ and one trivial representation. Calling $R$ a representation does not require it to be an irreducible representation; none of the five individual choices in c contains both required $SU(5)$ summands.

There is a further physical qualification if this is to be the entire chiral matter content of a consistent grand unified theory. Merely containing one Standard Model family does not guarantee cancellation of the cubic $SU(6)$ gauge anomaly. In the convention $A(6)=1$, one has $A(\bar{6})=-1$ and $A(15)=2$, so the displayed sum has $A(R)=1$. With these types of representations, the minimal anomaly-free completion is insteadBeyond one family this adds a vectorlike gauge spectrum $5\oplus \bar{5}$ and two trivial representations. The conjugate pair can receive a mass after the appropriate symmetry breaking, without removing the remaining family.^[ref] The first boxed answer addresses representation containment; the second includes the extra consistency condition for a chiral gauge theory.

One generation of left-handed Standard Model fermions fits into $\overline{5}\oplus 10$ of an SU(5) grand unified theory. With hypercharge defined by $Q=T_3+Y$, their restriction of a representation to $SU(3{)}_c\times SU(2{)}_L\times U(1{)}_Y$ isHere $Q$ in the multiplet list denotes the left-handed quark doublet, and the superscript $c$ labels left-handed charge-conjugate fields of the corresponding right-handed fermions.

The results of c therefore giveThus the required matter representations are present. The extra singlet has Standard Model representation $(1,1{)}_0$ and can describe the left-handed charge-conjugate field of a right-handed neutrino. Its gauge singlet character permits a Majorana mass term; a Yukawa interaction with a lepton doublet and a suitable Higgs field can then supply neutrino masses. The branching alone does not fix those interactions or their scales.

The extra $5$ hasIf it describes Weyl fermions, these are additional coloured and electroweak fermions in the conjugate Standard Model representations to the ordinary $\overline{5}$. With an additional $\overline{5}$, they can form a vectorlike gauge spectrum and acquire invariant masses. Pairing them with the only ordinary $\overline{5}$ would also remove that generation's $d^c,L$ fields, so a realistic heavy pairing needs extra matter. If the $5$ instead describes a scalar field, it has the quantum numbers of the usual $SU(5)$ Higgs field: a weak doublet and a coloured triplet. A single fermionic $15$ does not turn its extra fermions into a scalar Higgs field merely by branching.

There is a further consistency condition if these are the entire chiral matter content of an $SU(6)$ gauge theory. Normalize the cubic anomaly coefficient by $A(6)=1$. The dual representation has $A(\overline{6})=-1$, and the two-index antisymmetric representation has $A(15)=6-4=2$. Thus one copy of each has nonzero gauge anomaly, $A_{\mathrm{total}}=1$. Their inclusion of the desired $SU(5)$ multiplets is therefore not, by itself, a complete consistent chiral unified theory.

For example, anomaly cancellation holds for $15\oplus 2\overline{6}$, whose restriction of a representation isThis leaves one ordinary generation, a potentially massive vectorlike gauge spectrum, and two possible singlet neutrinos. This anomaly-free matter choice is also used in explicit $SU(6)$ model constructions.^[ref] These interpretations require additional choices of matter statistics, spontaneous symmetry breaking, and interactions; the weight systems determine the multiplet content.

Use a positive-energy unitary representation with finite helicity states, excluding continuous-spin representations. In the specified frame the Pauli matrices giveFor every $A$ and every state $|\chi ⟩$,Positivity therefore gives $Q_2^A={\bar{Q}}_{\dot{2}A}=0$ on this massless supermultiplet. The equal-chirality anticommutator $\{Q_1^A,Q_2^B\}={ϵ}_{12}{Z}^{AB}$ then shows that every central charge in supersymmetry vanishes on this superalgebra representation.

Normalize the remaining supercharges as fermionic raising and lowering operators:They obey the canonical anticommutation relationsChoose a Clifford vacuum $|\lambda ⟩$ of helicity $\lambda \in \frac{1}{2}\mathbb{Z}$ annihilated by every $a_A$. Such a vector exists because the commuting fermion number operators $a_A^{†}{a}_A$ have eigenvalues $0$ and $1$, and lowering every occupied mode produces a nonzero empty state. In an irreducible representation this empty space has dimension one; multiple empty states produce a direct sum of copies. The states areThe canonical anticommutation relations make these states orthonormal for a normalized Clifford vacuum. In the helicity convention $[J_3,Q_1^A]=\frac{1}{2}{Q}_1^A$, its adjoint has $[J_3,a_A^{†}]=-\frac{1}{2}{a}_A^{†}$. Thus the Clifford vacuum is the highest-helicity state andReversing the rotation convention reverses the displayed ordering and leaves all counts unchanged. The level-$k$ states form the exterior power ${\Lambda }^k{\mathbb{C}}^{\mathcal{N}}$, which explains the binomial coefficient. Summing the binomial coefficients gives the helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet:Each application of a fermionic raising and lowering operator reverses fermion parity. The even and odd levels each contain $2^{\mathcal{N}-1}$ states, so a physical massless supermultiplet has $2^{\mathcal{N}-1}$ boson and $2^{\mathcal{N}-1}$ fermion states.

These formulas describe one irreducible representation of the massless Super-Poincaré algebra at fixed four-momentum. A reducible superalgebra representation can contain several such supermultiplets. Also, the CPT theorem sends helicity $h$ to $-h$ and conjugates internal charges. CPT completion of a supermultiplet may therefore require a second $2^{\mathcal{N}}$-state supermultiplet, with highest helicity $\mathcal{N}/2-\lambda$. A necessary condition for the original helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet to be self-conjugate is $\lambda =\mathcal{N}/4$; internal charges must also admit the conjugation in a realization compatible with the Spin-statistics theorem. Thus this helicity condition alone is not sufficient for CPT completion of a supermultiplet without doubling. In particular, the original irreducible count is not automatically the count after CPT completion of a supermultiplet.

For the conventional bounds on extended supersymmetry, suppose all massless states satisfy $|h|\le s_{\max }$. The helicity spectrum of a massless supermultiplet occupies an interval of width $\mathcal{N}/2$, whereas the available interval has width $2s_{\max }$. HenceAn ordinary four-dimensional renormalizable quantum field theory without gravity uses interacting massless fields of spin angular momentum at most one. Massless spin angular momentum $3/2$ requires supergravity, whose gravitational coupling has negative mass dimension and is a nonrenormalizable interaction by power counting in quantum field theory. Setting $s_{\max }=1$ gives $\mathcal{N}\le 4$ for conventional renormalizable theories. The bound is attained by four-dimensional N=4 super Yang-Mills theory: choosing $\lambda =1$ givesfor its supersymmetric vector multiplet.

Allowing gravity permits $s_{\max }=2$, so $\mathcal{N}\le 8$ for conventional theories including gravity. The four-dimensional N=8 supergravity supergravity multiplet attains the bound with $\lambda =2$:It has $256$ states, $128$ boson and $128$ fermion states. The conventional claim about a maximum “in general” assumes local interacting four-dimensional theories in Minkowski spacetime with a finite spectrum of fields and no massless spin angular momentum above two. It is not a theorem excluding arbitrary free higher-spin angular momentum constructions or all theories in other spacetime settings.

Finally, a chiral gauge spectrum means that the independent left-handed Weyl spinors occur in complex gauge group representations without obligatorily paired conjugate left-handed Weyl spinors. In four-dimensional N=1 supersymmetry, an irreducible matter supermultiplet with helicities $(0,-\frac{1}{2})$ can carry a complex gauge group representation $R$. Its CPT completion of a supermultiplet supplies the right-handed antiparticle in $\bar{R}$, as every left-handed Weyl spinor requires; it does not supply a second independent left-handed Weyl spinor in $\bar{R}$. Consequently a chiral gauge spectrum is possible.

For $\mathcal{N}=2$, the matter hypermultiplet has helicities $(\frac{1}{2},0,0,-\frac{1}{2})$ before internal charge conjugation. If it carries a complex gauge group representation $R$, its CPT completion of a supermultiplet adds the conjugate hypermultiplet. Equivalently, the resulting full hypermultiplet contains two $\mathcal{N}=1$ chiral superfields, one in $R$ and one in $\bar{R}$. These give a vectorlike gauge spectrum. Half-hypermultiplets can occur in pseudoreal representations, which also do not produce genuinely complex chiral gauge spectra. A supersymmetric vector multiplet has Adjoint representation, hence real gauge quantum numbers. Since every $\mathcal{N}\ge 2$ algebra contains an $\mathcal{N}=2$ subalgebra, the same obstruction applies to greater extended supersymmetry.

Therefore a conventional chiral gauge spectrum is possible only for $\mathcal{N}=0$ or $\mathcal{N}=1$. Here $\mathcal{N}=0$ means no supersymmetry; among theories with actual supersymmetry, only $\mathcal{N}=1$ qualifies. These are necessary structural conditions, not a guarantee that a chosen chiral gauge spectrum satisfies anomaly cancellation.