Solution
ID: past-exam-of-the-particle-astrophysics-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2016/paper-1/1/solution
Past exam of the particle Astrophysics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 Paper 1 1 Solution by
Codex 0 2026-10-20
The known active neutrinos are too light and too fast to supply the dominant cold dark matter. Their relativistic decoupling leaves substantial free streaming, which erases rather than seeds sufficiently small-scale structure; their allowed mass density is also inadequate for the dominant cold component. Changing a light active neutrino from Dirac to Majorana does not remove those problems. What can change the picture is an enlarged neutral-fermion sector containing sterile states with different masses, production and decay rates. A sufficiently long-lived sterile neutrino in a Majorana state can be a dark-matter candidate; Majorana character alone supplies neither stability nor the correct abundance.
For the spinor calculation, put and define , . Applying the given chiral projectors givesConsequentlywhere the last equality uses . Same-chirality Lorentz scalar products instead vanish: for example . The nonzero overlaps demonstrate the Lorentz scalar structures coupling left and right chirality. For to this is a particle-number-preserving Dirac coupling; for to the charge-conjugate sector it can describe a lepton-number-violating Majorana coupling.
There is a normalization subtlety: both displayed overlaps equal the on-shell mass parameter used to define the spinors. A chiral scalar spinor overlap verifies a coupling structure without fixing an independent Lagrangian coefficient . Repeating the on-shell construction with mass parameter would instead give the corresponding overlap ; this is a different input, rather than a newly derived parameter. The independent coefficients of a Dirac mass term and a Majorana mass term are defined byThe Majorana terms connect a field with its charge conjugate and violate the corresponding continuous lepton phase symmetry by two units. With only unbroken Standard Model gauge symmetry, a left-handed Majorana mass also requires electroweak symmetry breaking or an appropriate higher-dimensional operator; it is not an arbitrary gauge-invariant bare mass for a lepton doublet.
Use an all-left-handed Weyl basis . For real parameters the one-family Dirac-Majorana mass matrix isWriting gives an orthogonal diagonalization, with up to the rotation-sign convention. Massive-particle chirality and helicity are not identical; the familiar left/right helicity language becomes an approximation in the relativistic regime.
The characteristic polynomial isIts roots areFor Majorana fermions the nonnegative physical masses, as explained by physical Majorana mass and signed eigenvalue, are after a possible field rephasing; a negative real eigenvalue is not a negative physical rest mass. When ,The light state is predominantly , while the heavy state is predominantly . Each mass eigenstate combines its Weyl component and charge conjugate to form a Majorana field.
For , the heavy mass is approximately . In the type-I limit ,The seesaw light-mass estimate needs a Dirac scale: no unique numerical light mass follows because the Dirac mass and were not supplied. As an explicitly conditional illustration, choosing and gives ; this is an assumed Dirac scale, not additional exam data or a prediction from alone. A heavy seesaw state is also not automatically stable enough to be dark matter.
The conventional minimal Pati-Salam model gauge group isThe group printed in this paper is different: it contains two factors and only one . This is a discrepancy in the original PDF, not just in the transcription. The standard-model discussion below uses the conventional intended Pati-Salam model model. A literal theory with the printed product would require additional fermion representations and symmetry-breaking data that are not specified.
The Pati-Salam model unifies the three quark color charges with lepton number as a fourth color charge. A family forms left-handed and right-handed multiplets, including a right-handed neutrino. The extended color charge group contains quark-lepton gauge bosons, while the right-handed weak factor supplies right-handed charged currents after symmetry breaking. The Pati-Salam charge embedding isThe original paper explicitly develops the smaller local subgroup , as well as a larger underlying global structure; neither distinction licenses silently replacing the printed group.[ref]
Lepton number as the fourth color by Jogesh Pati and Abdus Salam. §II.B, equation (2), printed p. 276; §II.C, charge assignments
The product group is a quark-lepton unification scheme rather than a simple gauge group with one automatically common coupling. Breaking the right-handed and symmetries can generate a large and light/heavy Majorana neutrinos through the seesaw. The gauge group alone does not uniquely fix their masses or guarantee a dark-matter lifetime.The most important laboratory test of Majorana character is neutrinoless double beta decay,with no outgoing neutrinos. Under light-neutrino exchange, the amplitude involvesThe coherent squared mixing elements allow phase cancellations. A null result constrains this combination within the assumed mechanism, rather than proving that all neutrinos are Dirac.
The observable is a peak in summed electron energy at the decay Q value, unlike the continuous two-neutrino spectrum. Enriched source material, large exposure, good energy resolution, underground operation and radiopure construction suppress backgrounds. germanium arrays use the source as a semiconductor detector; xenon time-projection chambers combine ionization, light and event-position information; bolometers measure deposited energy through a temperature rise. The GERDA collaboration's Phase-I study is a concrete example of an enriched-germanium source-detector search with background suppression.[ref]
Results on neutrinoless double beta decay of 76Ge from GERDA Phase I by the GERDA Collaboration. Abstract and Phase-I source-detector method, arXiv:1307.4720
energy calibration, resolution tails, radon and material backgrounds, cosmic-ray vetoes, signal-like event topology and sideband fits all need independent checks before a Q-value excess is convincing. Collider same-sign dilepton processes can test heavier Majorana states, but require a specified production and decay mechanism. Lepton-number violation, absolute-mass measurements and oscillation data provide complementary information; oscillations alone do not settle Majorana character. New to topics? Read the docs here!
