For , the Euler-Lagrange equation isSince has no explicit dependence, the Beltrami identity givesSolving this first integral, or substituting into the second-order equation, yieldsThe constants satisfy and . There need not be a solution for arbitrary endpoint data, and when there is one these equations can have more than one pair of constants. These are the possible stationary catenoids, so the axisymmetric second variation of a catenoid still matters when deciding whether they minimize surface area.
Raymond E. Goldstein Created 2026-10-13 Updated 2026-11-05
A researcher in physical and mathematical modeling whose team studied the collapse of soap films in the form of a catenoid. Moving the supporting boundaries destabilizes the film; the resulting shape develops conical regions before pinching. Comparing experiments with geometric and fluid-dynamical models reveals which features are controlled by geometry rather than liquid viscosity.[ref]
Geometry of catenoidal soap film collapse induced by boundary deformation by Raymond E. Goldstein and others. Abstract and §II: boundary deformation, transient cones, viscosity comparison and physical models
Soap film between coaxial rings 2026-10-14
Two equal circular rings of radius in parallel planes at provide a boundary for an open film. In the ideal axisymmetric model, a stationary connected film has the catenoid profileThe catenoid existence threshold for equal rings explains why this equation can have two solutions, one solution, or none. The cancellation of principal curvatures holds for both solutions whenever they exist; the mean curvature equation alone does not select a stable minimal surface.
This ideal geometry uses and . The two profiles have different waist radii , although both have . For either profile the surface area follows by integration:At this illustrated separation both profiles have greater surface area than the two disconnected disks, whose total is . This comparison disproves a claim of global area minimization in a class allowing disconnected competitors; it does not determine the sign of the second variation for small variations of a connected film.
A reported experiment used coaxial wire rings of radius , drawn from a surfactant solution and slowly separated until collapse. The solution contained tetradecyltrimethylammonium bromide in deionized water, with glycerol added to vary viscosity. Fluorescein enabled fluorescence imaging under cyan LED arrays; a Phantom V641 camera recorded 4,000 or 5,600 frames per second. Extracted contours gave neck radius, attachment angle, and inferred surface area. They showed neck narrowing and eventual breakup, rather than indefinite persistence of a stationary catenoid. Comparing solutions across viscosities helped distinguish liquid dissipation from the surrounding air's inertia, but the ring displacement beyond the last stable state was not precisely controlled. These are collapse observations, not direct measurements of equilibrium . [ref]
Geometry of catenoidal soap film collapse induced by boundary deformation by Raymond E. Goldstein and others. Geometry of Catenoidal Soap Film Collapse Induced by Boundary Deformation, §II, manuscript pp. 3–4, Figs. 1–3: apparatus, contour readouts, viscosity comparison, and displacement limitation
A proposed classroom measurement would instead hold two equal rings coaxial on a translation stage, leave both sides open to the same gas, and photograph the settled silhouette beside a scale. Fit and inspect fit residuals before inferring cancellation of the principal curvatures. Repeat at several separations and with the camera rotated about the axis to test rotational symmetry. Keep solution composition, ring wetting, and elapsed drainage time comparable, and shield the film from drafts. Film weight, drainage, evaporation, surfactant gradients, and rupture can invalidate the ideal soap film pressure balance. A silhouette fit alone neither measures the pressure jump nor tests all possible perturbations of a stable minimal surface.
Stable minimal surface 2026-10-14
A stable minimal surface has nonnegative second variation of surface area for every admissible normal variation fixing the boundary. For a two-sided minimal surface in three-dimensional Euclidean space, the quadratic form isHere is the gradient for the induced Riemannian metric. The gradient term penalizes rapid changes in the displacement; the principal curvature term can make the second variation negative. A plane has only the nonnegative gradient term. Nonnegativity alone, especially with zero modes, does not prove a strict local minimum or a global minimum.
For a finite catenoid between fixed rings, the answer depends on the ring separation, waist radius, and allowed variations. The axisymmetric second variation of a catenoid tests a specified restricted class. Comparing with two disconnected disks tests a different class of competitors, including a change in topology. Consequently, a stationary catenoid can have greater surface area than two disks without immediately collapsing under every small perturbation.
