Adriana I. Pesci Created 2026-10-13 Updated 2026-11-05
A researcher whose joint work on soap film collapse connects linear stability analysis with visible changes of shape. The team analyzed the loss of stability of a catenoid and the evolving modes that follow boundary deformation. This provides a link between an equilibrium minimal surface and its subsequent collapse dynamics.[ref]
For the catenoid profile spanning fixed-endpoint rings, the second variation of is
This refers to axisymmetric graph variations, not all possible changes in surface topology. Strict positivity for every nonzero admissible variation gives a strict local minimum in the topology: the positive lowest Dirichlet eigenvalue of the regular Sturm-Liouville problem gives coercivity, and sufficiently small coefficient perturbations preserve it. The zero variation must be excluded from a strict-positivity hypothesis.
James D. Shemilt Created 2026-10-13 Updated 2026-11-05
A researcher whose joint study of collapsing soap films in the form of a catenoid compared experiments with sequences of idealized shapes. The analysis predicts a cone angle before final pinching, showing how a tractable geometric construction can explain an observable feature of a more complicated fluid motion.[ref]
The helicoid and catenoid have the same first fundamental form . Therefore matching equal parameter pairs gives a local isometry. The result is local: a full turn changes the height on the helicoid while the angular coordinate on the catenoid repeats. Equal intrinsic lengths do not require the same embedding into Euclidean space.
Mean curvature Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
Mean curvature measures the average signed bending of a smooth surface. Unlike Gaussian curvature, it adds the two principal curvatures rather than multiplying them. A circular cylinder therefore has nonzero mean curvature despite zero Gaussian curvature, whereas a catenoid has zero mean curvature despite negative Gaussian curvature. The cancellation on a catenoid explains how a curved minimal surface can be stationary for surface area.
Choose a unit normal and the shape operator , as in the second fundamental form convention . For a smooth surface in Euclidean space of dimension three, define the signed scalar mean curvature by
Here are the coefficients of the first fundamental form, and those of the second fundamental form. The factor makes an average; the scalar trace convention instead calls the mean curvature. Authors who use reverse both signs. A formula involving mean curvature is therefore incomplete unless its shape operator, unit normal, and averaging convention are specified.
In orientation reversal of surface curvature, both principal curvatures and change sign, while Gaussian curvature and the mean curvature vector do not. The units of mean curvature are inverse length, compared with inverse squared length for Gaussian curvature. The distinction matters in soap film pressure balance: pressure couples to the sum of the signed principal curvatures.
Scale the catenoid by its waist radius and choose a unit normal with outward radial component:
The hyperbolic cosine controls the profile . Direct differentiation yields the first fundamental form and second fundamental form
The coordinate tangent vectors are orthogonal, so the meridional and circumferential principal curvatures are
The opposite principal curvatures cancel at every point, not just at the waist. This is precisely why the catenoid is a minimal surface, while its nonzero second fundamental form and negative Gaussian curvature show that it is not a plane.
For a sphere of radius , its outward unit normal is . Applying the shape operator gives , so the two principal curvatures coincide:
For the lateral surface of a circular cylinder with outward unit normal, moving around a circle turns at rate , while moving along the axis leaves constant. Thus the circumferential and axial principal curvatures give
Here is Gaussian curvature. The circular cylinder bends in only one principal direction, so its mean curvature is half that of the equally sized sphere. These formulas concern the smooth lateral surface, excluding any edges where end caps meet it.
Figure 1.
Signed principal curvatures and their mean on an outward sphere, outward cylinder, and catenoid waist
. Details.
The common length scale is , equal to the radius for the sphere and circular cylinder, and to the waist radius for the catenoid. The mean curvature marker is halfway between the two principal curvature markers. Gaussian curvature has a different unit and is listed separately beneath each panel.
Minimal surface Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
A minimal surface has vanishing mean curvature vector. For a smooth surface in three-dimensional Euclidean space, this means , equivalently . Thus Gaussian curvature is , but neither principal curvature needs to vanish. A plane and a catenoid both satisfy the condition, with very different Gaussian curvatures.
By the first variation of area formula, a minimal surface is a stationary point of surface area for every smooth variation that fixes its boundary, or has compact support in its interior. The word “minimal” specifies this differential equation; it does not guarantee a global minimum of surface area, or even a local minimum. A stable minimal surface imposes a further condition on the second variation.
A catenoid has zero mean curvature, but need not minimize area for its fixed boundary rings. For the profile on , take an endpoint-zero variation . The second variation of the rotational area is
To derive the integral, differentiate twice, then integrate its mixed term by parts; the endpoint term vanishes. To evaluate it, substitute , using the antiderivatives of and . The result is negative because and .
Small positive and negative perturbations remain positive and preserve the boundary values. The first variation vanishes, while the negative second variation gives nearby smaller areas. Thus being a minimal surface in the zero-mean-curvature sense is a stationarity condition, not a guarantee of area minimization for arbitrary boundary separations.
Using the two first fundamental forms calculated below, choose
The surface of revolution is then a catenoid, with metric . On the helicoid, take , assuming so that its parametrization is regular. Substitution gives
Thus the coordinate map
is a local isometry on sufficiently small patches. The constant only changes the radial parametrization of the given helicoid, whose pitch is fixed at one. For the displayed helicoid parametrization is not a regular surface.
Fixed endpoint variations yield the Euler–Lagrange equation
When is independent of , differentiation gives
This is the Beltrami identity. Denote the constant by when nonzero; for a general Lagrangian a zero constant is also possible.
The film area is . Suppressing its harmless positive factor , take . The Euler–Lagrange equation reduces to
The first integral is with . Hence and, using the differential equation without dividing by , . The positive solution obeying that first integral is . Equal endpoint radii force , giving
Thus every smooth positive stationary film in this axisymmetric class is a catenoid.
Put . The boundary equation is . The function tends to infinity at both endpoints of , and
Its minimum occurs when . The function is strictly increasing, with derivative , and has limits and . It therefore has exactly one positive zero . At this point , so . This proves the catenoid existence threshold for equal rings:
At equality there is one stationary solution and above it two. The equation describes candidates for an area minimum, not a guarantee that both branches minimize. The thinner-neck branch is unstable to suitable axisymmetric variations; topology-changing collapse can also compete with connected films. In particular two separate planar disks have area . The derived threshold concerns existence of the smooth annular stationary film; it does not exclude such disconnected competitors.
A minimal surface has , so and . For a nonflat example take the catenoid parametrization . Its first fundamental form has and . Choosing the normal appropriately, its second fundamental form has coefficients , , . Thus its principal curvatures are , proving and .
Along a sufficiently smooth stationary curve, differentiation and the Euler-Lagrange equation give the Beltrami identity:
The cancellation uses the absence of explicit dependence.
For an axisymmetric surface of revolution, its area is . A smooth positive-radius minimizer is stationary, so the Beltrami identity, with the constant factor omitted, gives
Equivalently the Euler-Lagrange equation gives , whence . The first integral selects
Equal radii at imply (subtract the two cosh values), giving
This is a catenoid. The conclusion is a necessary form for a smooth connected minimizer; it does not declare every stationary catenoid a minimum.
Put . The boundary equation is . Its derivative is , so its unique critical point solves . The left side increases strictly from zero to infinity. Thus decreases to a unique minimum and then increases, diverging as and . There are exactly two positive values of when
At equality there is one value, and below it there is none.
To match the printed second variation convention, write ; its is the quadratic coefficient, half the second derivative with respect to . Expanding the area integrand gives
On the catenoid these coefficients are and . Integrate the mixed term by parts; the boundary term is zero because . Since , this yields
This is the axisymmetric second variation of a catenoid, with the explicitly stated quadratic-coefficient convention.
An immersion has differential of rank , equivalently linearly independent . It has isothermal coordinates when its first fundamental form has , . A minimal surface has zero mean curvature.
For an isothermal immersion, differentiation of and gives
and similarly its scalar product with is zero. Its normal component is . The given mean curvature formula reduces to , so
Thus an isothermal immersion is minimal exactly when each coordinate is a harmonic function.
An explicit example is the Enneper surface, parametrized on by
Every coordinate has zero Laplacian. Direct differentiation gives and . Thus it is an isothermal immersion and is minimal everywhere.
It is not an open subset of any of the three listed surfaces. The parameter points and both map to , but their tangent planes differ: while . A plane, catenoid, or helicoid is an embedded smooth surface with a unique tangent plane at each point. If our whole image lay in any one of them, both rank- tangent planes at this point would have to equal its tangent plane, a contradiction.
Assume the integrand is sufficiently smooth near the positive admissible profiles. Define the second variation as , so it is twice the quadratic Taylor coefficient. Differentiation under the integral gives
Integrating the middle term by parts, with , yields
All coefficients are evaluated along .
For the surface-area integrand , the Beltrami identity for a stationary profile reads
Equivalently, its Euler-Lagrange equation is , solved by the positive catenoid profile with . Equal boundary radii at , for , require , so
Direct substitution also verifies the Euler-Lagrange equation. This is a stationary profile whenever a positive satisfying the boundary relation exists; such an does not exist for arbitrary ring separations and radii.
On this profile, with , the coefficients are , and . Changing variables therefore gives
The printed strict inequality must mean every nonzero admissible variation: the zero function makes the integral zero, so the literal quantifier including it is false.
For completeness, the strict positivity here is sufficient for a strict local minimum in the fixed-endpoint topology, among positive axisymmetric graph profiles. On this finite interval the weight has a positive minimum. The regular Sturm-Liouville problem associated with has an attained lowest Dirichlet eigenvalue in the Rayleigh quotient. Its first eigenfunction is a nonzero smooth admissible variation; the assumed strict positivity gives . Hence . Combining this with proves coercivity in the Sobolev space .
The coefficients of the second variation depend continuously on while . For a sufficiently small perturbation, the quadratic forms along the segment from the stationary profile to the perturbed one retain a uniform positive coercivity bound. Taylor's formula with integral remainder, and the vanishing first variation, then gives for nonzero sufficiently small admissible . The stationary area is therefore a strict local minimum under the stated nonzero-variation condition. This supplies the uniform bound needed in an infinite-dimensional problem, rather than relying on pointwise positivity alone in an arbitrary function space.
A regular surface is a minimal surface when its mean curvature vanishes identically, equivalently when its two principal curvatures sum to zero everywhere.
The catenoid
is an example. In part (a), take and , so . The formula there gives
A plane and a circular cylinder have zero Gaussian curvature, as does a flat cone away from its vertex. Because a local isometry preserves Gaussian curvature, the catenoid is minimal and is not locally isometric to any of those surfaces; this is the catenoid is a minimal surface.
The map is an immersion when has rank two, equivalently and are linearly independent. It is isothermal when its first fundamental form has
In general the mean curvature is
The surface is minimal when . In isothermal coordinates the Laplace-Beltrami operator identity is
Thus exactly when each coordinate function is harmonic.
For
the isothermal conditions are
and harmonicity gives
Consequently
and the isothermal equation reduces to
These are all the solutions for which never vanishes. When they parameterize a catenoid, up to translations, reflection and scaling. The limiting cases , , with exactly one of nonzero, parameterize a punctured plane.
With
the coordinate tangent vectors satisfy
Thus the first fundamental form is
Geometrically, is the half of a helicoid with positive radius, winding upwards indefinitely.
Consider the upper half of the catenoid, parametrized as the surface of revolution
It has the same first fundamental form, so defines a local isometry. By the invariance of Gaussian curvature under local isometry, the curvatures agree; directly, the conformal metric above gives
The functional is unbounded above. Let be the positive affine interpolant between the two endpoint values, and choose a smooth nonnegative function that vanishes at the endpoints and is positive somewhere inside. The admissible curves satisfy
The claimed minimum conclusion does not follow and is false in general. A stationary point may have a negative second variation, even though the functional is unbounded above. Here is an explicit example within the allowed positive-graph class.
Take the stationary profile on , and the endpoint-zero variation . For sufficiently small perturbation parameter , remains positive and preserves both endpoint values. Put . Differentiating the area twice and integrating its mixed term by parts gives
This is strictly negative: the first term is less than , while . For example gives and , whose product already exceeds . Thus nearby positive profiles have smaller area. This catenoid is not a local minimum.
The corrected conclusion is that any smooth positive minimizer, if attained, must have the catenoid form. That necessary condition is not sufficient, and existence or stability requires a separate argument.
Figure 1. . Endpoint-preserving positive perturbations of an extended catenoid lower the area; the stationary profile is not a local minimum. Details.
The functional is unbounded above. Let be the positive affine interpolant of the endpoint values and choose a nonnegative, nonzero, continuously differentiable vanishing at both endpoints. The admissible functions satisfy
This excludes a global maximum, but does not prove that a stationary curve is a minimum. The concluding assertion is false without additional conditions.
An explicit counterexample uses , , and the stationary function . Its second variation, for a perturbation vanishing at the endpoints, is
Choose . Since , the positive contribution is at most . On , , so the magnitude of the negative contribution is at least . Thus . Small perturbations in this direction preserve positivity and the endpoint data while decreasing surface area. Consequently this catenoid is not a local minimum. The valid conclusion from part (ii) is a necessary stationary form; minimization requires a separate stability and existence analysis.