Center manifold of the 2024 Cambridge cubic system Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-11-05
Consider the cubic feedback system
At the origin its eigenvalues are . With and , the center subspace is the axis and the two remaining directions are strictly stable. The equations become
The symmetry allows a center manifold graph with odd and even. Write and . The invariance equation for a graph requires and , rather than setting the stable-coordinate derivatives to zero.
The quadratic equation gives ; the cubic equation gives . At fourth order the invariance equation is , so
Substitution into the equation yields
In particular, the quintic coefficient is , which records both the cubic stable graph and the quartic lag in . For , the leading odd term points toward zero on both sides; for it points outward. At the cubic vanishes but the quintic coefficient is one and still points outward. Since the transverse directions are strictly stable, the centre manifold theorem gives local asymptotic stability exactly when .
At the double threshold, . For , , so and every remaining eigenvalue is strictly negative. There is a spectral gap separating this two-dimensional kernel from the stable modes. The centre manifold theorem therefore gives a two-dimensional state centre manifold, with
If the two detuning parameters are adjoined as variables with zero time derivatives, the extended centre manifold has total dimension four; its state fibers still have dimension two.
The only nontrivial spatial symmetry of the bounded interval is the reflection . Since is even and odd, its group action on the amplitudes is . Thus equivariance requires to be even and odd in . There is no sign symmetry , because the quadratic nonlinearity breaks it. The general smooth form is , , with the zero solution preserved. The quadratic even-odd mode interaction follows on truncation:
Writing and , the exact linear growth rates are and . To first order in detuning,
The orthogonal projection of the quadratic term onto the neutral eigenfunctions determines the leading coefficients. Both eigenfunctions have squared norm one, and parity kills the unwanted products. The quadratic correction contributes no term through , since is self-adjoint and the projected modes lie in its kernel. Consequently
These projections are also a concrete way of computing the normal form. In this normalization they give , and , consistent with the stated coefficient ratios.
Put and extend the system by . At the zero equilibrium with zero parameters, the block is the nilpotent matrix , while the eigenvalues are . Since , these are stable. The extended centre manifold is a graph , tangent to the four-dimensional centre space containing the two parameter directions. Its invariance equations are
For the quadratic jets in the ordinary total degree, the coefficient multiplying has no linear part. Hence and . With , comparison gives , , . The second graph is obtained in the same way. Terms involving parameters at quadratic order have zero forcing and vanish. Thus the quadratic centre manifold for a pair of linear filters is
Substitution into the centre equations gives the cubic terms
The last displayed cubic term is absent from the proposed second-order approximation, so its omission needs the weighted scaling rather than an ordinary-degree truncation.
Under the hinted scaling , , , , one has and . The invariance equations at weighted orders two and three give and . In particular no additional parameter-dependent weighted-order-three graph terms appear. Therefore the term and the omitted manifold corrections affect the reduced acceleration only at order , whereas has order and order . After division by , the slow equation is
This proves why the stated approximation retains the leading nonlinear restoring force and its first nonlinear damping correction. The centre manifold theorem removes the exponentially decaying transverse directions, while the retained generic coefficients determine the nearby reduced bifurcations. It is a local asymptotic description, not an exact global reduction. If either relevant coefficient vanishes, higher-order terms may be needed to resolve that degeneracy; the two extreme cases in part (b), with , avoid it.
With , substitute , , . The equations become
The extended centre variables are . The centre manifold theorem gives smooth graph functions with and all first derivatives zero. Their invariance equations are and , after substitution of the graph.
Count as order . Then on the graph, so the left side of the equation contributes only at higher order. Its quadratic terms give , hence . The cubic terms of the equation similarly give . Thus
Terms purely in vanish because the origin remains an equilibrium for every parameter; these expansions describe the weighted scaling , not an unrestricted one-variable Taylor series. Substitution gives the reduced equation
Its cubic coefficient is negative. For the origin is attracting in the centre direction; for it loses stability and two attracting branches emerge with . Therefore the bifurcation is a supercritical pitchfork. These branches agree with the exact Lorenz equilibria , .
The centre manifold theorem says that near an equilibrium of a sufficiently smooth finite-dimensional vector field, there is a locally invariant centre manifold tangent to the generalized eigenspace of eigenvalues with zero real part. It can be represented as a graph over that space, with graph value and derivative zero at the equilibrium; the dynamics on it determine the local centre-direction behaviour. For parameter-dependent systems the parameters may be adjoined as variables with zero derivative, producing an extended centre manifold.
At , the linearization has the block and the independent eigenvalue . Its other eigenvalues are zero and . Hence the equilibrium is nonhyperbolic, the stable subspace has dimension two, and the non-extended centre subspace has dimension one. A centre eigenvector is .
For parameter-dependent centre manifold theorem, append . At the eigenvalues are : the direction is strongly stable and span the extended centre directions. An extended centre manifold for a parameter is an invariant graph of a function tangent to ; nearby trajectories approach its reduced dynamics along stable fibers. The stable eigenvalue remains separated from zero, so local bifurcation and stability are governed by this reduction. This is the parameter-extension content of the requested stable/centre-manifold discussion.
The centre-manifold invariance equation is
Reflection symmetry permits an invariant graph of a function with and . At quadratic order the left side vanishes and the right side is , giving . More explicitly its first mixed coefficient is , found by equating the terms. The reduced equation is
Thus the origin is locally asymptotically stable for , becomes a saddle for , and creates two stable equilibria , . This is a supercritical pitchfork bifurcation. The exact nearby nonzero branches provide a check: the equilibrium equations give
which are real and nonzero for small positive . The omitted branch is not near the origin. At the leading also attracts, although at an algebraic rather than exponential rate.
There are axis equilibria when , and for every . At an axis equilibrium the eigenvalues of the Jacobian matrix are and . Thus a negative axis root is a stable node when and a saddle when . A positive axis root is an unstable node when and a saddle when . Equalities give a zero eigenvalue.
At ,
It is a saddle for . For , it is stable if , unstable if , with real node eigenvalues for and a focus for . At the node-focus transition is not a bifurcation of hyperbolicity when . For , has imaginary eigenvalues when and the linearized system is a centre. For , the candidate local bifurcation values are . When these zero-eigenvalue events coincide at , while the off-axis equilibrium also has zero-real-part imaginary eigenvalues for every .
The centre manifold theorem reduces local dynamics near zero-real-part eigenvalues to an invariant manifold tangent to their eigenspace; transverse directions with nonzero real parts retain their stable or unstable character. For a varying parameter, adjoin and use an extended centre manifold for a parameter.
Take . At near the origin, is an exact extended centre manifold. Its reduced equation is
This is a saddle-node bifurcation: no nearby axis equilibria for , one at zero, and two for . The transverse eigenvalue is positive, so the negative root is a saddle and the positive root an unstable node for small positive .
At , put , , . Then , , . Write the extended centre manifold as . Its invariance equation is . Matching degrees gives
Hence the reduced dynamics are
The exact equilibrium branches are and , crossing at zero and exchanging stability in the centre direction. This is a transcritical bifurcation; the transverse eigenvalue remains positive. For the axis branch is an unstable node and the off-axis branch a saddle; for their roles reverse locally.
When , the two parameter values merge and the origin at has a double zero eigenvalue with nonzero nilpotent linear part. The centre manifold is then two-dimensional, so the preceding one-dimensional classifications cannot simply be reused. Also the off-axis branch has imaginary eigenvalues for every , with identically zero trace: this is not a generic Hopf bifurcation obtained by varying . These degeneracies already follow without computing a new normal form.
The centre manifold theorem gives, near an equilibrium of a sufficiently smooth system, a local invariant manifold tangent to the generalized eigenspaces with zero-real-part eigenvalues, expressible as a graph of a function over them. Its reduced dynamics govern local equilibria and their stability in the presence of strictly stable transverse directions. The manifold need not be unique or analytic; finite Taylor jets can nevertheless be determined from invariance. Treating a parameter as a variable with gives the extended centre manifold for a parameter.
At the linearized block has eigenvalues , and the direction has eigenvalue . Thus the origin is a nonhyperbolic equilibrium, with stable dimension two and non-extended centre dimension one. The extended centre dimension is two. The transformed equations are
The graph of a function satisfies and , with invariance equations and . Symmetry permits odd and even in . Giving weight one and weight two, comparison yields
Here means terms of weighted order at least under the stated scaling. If , the pitchfork bifurcation is supercritical: stable branches appear for as the origin loses stability. If , it is a subcritical pitchfork bifurcation: unstable branches occur for , while the origin is stable there.
For , assign weight four. The leading cubic terms in cancel. The invariance equations now give and : first contributes at weight six and also first contributes there. Substitution then gives
The derivative along the nonzero branches is , so they are unstable. The origin is stable for , unstable for , and nonlinearly unstable at because the leading term is . This is a degenerate subcritical pitchfork bifurcation.
Figure 1.
Bifurcation diagram for the equilibrium branches
. Details.
The centre manifold theorem states that near an equilibrium whose linearization has centre, stable, and unstable spectral subspaces , there is a local invariant manifold tangent to at the equilibrium. It can be written locally as a graph over , and the dynamics on it govern the local nonhyperbolic behaviour. The manifold need not be unique, but its finite Taylor expansion is determined to the required order by the invariance equation.
For a parameter-dependent system, the key step in forming the extended centre manifold is to promote the parameter to a dynamical variable:
The parameter direction then has zero eigenvalue and is included in the extended centre subspace.