Resonance (chemistry)

A single nitrate Lewis structure singles out one N=O connection, yet the three N–O chemical bonds of the isolated symmetric ion are equivalent. Chemical resonance reconciles that symmetry with the integer electron pair allocations of a Lewis structure. The equal chemical bond lengths in nitrate are discussed in The Open University, Discovering chemistry: resonance structures.

Chemical resonance uses several Lewis structures with the same chemical atom connections and total electric charge to describe electronic structure that one allocation cannot fully express. The chemical atoms stay in place; the positions of bond pairs, lone pairs, and formal charges differ between drawings. A two-headed arrow $\leftrightarrow$ connects the drawings and is distinct from a chemical equilibrium arrow $\rightleftharpoons$. See the IUPAC Gold Book, resonance form.

In each nitrate resonance structure, use the existing formal charge convention $\mathrm{FC}=v-n-b/2$:Here $v$ counts neutral-chemical atom valence electrons, $n$ counts nonbonding Electrons, and $b$ counts incident bonding Electrons. The sum is $+1-1-1+0=-1$, agreeing with the nitrate ion's net electric charge. The formal charge rules and their distinction from actual atomic electric charge are given in Flowers et al., Chemistry 2e, 7.4: formal charges and resonance.

Keep one labelled oxygen fixed while reading the three nitrate resonance structures. Its connection is double in one drawing and single in two. Equal weighting within this three-contributor Lewis structure model gives the average bond orderThe same calculation applies to all three N–O connections. Averaging the drawn formal charges similarly gives $-2/3$ per oxygen, while nitrogen retains $+1$; $+1+3(-2/3)=-1$. These fractions summarize the chosen contributors. They are not a measurement of partial atomic charge, a literal fraction of an Electron sitting on an oxygen, or time spent in one drawing.

The resonance hybrid has one spatially continuous electron density extending over the ion. None of its N–O chemical bonds is permanently selected as the double connection of one contributor. The dashed marks above are symbols; Electrons do not travel along them or make the marks float between chemical atoms. For isolated symmetric nitrate, symmetry makes the three N–O chemical bonds equivalent; an environment that distinguishes the oxygen sites can remove that equivalence. The fraction $4/3$ alone predicts neither a chemical bond length nor a dissociation energy. The general relation between multiple chemical bonds, lengths, and strengths is discussed in 7.5 Strengths of Ionic and Covalent Bonds; its tabulated averages are not a nitrate-specific calibration of $4/3$.

Ozone provides a useful two-contributor comparison. Its $3\times 6=18$ valence electrons give three bond pairs and six lone pairs. One resonance structure has a double O–O connection on the left and a single one on the right; the other reverses these allocations while retaining the same chemical atom positions and connections. The central oxygen has one lone pair and formal charge $+1$; the singly connected terminal oxygen has three lone pairs and formal charge $-1$; the doubly connected terminal oxygen has two lone pairs and formal charge zero. Thus $6+12=18$ Electrons and zero net electric charge are conserved. The equal-contributor bond order count is $(2+1)/2=3/2$ for either connection. See MIT 5.111, lecture 10, pp. 4–5: ozone resonance structures.

For carbon dioxide, $\mathrm{O}=\mathrm{C}=\mathrm{O}$ and ${\mathrm{O}}^{-}-\mathrm{C}\equiv {\mathrm{O}}^{+}$ share sixteen valence electrons and the same O–C–O connections. The mirror drawing ${\mathrm{O}}^{+}\equiv \mathrm{C}-{\mathrm{O}}^{-}$ is also possible. The two charge-separated drawings are equivalent to one another for an isolated symmetric carbon dioxide molecule, but neither is equally dominant with $\mathrm{O}=\mathrm{C}=\mathrm{O}$ in the elementary formal charge comparison.

Chemical resonance does not mean that a molecule rapidly flips between drawings, nor that separate molecules at chemical equilibrium carry the individual drawings. The actual electron density belongs to one combined electronic description. In a quantum mechanics treatment, contributors enter a linear combination of many-Electron wavefunctions; a molecular orbital treatment can describe the extended electronic arrangement through molecular orbitals. The drawings alone provide neither a measured density nor numerical weights. Their usefulness is to expose the limitations of one localized allocation without pretending that every algebraically allowed Lewis structure contributes equally.

A resonance structure is one Lewis structure contributing to a chemical resonance description. The contributors retain the same atomic nuclei in the same positions, the same connections, and the same total valence electron count and electric charge; allocations of bond pairs, lone pairs, and formal charges differ. They are alternative representations of one electronic structure, not distinct substances with different atomic arrangements. See Chemistry 2e, 7.4: resonance forms.

A resonance hybrid is the combined electronic description expressed using several resonance structures. The word does not describe a mixture of separate molecules or ions: a nitrate ion has one electron density, rather than three species in chemical equilibrium. Equal weighting is appropriate for the equivalent nitrate contributors in the elementary model; the unequal carbon dioxide contributors illustrate why it is not a general rule. See Chemistry 2e, 7.4: resonance hybrids do not fluctuate between forms.