An algebra homomorphism onto a semisimple Banach algebra is continuous. To see the spectral mechanism, suppose and . For any , choose with and , and set , . Apply the spectral-radius three-circle inequality to . On the outer circle its norm tends uniformly to ; on the circle of radius its spectral radius is bounded by . Hence for every , so . The unit criterion for the Jacobson radical gives , and the closed graph theorem finishes the proof.
On for compact Hausdorff , any complete norm making every point evaluation functional continuous is equivalent to the uniform norm. If converges in the new norm to and uniformly to , evaluation gives for every , so the identity map between the two Banach spaces has closed graph. The closed graph theorem and open mapping theorem make the identity and its inverse bounded. Completeness of the proposed norm is essential to this argument.
Closed-graph proof for a factored operator Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-11-05
Let be Banach spaces, let and be bounded linear operators, and assume is injective and . Then is a well-defined linear operator with closed graph. If and , continuity of both and gives
Injectivity gives . The closed graph theorem therefore makes bounded.[ref]
It is not necessary for to be bounded on its whole range. On , take and . Then is unbounded, but is bounded. The boundedness assumption on is essential to the closed-graph argument; it cannot be omitted from the hypotheses.
Continuity of a positive linear map into a dual space Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-24
Let be a real Banach space and be linear with for every . If and in , positivity of and passage to the limit give
for every real and every . Taking small of either sign forces . Thus the graph of is closed, and the closed graph theorem makes continuous.
Suppose every continuous periodic function has a unique continuous periodic with Fourier coefficients . Uniqueness first makes linear. If and uniformly, continuity of each coefficient functional gives for every fixed , hence . Thus has a closed graph and the closed graph theorem makes it bounded. Applying it to normalized exponentials gives .
For , the bounded functional satisfies . The normalization factor follows from .
A linear functional on a normed vector space is continuous exactly when its kernel is closed. The forward direction follows because zero is closed in the scalar field. Conversely, if , choose with and write . Closedness gives . Since when , . The zero functional is continuous separately. Thus the criterion does not require completeness or the closed graph theorem.
Let be Borel. If for , the closed graph theorem makes the inclusion continuous. Applying its norm bound to indicators of shows that their measures are uniformly bounded, hence .
The graph is closed if it is a closed subset of . Equivalently, and imply .
The closed graph theorem states that an everywhere-defined linear map between Banach spaces is bounded if and only if its graph is closed. Completeness of both spaces is part of the theorem. A bounded map has a closed graph by continuity.
Conversely, if the graph is closed, it is a Banach space in the product norm . The coordinate projection , , is a bounded linear bijection. The open mapping theorem makes bounded. The other coordinate projection is bounded, and is therefore bounded. This proves the theorem from the permitted result.
For each fixed , the coefficient functional is bounded since
Suppose and uniformly. Taking coefficients and passing to the limit gives
for every fixed . No uniform bound on is needed for this passage. Uniqueness gives , so has a closed graph. The space is Banach, being the closed subspace defined by inside the continuous functions with the uniform norm. The closed graph theorem therefore proves is bounded.
A linear operator has closed graph when is closed in . The closed graph theorem states that an everywhere-defined linear operator between Banach spaces is bounded if and only if it has closed graph. Boundedness gives the closed-graph property by continuity. Conversely a closed graph is Banach in the product norm . Projection of the graph onto is a bounded linear bijection, so the open mapping theorem makes its inverse bounded. Composing that inverse with the second-coordinate projection proves is bounded.
For the composition assertion, suppose and . Boundedness of gives , and boundedness of gives . Injectivity of forces . Hence has closed graph and is bounded by the theorem.
For the derivative bound take with norm , and with its supremum norm; both are Banach. Regard as a map into , and let be inclusion. This inclusion is bounded and injective, and is bounded by hypothesis. The preceding result gives a constant with . In particular uniformly in .
(vi) implies (iv) without assuming beforehand that any coordinate functional is continuous. Define the everywhere-defined linear map
The preliminary coordinate bound ensures it really takes values in . Condition (vi) states exactly that its graph is sequentially closed: and in the supremum norm imply . The product is a metric space, so sequentially closed means closed. The closed graph theorem therefore makes bounded. Every coordinate projection on is bounded, hence so is each .
Together with the preceding implications this proves all six conditions are equivalent. No continuity of the coordinate functionals was assumed during the preliminary bounds.
(v) implies (iv). Fix and consider any sequence with . Apply (v) to and . It gives . Thus the graph of is closed. Both spaces are Banach, so the closed graph theorem makes bounded.
It suffices first to treat unital algebras and a unital homomorphism. A surjective homomorphism between unital algebras automatically preserves the identity. If , continuity is immediate. In the nonunital case, extend to the forced unitizations by . This is still surjective and the unitization of a semisimple algebra is semisimple: its radical projects to zero in its scalar quotient, and its remaining intersection with the original algebra is its original radical. Continuity of the extension implies continuity of the original map.
An algebra homomorphism decreases the spectral radius, even without any continuity assumption, because it takes an inverse of to an inverse of . Suppose in and in . Fix any and choose with , . Put
Consider the polynomial . Its value at one is exactly . On the outer circle ,
On the inner circle , spectral-radius decrease gives
Applying part (i) in and then letting , with fixed, gives
This holds for every , so for every .
This forces into the Jacobson radical. To see the criterion directly, if were outside a maximal left ideal , then , so for some , . The equality makes invertible, but this element equals , impossible in a proper left ideal. Hence lies in every maximal left ideal. Since is semisimple, .
We have shown that the separating space of is zero. If and , apply the result to to obtain . Its graph is closed, and the closed graph theorem now proves
The crucial estimate uses part (i) with an exactly fixed central value; it does not assume the false general assertion that the spectral radius is continuous under norm limits.
Put . The hypothesis scales to every residual : if , apply it to and multiply the resulting vector by to obtain an approximate preimage of norm at most with error at most . For , choose zero.
Start with . Inductively choose so that
Then and . Completeness of the Banach space gives . Boundedness of gives
Thus
This geometric correction for approximate surjectivity uses no completeness assumption on : every infinite sum was formed in .
To establish the completeness forced by uniformly bounded lifting, let be a Cauchy sequence in . Choose a subsequence with . Lift to and each difference to with and . The series converges in , and its image under is the limit of the subsequence. The original Cauchy sequence has that same limit, by the triangle inequality. Hence is complete.
The open mapping theorem states that a bounded surjective linear map between Banach spaces is open. In particular, a bounded linear bijection has a bounded inverse. This is the theorem the question permits us to state without proof.
For the closed graph theorem, suppose is everywhere-defined and linear with closed graph . The product norm makes a Banach space, so its closed subspace is complete. Projection , , is a bounded linear bijection. Its inverse is bounded by the open mapping theorem; therefore
It follows that is bounded, proving the closed graph theorem rather than assuming it.
For the final clause, is the separating space of a linear map. It contains zero, and if , and , , then and its image tends to . Thus is a vector subspace. If and , choose one vector from a witnessing sequence for with
Then and , so : it is closed. If is continuous, every defining image limit is zero, hence . Conversely, if and , , then and , so . The graph is sequentially closed and therefore closed in the normed, metrizable product. The proved closed graph theorem now gives continuity. Consequently
The original PDF places in ; the TeX's first reference to a subset of is a transcription error.
First scale the stated unit-ball approximation. For every nonzero residual , apply the hypothesis to and multiply the resulting vector by . This gives with
For zero residual use . Start with , choose by this rule for , and set . Inductively,
The Banach space therefore contains the sum , with
The partial sums satisfy . Boundedness of gives convergence of the left side to , while gives . Thus is surjective with the stated lifting bound. This geometric correction for approximate surjectivity used completeness of , not any unproved completeness of .
Put . Given a Cauchy sequence in , choose a subsequence such that for . Lift each difference to with and . Lift to . The sum exists in , and its image is the limit of the subsequence. A Cauchy sequence with a convergent subsequence converges to the same limit: use the triangle inequality between an arbitrary late term, a later subsequence term, and the limit. This proves is complete, the completeness forced by uniformly bounded lifting principle.
The open mapping theorem states that a bounded surjective linear operator between Banach spaces maps open sets to open sets. In particular a bounded linear bijection between Banach spaces has a bounded inverse. To deduce the closed graph theorem, let be an everywhere-defined linear map between Banach spaces with closed graph. Its graph is a closed subspace of the Banach product , with norm , so it is itself Banach. The projection
is a bounded linear bijection. The open mapping theorem makes its inverse bounded. Composing that inverse with the bounded second projection proves that is bounded. This is the required closed graph conclusion, rather than a continuity assumption on .
Finally consider the identity map . If in the new norm and uniformly, each assumed continuous point evaluation functional gives , while uniform convergence gives . Hence . Since both spaces are metric, this sequential argument proves the graph is closed. Both norms are complete, so the closed graph theorem makes bounded. Its inverse is bounded by the open mapping theorem. Consequently there are constants such that
This proves Banach norm rigidity from continuous point evaluations. Pointwise continuity alone would not give a common bound on all evaluations; completeness supplies that through the closed graph argument.
Regard the set-theoretic inclusion
as a linear map between Banach spaces. Its graph is closed. Indeed, if in and in , part (i) gives an almost-everywhere convergent subsequence for the first convergence and then a further subsequence converging almost everywhere for the second; hence almost everywhere. The closed graph theorem therefore gives
Let . It has finite measure, and . Applying the bound to gives, for finite ,
so . For , it gives . In either case the measures are uniformly bounded. Continuity from below now yields
This proves the converse summarized by Lq inclusion implies finite measure on a Euclidean Borel subset.
For , define by . The map is linear, and
shows , so is continuous. The granted equality is the canonical embedding into the bidual.
Suppose, contrary to the claim, that exactly the same linear functionals are continuous for and . Their common continuous dual has two operator norms, say and . Both dual spaces are Banach, even if the second normed space is not complete. The identity map
has a closed graph: convergence in either operator norm implies pointwise convergence on , so two limits must agree. The closed graph theorem makes the two dual norms equivalent.
Applying the isometric bidual formula for each primal norm then gives constants such that
This says the two norms are equivalent norms, contrary to the hypothesis. Their continuous duals must therefore differ as sets, so a linear functional belonging to one and not the other is continuous for exactly one of the two norms.
Define
The hypothesis makes everywhere defined. The dual is Banach even when is incomplete. If in and in , then coordinatewise convergence gives , so the graph of is closed. The closed graph theorem therefore gives
Taking the supremum over the unit ball proves the required finite bound.
The open mapping theorem states that every surjective bounded linear map between Banach spaces maps open sets to open sets. Equivalently, there is such that
The closed graph theorem states that a linear map between Banach spaces is continuous if and only if its graph
is closed in .
Assume the open mapping theorem and suppose is closed. As a closed subspace of the Banach space , the graph is itself Banach. The coordinate projection
is a bounded linear bijection. By the open mapping theorem, is bounded. The other coordinate projection is bounded, and
Thus is bounded and hence continuous. This is the closed graph theorem from the bounded inverse theorem argument.
Write . We prove that has a closed graph. Suppose
Put and . Then and in .
Fix and . Positivity and linearity give
Because converges in the continuous dual space, its norms are bounded, so
Also , while because the fixed functional is continuous. Passing to the limit yields
for every real . If , a sufficiently small of the opposite sign makes the right-hand side negative. Hence for every , so and .
The graph is therefore closed. The closed graph theorem now proves that is continuous. This is precisely continuity of a positive linear map into a dual space.