Molecular dipole cancellation occurs when nonzero contributions to a molecule's electric dipole moment cancel under vector addition. In a bond dipole model, use ; adding magnitudes instead discards the molecular geometry. A symmetric linear molecule with two equivalent opposed bond dipoles has and , hence zero total electric dipole moment even though each chemical bond is polarized. Carbon dioxide provides the familiar molecular example; water's bent molecular geometry permits a nonzero total.[ref]
Chemistry 2e. §7.6, Figure 7.27 and accompanying paragraphs: cancellation in carbon dioxide, noncancellation in water
For an original geometry calculation, give a fictitious three-site model a central effective electric charge at the origin and two terminal electric charges atHere is the stipulated bond length, the angle between the two connections, and is independent of any electronegativity scale. Equivalently, split the central into two colocated contributions, one for each neutral bond dipole. With , the physical electric dipole moments point from the terminal sites towards the central site:The sideways components cancel; the components along the angle bisector add. Thus . At the result is zero; at the stipulated it is exactly . This is an angle example for a model, not the measured angle or electric dipole moment of water.
Vector addition of physical bond dipoles in a stipulated neutral three-site model: cancellation at , a bisector resultant at
. Central effective electric charge , terminal electric charges , and equal bond lengths . Arrows point from negative to positive electric charge. The lower panels translate the bond dipoles to a common origin and show their components; they are vectors, not electron trajectories or extra bonds. Details.Opposition alone is insufficient: a linear molecule with unequal opposed bond dipoles of magnitudes and retains magnitude . Conversely, symmetry can enforce exact cancellation beyond a particular bond dipole partition. If the complete charge density invariant under point reflection about the origin satisfies , contributions to cancel in pairs. That proof uses the whole electric charge distribution, including lone pairs and atomic nuclei. It explains why molecular symmetry is stronger evidence for zero permanent electric dipole moment than a rule based only on tabulated electronegativity differences.
A permanent molecular electric dipole moment is specified relative to the molecule's orientation. An ensemble with random orientations can have zero mean laboratory vector while each molecule is polar. That orientational average differs from internal molecular dipole cancellation. The Stark effect and molecular beam electric resonance probe molecular electric dipole moments through state-dependent responses to an electric field.
Articles by others on the same topic
There are currently no matching articles.
