The inverse tangent is a homeomorphism from the real line with its Euclidean metric onto with its subspace topology: and its inverse are continuous. It is also an isometry from onto , because . Consequently, for ,
For a direct open ball interpretation, is -open by continuity of . Conversely, continuity of at supplies a sufficiently small -ball inside any prescribed -ball about . Thus both metrics generate exactly the same open sets.
Assume condition (1). For fixed , the supremum
is nondecreasing as increases. Therefore its limit as exists in the extended real numbers and equals . Because , it is at least . Condition (1) says precisely that this limit is .
It follows that for every there is with . Fix and with . Taking produces an open ball on which . Thus is an open set, and its complement
This proves (1) implies (2). The property being characterized is upper semicontinuity.
Assume condition (2). Fix and . The superlevel set
is a closed set and does not contain . Its complement is therefore an open neighbourhood of , so some open ball avoids . Consequently throughout that ball, giving
The same bound holds for every smaller radius. Taking and then yields
Together with the previous implication this proves the equivalence. A supremum may equal even when every individual value is strictly smaller; the non-strict estimate here handles that possibility.
First suppose is a closed set. If , the definition in part (ii) gives an open ball disjoint from . Thus every has , and the distance to a set satisfies . Its contrapositive is the required implication.
Conversely, suppose that zero distance to a set forces membership. For we have . Choose . Then , proving is an open set. Hence
For , use the extended-real convention : both assertions hold, with the implication vacuous. Part (b) only uses nonempty sets, so all its distances to a set are ordinary finite real numbers.
A subset is a closed set in when its complement is an open set in the metric topology. Equivalently,
The open ball is taken inside the ambient metric space ; closedness always depends on that ambient space.
A metric space is a bounded set if there is a finite constant such that
For nonempty , this is equivalent to containment in an open ball of finite radius: the triangle inequality converts a radius bound into a diameter bound, and conversely a diameter bound gives a ball of any slightly larger radius about a chosen point.
It is a complete metric space if every Cauchy sequence in has a limit of a sequence belonging to . Explicitly, the hypothesis on is
and completeness requires an with . Thus
Boundedness controls distances; completeness ensures that these limiting points remain in the space.
Let be any sequence in the compact metric space . There must be an such that every open ball about contains for infinitely many indices . Otherwise, for each choose a ball containing only finitely many terms, counted by indices. These balls are an open cover. A finite subcover would imply that only finitely many indices occur anywhere in , a contradiction.
Now choose successively with ; infinitely many available indices make this possible. Then , so is a convergent subsequence. Thus
The proof counts indices rather than distinct points, so it also handles a value repeated infinitely often.
Construct one infinite binary sequence by concatenating every binary word of length one, then every word of length two, then every word of length three, and so on, in lexicographic order within each length. Every finite binary word occurs somewhere in .
Given any target sequence and any , choose such that . The word occurs in , beginning after some symbols. Thus agrees with in its first positions, and the prescribed metric gives
Every open open ball about every point therefore meets the forward orbit of . This forward orbit is dense in . The argument identifies finite-prefix cylinder sets as arbitrarily small neighborhoods in this metric; no binary-expansion convention for real numbers is needed.
A metric space is a set with a function satisfying , symmetry and the triangle inequality. A subset is open if every has some open open ball contained in .
For finitely many open sets and in their intersection, choose radii with . The positive minimum radius gives a ball contained in the intersection. Thus every finite intersection is open; the empty intersection is , also open.
For distinct points put . The balls and are disjoint: a common point would make by the triangle inequality. This proves the Hausdorff condition.
A singleton is closed because each has a ball of radius avoiding it, making its complement open. Finite unions of closed sets are closed, as their complements are finite intersections of open sets. Hence every finite subset is closed, including the empty subset.
The singleton calculation shows that every map out of is continuous at each point other than : use the domain ball consisting only of that point. Thus global continuity in this metric is equivalent to continuity at , proving .
For every , including , one has . Therefore the open balls centred at are identical for and . The epsilon-delta definitions of continuity at are identical, giving . Hence all three conditions are equivalent.
If , then , so no such lies in the strict open ball. Its centre always does. Hence
Thus every point other than is isolated.
Every point of differs from , so its singleton is an open ball by part (ii). The union of these singleton open sets is . Thus is open whenever .
Every iterate is an isometry of the strip with its Euclidean subspace metric. Let lie in distinct orbits. Since the first-coordinate difference in grows without bound as , the positive distances have a positive minimum . Only finitely many indices can give a distance below any fixed bound, and none gives zero.
Choose . Saturate the relative open balls by setting
These are open saturated neighbourhoods of the two orbits. Any two centres are at least apart, since their distance equals . Their radius- balls therefore cannot intersect. Hence , and part (a)(iv), an instance of positive orbit separation implies a Hausdorff quotient, proves
The distance function is continuous because the triangle inequality gives . Hence is the inverse image of the closed interval , so is closed. Since it contains , it also contains the closure of that open ball:
The induced-metric balls are intersections with the corresponding ambient balls. On the horizontal arm the distance from the centre is ; on the vertical arm it is . Consequently
The closure relative to of the open ball is . Every point with has positive distance from that horizontal arm, so none of those points is in the closure. In particular lies in the closed ball but not in the closure of the open ball, proving strict inclusion.
Let the radius be . One inclusion follows from (a). For the reverse, if , set for . Then and , so every closed-ball point is in the closure of the open ball. Hence
The positive-radius convention matters: if radius zero is allowed, the open ball is empty whereas the closed ball is , so the asserted equality fails at that degenerate radius.
Let be open in the Euclidean topology on the real line, and let . There is an with . The basic open set contains and is contained in . Taking the union of these basic neighbourhoods over shows that . Thus
In fact this is a strictly finer topology: is open in but not in the Euclidean topology, since no usual open ball about is contained in it.
Let and be the quotient maps. The continuous map
is a homeomorphism onto the upper hemisphere; its inverse function is the restriction of the projection map . Every antipodal pair on meets that hemisphere. Moreover, two points of this hemisphere are antipodal only if both lie on the equator. Thus
By the universal property of the quotient topology, induces a continuous bijection
To justify continuity of the inverse function, the source is compact, being a continuous image of a compact space ; the Heine-Borel theorem gives compactness of . The target is Hausdorff, as follows. For distinct equivalence classes , put
In , take the union of the two relative open balls of radius about , and similarly take about . Every distance between their respective centres is at least , so the triangle inequality gives . These open sets contain entire antipodal pairs, hence and similarly for . The quotient topology therefore makes and disjoint open neighbourhoods of the two classes.
Let be the common point of the two circles. For sufficiently small , the open neighbourhood
has the following local structure: consists of four disjoint open arcs, an upper and a lower branch from each circle. These are its four connected components, each open and closed relative to .
Suppose a coordinate chart of some dimension of a manifold existed at . The case would make an isolated point, which it is not. For , shrink the chart inside so that its image is an open ball centred at the image of . Its domain of a function is an open neighbourhood of , so it meets all four arms of . Intersecting those arms with gives four disjoint nonempty clopen sets partitioning ; hence there are at least four connected components.
But a punctured ball in has exactly two connected components, and a punctured ball in for is path-connected. A homeomorphism preserves connected components, giving a contradiction in every dimension of a manifold. Thus is not a topological manifold. The argument uses arbitrarily small coordinate charts; the fact that the whole has two pieces alone would not be a local obstruction.